With the muffs on when I rev it, the volume of water increases dramatically, when I take the muffs off and run it straight from the tank it will overheat and the volume of water never changes. I did a test (not sure if it's a great test) by loosening the thermostat cover and seeing how much water seeped out by revving it up. On muffs it pours out of the thermostat, without muffs it never even leaks. I am guessing the impeller is bad and that is probably how the previous owner destroyed it. My hose has pretty good water pressure, maybe that is why it runs fine on muffs. I think the plugs are covered with fuel, it feels more like premix than water.