Prez Bush talks about Iraq

12Footer

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
8,217
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

The biggest obstruction we have towards a favourable outcome in these dangerous times, is our party wars. The they sit on sperate sides of the isle...One side stands and aplauds. The other sits, and sulks. There are the enevitable rebuttals,and something new this year.. A PREBUTTAL!<br />I am admittedly, a Staunch Republican. But please forget that for the remainder of this post.<br /><br />This little cival war is going to to more damage than anything France or Germany could do to our efforts.<br />We are all Americans, regardless. If you are on the side of freedom and homeland security.<br />If you see no reason to force the issue of Saddam,Iraq,Korea, or other harbingers of global sorrow, then move there.<br />Otherwise, get on board. If Daschle were the commander in chief, and thank allmighty God he is not, I would still follow his lead in these matters. This is mainly because the president is the commander in chief.<br />The military,regardless of branch,must follow his lead, provided he stays within common ethics of human decancy.<br />Now understand, this situation we americans find ourselves in,is the attacks of September 11, 2001,which targetted the citizenry, not just the military.<br />This greatly changes things. It makes every American a potential target. Therefore, every American citizen is a soldier on the front lines!<br />Now, as soldiers,Why not get over our petty self-righteous party wars, get together and get on with the task at hand? How about kicking Sadam's maniacal self back from the stone age, and give Osama one less haven to train in?<br />If not, leave, so we have a fighting chance at establishing a baseline to America's front.
 

ebbtide176

Commander
Joined
Jan 22, 2002
Messages
2,289
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

and you cannot make a termite colony leave your house by laying a rotten log on your doorstep...<br /><br />too generalized? ok. <br /><br />can you lead your lawn to good health by bombing it with weedkiller granules? <br /><br />yes, the weedkiller bomblets will remove the weeds which leads to more grass in their place, which results in a lush lawn. and with added lawn food it will have an end result of great health.<br /><br /> and in short, you cannot develop a trophy fishery by killing fish. <br /><br />(not true)- it is sometimes necessary for fisheries mgmt to kill certain specimens & species, in order to develop the target fishery. {such as the snakehead}<br /> ;)
 

ob

Admiral
Joined
Aug 16, 2002
Messages
6,992
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Ditto to 12footers comments.
 

Reel Appeal

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 19, 2002
Messages
566
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

I think the president gave a great speach and I thank God he is in office in these times of crisis.He has backbone and integrity,which many other politicians in this country severely lack.He also has a heck of alot of serious issues on his plate at the moment.I cannot imagine how "Slick Willy and his wife",my(our)newly appointed Senator :rolleyes: would be dealing with these international issues.If Billy Bob had his nose down to the grind-stone instead of down every skirt and fixin his hair,maybe all this would not be happening. :( <br />Ebb and 12Footer make comments on people making negative comments on the speech.Most media TV news and newspapers(at least where I live) favor the democratic/liberal view with some exceptions.So,when you hear something,consider the source of the comment and to the party commented on.I believe the people protesting the possible war have thier own best interest's(economic or otherwise) in mind and not that of the American people or the security of our country(or our allies).I understand the protest's during Vietnam because we were losing so many fellow Americans,but to protest a war that has not even started?Did anyone notice that alot of the protestors are of draft age?What is it with the Democrats anyway?Are they so afraid to make a positive comment on a Republican president?What is it,embarrassment or party loyalty?I think this is why I've been a Republican all my life.The Democratic politicians act like a herd of sheep and express little individual thinking.So,the people who think the war is un-warranted are also the people who are ok with leaving the likes of Hitler in power.Hussien is a crazy man that cannot be trusted at any time.If you think Iraq is not a threat to the U.S.,you are just waiting for the inevitable(again).Now he has all these wonderful chemicals/toxins/bio-weopons,maybe nukes.Hmm,I wonder if any of that stuff is on the black market.Bin Laden has plenty of money and Sadamm is crazy :eek: .Still don't think Iraq is a threat?Just wanted to clear that up.....
 

BassMan283

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Aug 26, 2002
Messages
277
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Might as well give up,plywoody. The right wingers who lust for war own this forum.
 

12Footer

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
8,217
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Not true.<br />Try many forums, and it will open your eyes...Well, maybee not, but you might find one or two "left wing-owned" forums.<br />There are gobs of liberals on here, and they air thier opinion just as often as the "right wingers".<br /><br />Next thing you'll read on here is a debate on God or no God., and who is more holy? Conservatives or liberals?<br />It's a moderator's nightmare, I'll bet.
 

plywoody

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Messages
685
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Well, Bassman, while I will not belabor the issue, as I doubt all the neo conservatives in this administration follow this board and care what I think, but I will not give up.<br />All of these arguments about what *could* happen if this scenario or that scenario played out can apply to any number of a multitude of nations. Are we to attack them all?<br />And no mention was made in the speech of how exactly are we going to turn Iraq into this Jeffersonian democracy, or how much is that going to cost.<br />And we all stand and cheer at the "Liberation" of Afghanistan mentioned in the speech, and yet no mention of the firefight involving American troops at the very moment of the speech and before. Yes we threw out the Taliban, and that was good, but they have been replaced by the the various warlords of the region, and Alqaida have scattered to the winds. and this is called victory??<br />And we claim to want to solve the NK situation diplomatically, but refuse to meet with them and have talks.<br />I hope that magically all the terrible leaders and regimes in this world see what we do to Saddam, and all throw down their weapons and turn tail and hide somewhere, leaving in their wake budding democratic regimes! That seems to be the assumption. Either that or they stay put and we attack and destroy them one at a time.<br /><br />I think this is very possibly the most dangerous administration ever to occupy the white house, and it is my American patriotic duty to point it out. That not enough listen, if that is the case, I can't do much about. To think what I think, and move away, or stay silent, is a patently un-American response, notwithstanding some of the suggestions on this board.<br /><br />And I really hope the strategy of this administration is successful, and I hope it leads to a more peaceful world and a more secure US of A. I cannot even imagine that, but I suppose miracles are possible.<br /><br />John
 

ebbtide176

Commander
Joined
Jan 22, 2002
Messages
2,289
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

LOL, yep - everyone has a right to their own opinion here.<br /><br />if you polled me on whether i would like to erase the possibility of war ever again- i would say yes. and if we could make everyone in the world delete all weapons period/for eternity- i would agree. and then, if there were any disagreements, it can only be settled by a world-wide consensus - i like it.
 

SCO

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
1,463
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

There you go Bassman. You and Plywoody cant make an argument thats not full of holes because its always based on some type of false premise. We're afraid of war, but sometimes when the hoards are going to firebomb your house, you have to be ready to fight or die. That is what the whole of human history says. If your city is surrounded and the enemy is firing at you, are you going to fight back? You obviously dont think that is the situation here. Therein lies the differences in our opinions. It ought to sober you that our president feels compelled to make this stand and of course I know the obvious sarchastic response so spare us. It ought to wake you up to the vulnerability of your family, community, city , state, country. Far as I can tell, illegal drugs are still readily available. If drugs can be smuggled then...
 

Reel Appeal

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 19, 2002
Messages
566
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Being the offspring of a WWII veteran I can honestly say I have no "lust" for war.My father was an infantry/bazookaman.He has(reluctantly)told me some true stories that made my hair stand on end(and made me sorry I asked).I feel this may be the only alternative though in this situation.On the contrary Plywoody,I'am very open-minded to Democratic views and value thier idea's highly.But,there is a time when common sense must prevail and we must take action before our enemy's do.Considering what the leader of Iraq has done to his own people already,one has to wonder what he would try on his "enemy".I don't want to find out,do you? Take care....<br /><br />PS.My birthday is December 7 ,remember that day?
 

62_Kiwi

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jan 20, 2002
Messages
1,159
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

I'm not a Democrat or a Republican...just a New Zealander who's glad that the people of America have chosen a commander in chief who's prepared to take positive action against the murderous terrorist organisations that exist in our world today. After Saddam there will still be plenty more to deal with, unfortunately.<br /><br />So many of the world's politicans seem happy to bury their heads in the sand and gloss over this major world problem....I imagine that privately they're glad that President Bush is doing the right thing and taking all the heat for it - someone has to...<br /><br />"Give the inspectors more time!"....."Use more diplomacy!"....."But Saddam hasn't attacked us yet!"....."Wait for a UN resolution".... If the situation wasn't so tragic, I'd find these statements very funny.
 

plywoody

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 11, 2002
Messages
685
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

So I am really curious, SCO. Where in any of my arguments are any holes? All of the debate on your side is purely wild speculation. Mine are full of facts.<br /><br />And where in your statements is there any substance at all. I sure could not find any. <br /><br />Tell me- Are we finished in Afghanistan?<br />Tell me- What is the endgame in Iraq, and how do we propose to finish what we start, and how are we going to pay for it when deficits are already spiraling out of control?<br />Tell me-How can we say with a straight face that we can resolve issues diplomatically with NK, when we won't talk to them, and the president has already said they are an evil regime that cannot be trusted.<br /><br />And on and on...<br /><br />And how can anything I said be construed as being "afraid" of war? I am not afraid of war when necessary. I simply do not believe this war is either necessary or will achieve any benefit.
 

SCO

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
1,463
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Well said reel appeal. I think I'm going to drop out of this one because I've said my piece, and you others are getting your points across more effectively. I'm not trying to alieniate you Plywoody or Bassman, but trying to fairly debate. If there are better options to solving our countrys delimas, I and we I think are all ears.
 

SCO

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
1,463
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Plywoody, <br />My last post was made prior to seeing your last post because my computer refreshed when I posted. I will formulate a response soon.
 

Skinnywater

Commander
Joined
Mar 7, 2002
Messages
2,065
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

ebb,<br />"yes, God help us all... like our coins, In God We Trust." <br /><br />I trust God will have the final word. These are vastly different times when mottos and Constitutions were made.<br /><br />ebb,<br />" but me thinks you are more of a democrat than i"<br /><br />But me thinks you are more liberal then I. :p <br /><br />ebb,<br />"i think someone, anyone who can, should remove from power the leaders like hussein, who've provided adequate evidence that they are maintaining power through inflicting pain & suffering on their own people. that's a simple rule to me. taking action/doing it, is not simple. nobody wants to sacrifice bloodshed doing it. "<br />"sure, we're big enough to go slap some evil regimes into playing nice with their people & neighbors. but since we're so big, nobody will mess with us"<br /><br />Undeniably this a noble and righteous effort. However, put Iraq aside for a moment.<br />More then half of the Worlds governments do not come anywhere near our standards or form of government. Is it really the responsibility of all the hardworking, taxpaying US citizens here to slap these governments in line? I think I heard it hinted on before, but am I learning here that you guys really like and want to be the worlds police? In the name of , "new world order", "family of nations" and the United Nations, are you really comfortable that this country take on this role? This is a LIBERAL view and isn't consistent with our Constitution.<br />Don't assume that this means not defending or aggressively attacking your enemies. However, if and when this war is over. Do you really want to go door to door telling other countries they have to conform to our rules? You Imperialists need not answer.<br /><br />62 kiwi,<br />"he sticks to the hard decisions and does what's right"<br /><br />I truly believe he's convinced he's right. I have a lot of respect he's willing to take an enormous hit on his popularity and possibly his second term and still sticking to his guns. Very gutsy to essentially go it alone. And you do know Kiwi that we are essentially doing this on our own. Our allies may have a flag in the theater of operations but US paying for it to be there.<br /><br />plywoody,<br />"I think for those out of a job, or worried about how they are going to pay for prescriptions, or concerned about the falling value of their 401(k), some plan that made some sense about dealing with the economy might have been nice to hear." <br /><br />Here is why you're repeating rhetoric. The economy has more to do with you, me, people like Bill Gates and Alan Greenspan then the executive branch of our government ever did. That goes for Clinton or Bush or ANY other President. While Presidents may might want to take the credit for a good economy don't perpetuate the lie by holding the economy against him. <br />I'll give credit where it's due though. The same nieghsayers of the last round of tax cuts Bush gave me definitely was welcome to my MIDDLE INCOME paycheck. He says he has more of MY money to give back to me. Since all politicians have an acute ability to SPEND like a drunken teenager, I'll take some of mine back first.<br /><br />plywoody,<br />"The stock market has voted this morning, however. Why is it that every time this president speaks, the stock market dives?"<br /><br />Huh? It wouldn't have anything to do with all the untold, countless corrupt business practices that finally abscessed early in this Presidents term?<br />The stock market types made their beds and now are lying in them. They did all that with total disregard of the consequences it did have on our economy. <br />Simply put, between all the very major players in the stock markets who were as CORRUPT as they come AND the attack on 911, with the following Anthrax attacks, and the total defensive posture that was initiated country wide at airports , communities etc., etc.,. It's amazing to me that we are in as good as shape as we are. If we could get the Democrats and the press to keep from wishing the economy get worse, maybe we could get going again this spring.<br /><br />JB,<br />"Red sky at night"<br /><br />Actually JB, you mentioned something that I held onto. It was the only way I'd be able, at that time to justify, in my mind, an Iraq attack.<br />You made the comment that Saddam made efforts to assassinate the previous President Bush. I'd spit in Saddams eye for that.<br /><br />SCO,<br />"There is no nice way for any President to take a stand in the political environment that has evolved here. Seems the left will always be against the Republican President regardless of whether right or wrong. <br />To those that will not stand with our President...how would you protect the American people from where this world is headed?" <br /><br />SCO, don't lay it all on the left. There is plenty that Repulicrat politicians do (it's in their nature) that get the moderate, and the RIGHT against them. As a conservative, the first thing that gets my back up is passing laws out of panic that limit my Constitutional rights. Calling it a "Patriot Act", is rubbing salt in the wound. <br />There was more to his speech. As a conservative I believe that if the government (only)fairly taxed me and gave me the option to invest my money, I'd be fully able to afford my own health care and medicine. Thanks but no thanks President Bush, I do NOT want the government to help me. Again, Bush has been actively GROWING the government, and again the best government is the least government.<br />Now, don't assume I have a hardened heart or I'm a grumpy old man. If the Afrikaners were having a problem with hunger, polio, typhoid or another catastrophe that couldn't be helped, we should help where we can. However, AIDS is preventable through education, NOT drugs. <br />To increase the amount of our money for drugs when education isn't helping is foolish and doesn't even have any common sense. Why should we pay for the drugs to keep the person alive longer to rape and infect more virgins? Sounds like a perfect way to increase the infection rate.<br />The President was pandering away conservative principals.<br /><br />ob,<br />"The entire middle east IMO needs an enema.Try voicing your opinion on their turf.The middle eastern countries leaders are self serving dictators whose people have little to lose.Left wingers are looking for more proof before we impose our might,however, they offer no logical conclusions to perpetual policing.When I see hundreds of citizens on their knees in Pakistan worshiping a model of the mountain where their first nuclear testing was successful,and they are supposed allies,it tends to ring a bell of skepticism for the ones who are not.Nobody likes war and it's not Americas fault that things are the way they are.Diplomacy only works between reasonable minds.Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor."<br /><br />Am I the only guy here that keeps his nose out of his neighbors back yard? If his stink gets to bad I don't have to like him. No more friendly waves. But what right would I have going over and tell him how to live his life. I'd maybe yell accross the fence at him but why trespass while voicing my opinion. ALL POLITICIANS are self serving. And while this country is strong in foundation, its people and military, our country is very weak in diplomacy, it has been for decades. Once Saddam is toast, I mean really long gone. You take a honest look at who will be coveting thy Iraqi oil.<br /><br />SCO,<br />" I am at a loss to why your view requires a conspiracy theory of imperialism, revenge, greed, sagging polls...whatever else and anything else except the danger we face to explain the actions of this administration." <br /><br />Because we aren't all alike. We aren't clones of one another. Different issues effect others differently. It is usually the ones that find it just plain easier to turn a blind eye to hypocrisy. The sources of substantiated truth is at your finger tips, educate yourself if you care to. I know you probably suspect that conspiracy theories may even be partially true, it's just easier to ignore them, pass them off as wacko. <br /> I know that politicians will lie about anything and they will sell mine and your best interests to the highest bidder. Politicians do this best and the best politicians are running the country. You think it's strange not to trust them, I think it equally strange that you do.<br /><br />plywoody,<br />"In short, we cannot lead the world to freedom and democracy by bombing them--we might do it economically and with leadership, but it won't happen with bombs".<br /><br />In the case of Iraq we can bomb them into democracy. We will too. With in five years Iraq will have a leader all voted into place. All the choices the Iraqi's will have to chose from will be hand picked by the US. We are beginning to establish ourselves as the police, judge, jury and rulers of the world. This world will never see peaceful times, it never has and it never will.<br /> <br />12footer,<br />"The biggest obstruction we have towards a favorable outcome in these dangerous times, is our party wars. The they sit on sperate sides of the isle"<br /><br />These are the checks and balances. Gotta have them 12'. I feel your pain though. I've tried for 20 years to vote out my states socialists Senators. It has evolved to the point that the Democrats seem to take the view that they would wish a poor economy or outright failure in all things that we embark on, just to make the Republicans look bad. I really wouldn't expect anything differently from a party that the largest political contributor is the trial lawyers. Hey, Hilary is their own poster child!<br /><br />"I am admittedly, a Staunch Republican"<br /><br />I'm sorry for your bad luck. :p As an American Independent, I'll always hope for a bonafide chance for a Keyes/Buchanan ticket. <br /><br />" If Daschle were the commander in chief"<br />Here, here, still support him lockstep? Hmmm? Come on, tell me. President Tom Daschle has just declared war on Florida because Jeb Bush is still governor. The citizens of Florida have also voted down gun control and 72% taxation. Would you still support your commander in chief President Tom Daschle? <br /><br />Humor me 12', I truly respect what you're saying and I'm right there with you, still wavin' the flag on the street corner. ;) <br /><br />Now, just for the record. I didn't start this thread and the post is long, not because I'm soapboxing but because I'm responding to multiple respondents. <br />I'm still unclear about the rules so I'm still winging it. <br />If I've said something that has offended you, DON"T take it personal. I assure you, I'll do the same.<br /><br />Otherwise thank you gentlemen for taking me away from the TV this evening.
 

SCO

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
1,463
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

I'm back. You ask me for a lot of responses. I asked you for a response in an earlier post and you ignored it. I'll repost my question to you, then answer your questions briefly cause it's late.<br /><br />My prior question to you:Let me boil it down to one question for you: Is it reasonable that the President fears for the safety of the American citizens in an environment post 911, and feels a duty to take on what he perceives to be the most immediate and dangerous threat to our safety, that being the thwarted hoarder of WMD who is practically burning for revenge against those that thwarted him? <br /><br />Now for the short answer to you. The holes in your arguements come from your basic premise that the Presidents motive for war is to get the oil fields. <br />I think you are way, way, way off base. I tune you out right there because your whole platform depends on that cynical view. If you recognized that the Presidents motive was to save our bacon because we are in serious, almost unimaginable danger, you might not think we have the luxury of time or worry about deficit, lifestyle, nation building, fairness, benefit of the doubt and so on. The short basis for my views are the fact of 911, the history of terrorist sctivity directed toward the US, The desperation of the Iraqi dictator, his irrational behaviors and history, his fanaticism for WMD(for now just ask yourself if you think he has them), his probable desire to get even as evidenced by his assination attempt on President Bush 41 and penchant for watching videos of executions of his enemies, the fact that we have borders as porous as swiss cheese to aliens and contraband, and finally the realization that Republicans are decent people . <br /><br />To clear up one thing, I said we're afraid of war, meaning we don't lust for war as expressed by Bassman.
 

SCO

Lieutenant
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
1,463
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

Skinnywater,<br />You generalized on me. It is not my policy to trust politicians. I evaluate it on a case by case basis. In this case I find it an indication of bias that people dont take Pres Bush at his word. If you think his motivation is oil in light of all that has happened which flashes DANGER DANGER, you've got a bias that has led you to an incorrect conclusion. Our job isn't to pick a motive for the President that fits our personal world view, it is to figure out what his motive really is so our conclusions will be valid.In a perfect world you build your world view around the reality, you dont build your reality perception around your world view.
 

mattttt25

Commander
Joined
Sep 29, 2002
Messages
2,661
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

skinny - i'm offended you didn't quote me...<br /><br />12footer - exactly my point, good post...
 

ebbtide176

Commander
Joined
Jan 22, 2002
Messages
2,289
Re: Prez Bush talks about Iraq

well Skinny, you pulled part of my words, and then expl how it is a liberal view. and listed that you are an independant. whatever. maybe i should call myself an independant - or do you have to take a side? i doubt i would be a liberal, and i know i feel more inclined to agree with conservative ideals. so what? i tend to just try to learn more of politics when i can, but i don't try to pay homage to a certain camp.<br /><br />it seems with your story about a neighbor that stinks that you would just be willing to let whatever may happen around you happen, as long as it doesn't hurt you personally. thats what i felt came from that story anyway. fine, i don't feel that way. <br /><br />since i could really use more knowledge of the details of our constitution, and finer points of what views have nuances of the various liberal/conserv or demo/repub patterns, i can only heed your advice. for now.<br /><br />so - what did you think of the speech?<br /><br />PS ;) since you seem to enjoy being taken away from the tv, in order to properly educate us all, please help me with this thought (and it might be elementary, so be somewhat nice):<br /><br />does our constitution direct us to only concern ourselves with our country? does it give direction on how to deal with being involved in a union of nations, and what limits of responsibility we have to other countries?<br /><br />i only ask this because it seems many people think we are only able to take action against another country when under attack, as per our constitution.
 
Top