Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

1730V

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 14, 2004
Messages
563
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

jtexas<br /><br />You bet I was being sarcastic. :) <br />You are correct about the use of the term Allah.<br />I will bet some non thinking Christian bashers would fall for it though and think they got one over. ;) <br />Explanation in advance. Not all Christian bashers are non thinking.
 

12Footer

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
8,217
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

And to think, I assumed we understood each other's religous beliefs!<br /><br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> <br />THIS is exactly what you said: <br />----------------------------------------------------------<br />"I'm a little sick of this thread too, yet,I feel compelled to set the record straight,due to the damage caused by someone being misled (lied to) by the wrong "expert", as it pretains to Christianity, every other time I read another<br />post here."<br />----------------------------------------------------------<br />happy now? Just like I quoted it before. See the part where you say "lied to"? That would imply that someone is a "liar". And I never said that those were your views of non-christians, but that those who hold negative views of Christianity have been misled or lied to. That is almost exaclty what you said<br /><br />
<br />It would appear you really,really want this thread to stay derailed on my particular faith in God and his son,Jesus Christ. Whatever. I have no clue what you are twisting-into that quote, but it should be self-explanitory to you. You seem like an otherwise very bright person. <br />The quote above, in no way calls you a liar, but the shoe does seem to fit,now that you regurgitate it all. I AM getting a little tired of your continued attempts at DECEPTION (It is misleading) It would qualify you as a "liar", even tho I never called you a liar..I realise it was probably not your intent to decieve, but I'm just pointing-out the facts as I see them. The misled-to-liar connection was YOUR OWN. And I do point to deciet with your continued attempts to blame Christianity for the majority of the ills in public school, and with this government. Let me try one more time here;<br />I don't pretend to be an expert on all things Christian.But your posts would also indicate you are far from an expert on the subject. So when it comes to Christianity, I'll stick to what I know and love. I hope you are doing the same. <br /><br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /><br />And now you are calling ME a liar! with no reference of course to what exactly I've lied about...<br />
<br />Where? I again inform you,I never made such a connection until you pointed it out to me that thru your efforts to mislead and decieve, (by decieve or mislead, your posts center upon {, Christians are trying to take over the public school system, wanting to erradicate non-Christians,such rot as that}). <br /><br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> <br />Funny that you're getting so worked up. never in this entire thread have I disagreed with you about the fact that the declaration of independence belongs in school. Not once!
<br />This prooves that your intent is not to debate the opriginal subject of this thread, but to mislead by redirecting the debate to Christianity,and in particular, Christianity with Happy (yes, I am happy) Christians here on iboats, who you perceive, are trying to take-over the schools or control the government.In other words,I cite the following;(your words)<br /><br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> <br />However, since you christians are comprised of the same kind of fallible humans as the rest of us un-saved masses, it should be obvious that I don't want fallible and politically motivated and imperfect HUMAN christians deciding that certain select parts of their faith be foisted off on the rest of us, by coercion through the law, or by evangelizing to a captive audience of schoolchildren. That needn't "rip away" your rights to worship and believe how you please,<br />UNLESS what you please is to write your religion into law.To me and many others, that starts to tread into the territory of a government sponsored religion, which the constitution does proscribe against.
<br /><br />You stated in the very paragraph above THIS one;<br />"Funny that you're getting so worked up. never in this entire thread have I disagreed with you about the fact that the declaration of independence belongs in school. Not once!"<br />And yet,----"since you christians are comprised of the same kind of fallible humans as the rest of us un-saved masses, it should be obvious that I don't want fallible and politically motivated and imperfect HUMAN christians deciding that certain select parts of their faith be foisted off on the rest of us, by coercion through the law, or by evangelizing to a captive audience of schoolchildren".-----<br /><br /> Which is it ?Include Christians, or erradicate Christians?<br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> THAT is what I am against. And I gather from talking to many self -described christians that THAT is exactly what many of them would love to do. And all your riled up "bilge" hasn't convinced me one bit that you would not join in such an effort if it were to come to that.
<br />And again,THIS is what deciet would be. How many have done that? Pat Robertson? I agree, he is out there! And so was Jim Jones with the koolaid. There are an extremely small percentage of "smokers" in Christian society, just as in all walks of life. But if those guys define Christianity to you, you have been SORELY misled! The country crawls with mentally-unstable people, Mark. Christianity does not have the market cornered there by a long shot. Even the former "Black Panther" leader, Jessie Jackson calls himself "reverand",but never spent one day in seminary training, (until much later in life, and then, only to silence real Christians from pointing this fact out). Most REAL Christian teachers (IE pastors,priests,men-of-cloth,"reverends") went to Christian colleges, to learn from whence they speak first, before being assigned a church,But ANYONE can build a "church", or call themself, "Reverend".<br />You seem very interested in the entire subject Christianity, as it pertains to organised religion. Keep in mind that every sect,cult,faith,writing,study,religion is populated and conducted by humans, All of which are not only capable of sin, but are pretty good at it. The only difference between you and I, is I talk to my creator daily, and I pray to God thru Jesus, like the book I study has taught me. But NOBODY needs that book, Mark, to talk to God. I would sugjest you keep with that healthy interest, and work with it.I have no desire to wipe non-Christians off the face of the Earth like some sick,modern version of the "Crusades". I am no different from any other person, in that I do not want to be persicuted, or removed to a concentration camp ,where I can't influence anyone, have my history re-written to delete references to God, ect.<br />I will try to prevent that with my life. It hasn't happened yet, but just do a search thru our recent Christian history,(about the last 35years or so), of how life for the common Christian has changed here in America, and around the globe. It should set-off alarms in your head in short order! We are not that far removed from Stalin's purges as our freedoms would have us believe.
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Read further, 1730V.<br /><br />What was banned was an exerpt from the DofI, along with selected exerpts from several other documents.<br /><br />What was banned was this particular teacher's use of them to promote a forbidden evangelical agenda.<br /><br />Do you wonder why this teacher was singled out? I don't. I have run schools, though not public elementary schools, and the evangelical spirit of a few teachers is a constant problem for administrators, along with those with political agendas. I have had to fire more than one.<br /><br />As the truth behind this exaggerated gossip surfaces, if the media allows it to surface, you will see why the teacher needed to be fired.<br /><br />I repeat. The Declaration of Independence was not and is not banned from the school. Use of exerpts to promote a forbidden agenda was banned.<br /><br />This whole thing is a "police brutality cancels out my wrongdoing" smokescreen.
 

woodrat

Ensign
Joined
Jul 27, 2004
Messages
949
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Originally posted by 12Footer:<br /><br /><br />The quote above, in no way calls you a liar, but the shoe does seem to fit,now that you regurgitate it all. I AM getting a little tired of your continued attempts at DECEPTION (It is misleading) It would qualify you as a "liar", even tho I never called you a liar..I realise it was probably not your intent to decieve, but I'm just pointing-out the facts as I see them. The misled-to-liar connection was YOUR OWN. And I do point to deciet with your continued attempts to blame Christianity for the majority of the ills in public school, and with this government.
<br /><br />right here:<br /><br />" If you plan to quote me, quote ME. don'r decieve on top of lies."<br /><br />is where you seem to call me a liar. As to the misled-to-liar connection, you were the one to put the two together here:<br /><br />"I feel compelled to set the record straight,due to the damage caused by someone being misled (lied to) by the wrong "expert", as it pretains to Christianity, every other time I read another post here. <br /><br />I have not blamed christianity for the majority of the ills in the public school system EVER. I'm not even an ADVOCATE of public schools. I don't trust them for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with christianity.<br /><br />You seem to think that I fit into some pattern of some imaginary "godless socialist" enemy of america, so you continue to attribute all manner of claptrap to me which I have never said. <br /><br />I am not decieving anyone by intent or accident. I am merely stating my opinions on this subject, and relating some of my own experiences. What's to deceive? Is christianity somehow threatened by me stating that I've met a lot more arrogant hypocrites who say that they are christian than not? Its simply a fact! Maybe I'm getting a poor sampling, I don't know, but I continue to hear stories every day that make me wonder where these nuts get the idea that they are living christ's values. I never even got around to mentioning the so-called "pro-lifers" who condoned, encouraged and carried out the sniper murders of abortion doctors. They were all god's followers too, if you asked them, and they were just enforcing god's law "thou shalt not kill." So its not such a great leap to imagine that many christians might embrace other radical measures to enforce other biblical tenets if they managed to embrace murder to prove that killing is wrong.<br /><br /> Its really not such a stretch either, to imagine that a teacher might use his position to inappropriately promote his faith.<br /><br /><br /><br />
You stated in the very paragraph above THIS one;<br />"Funny that you're getting so worked up. never in this entire thread have I disagreed with you about the fact that the declaration of independence belongs in school. Not once!"<br />And yet,----"since you christians are comprised of the same kind of fallible humans as the rest of us un-saved masses, it should be obvious that I don't want fallible and politically motivated and imperfect HUMAN christians deciding that certain select parts of their faith be foisted off on the rest of us, by coercion through the law, or by evangelizing to a captive audience of schoolchildren".-----<br /><br /> Which is it ?Include Christians, or erradicate Christians?<br />
<br /><br />huh? telling christians that they can't use the school system or the arms of government to promote their faith eradicates them?!<br /><br />
<br /> The only difference between you and I, is I talk to my creator daily, and I pray to God thru Jesus, like the book I study has taught me. But NOBODY needs that book, Mark, to talk to God..
<br /><br />I already know this. It is heartening that you seem to know this. Many, many christians do NOT seem to know this.<br /><br />
<br />I am no different from any other person, in that I do not want to be persicuted, or removed to a concentration camp ,where I can't influence anyone, have my history re-written to delete references to God, ect.
<br /><br />...and neither do I want to live in a concentration camp. We both seem to suspect that each others' side is willing to do this to us. I acknowledge that there have been plenty of bizarre so-called "liberal" overreaches and fanaticism that would contribute to your paranoia about it, I just don't have anything to do with them myself. I also know for a fact that there has been much in the christian cultural landscape during my lifetime that would cause me to be concerned and paranoid about the christians wanting to write the laws and enforce them to their specifications as well. Whether you have anything to do with that I don't know. <br /><br />For the sake of everybody's sanity, i will quit my part of this argument and let this worn-thin thread die if it is inclined to.
 

AK_Chappy

Lieutenant
Joined
May 25, 2003
Messages
1,357
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> For the sake of everybody's sanity, i will quit my part of this argument and let this worn-thin thread die if it is inclined to.
Wow,<br />can't everyone elso too?<br /><br />short ending<br />D of I is not banned from school.<br /><br />AK Chappy
 

12Footer

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
8,217
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Orignally posted by AK:<br />Wow,<br />can't everyone elso too?<br /><br />short ending<br />D of I is not banned from school.<br /><br />AK Chappy<br />
<br />Short ending, that's all I care about. As for the issue, this round is over,and I feel we win. All Americans win.<br /><br />This thread will not die,because INDIVIDUALLY,we ALL love our children, we love our country, and we keep our faith, whatever that happens to be. When any ONE of those seem threatened , many of us get extremely defensive.<br />Add all three to the fire, and it feeds itself.<br /><br />Ham radio operators spend hours talking to each other about all manner of subjects, but they avoid these topics (relating to religion or politics) like tha plaque,for much the same reasons.<br /><br />
Originally posted by woodrat:<br /> For the sake of everybody's sanity, i will quit my part of this argument and let this worn-thin thread die if it is inclined to.
<br /> I've made all the points I wanted to make ,more times than I cared to make them. But I look forawrd to these debates with you all, and see them only as such. Even those with you,Mark.<br />Peace.
 

wilkin250r

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Messages
570
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Originally posted by jtexas:<br /> <br />from page 6:<br />"Mr. Williams intended to distribute these handouts to explain 1) the role of religion at the nation's founding; 2) the religious references in several founding documents including the Declaration of Independence; and 3) the reasons for the Establishment Clause in the First Amendment."<br /><br />
Sure, it seems innocent enough, at first glance. He's teaching history, so along with actual events, he is also going to teach historical context.<br /><br />But why is it so important that he highlight religious involvement? Perhaps he DOES have a hidden agenda. We have seen in this very thread that people believe the future of our nation will crumble without a firm, Christian faith. While I will not hold a grudge to anybody with this belief, I will not tolerate anybody preaching it inside a public classroom. Such matters belong at home and in church, not in school.<br /><br />If this teacher was specifically focusing his topics on religion, I think it's entirely possible that he was taking it too far. Of course, he is not going to say that he was preaching in his own lawsuit, but he won't be able to hide the fact that religion was the topic of discussion, so the "role of religion" is an easy scapegoat.<br /><br />Me personally, I don't have a problem with an educator teaching religious context, as long as it is done at an appropriate age, and I don't think that age is 5th grade.
 

Whaler Proud

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Feb 23, 2003
Messages
187
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Here is what I have learned about Christianity:<br /><br />Before I was a Christian, no Christian would have convinced me I needed to be one, would ever want to be one, would ever be one, not in a million years. I could twist the mind of any evangelical that came down my path and leave them questioning the validity of their faith.<br /><br />The day I asked forgiveness for my sins against God I learned that; I would never be able to convince a non-Christian that they needed to be one, would ever want to be one, will ever be one, not in a million years. <br /><br />And while I have yet to experience a non-Christian who can make me question my faith, I have seen the result of me accepting them for who they are, praying for their salvation, and leaving the "saving" to the One who saved me. And my "non-Christian" friends are some of the most loyal and moral people I know. Most are better people than I have met at church. Jesus set the example by hanging out with sinners and rejecting the self-righteous church leaders.<br /><br />If God wants the bible taught in public school, it is going to happen. For me and my house, I would rather they stick to facts, present history truthfully, and leave the evangelizing to me. <br /><br />And I have read the biography of John Adams, and the comments made about his writing and faith in the link provided above, are taken way out of context and used to support the opinion of the writer. <br /><br />Love ya' all! <br /><br /> :)
 

wilkin250r

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Messages
570
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

On a tangent, I have to side with woodrat on his issues and experiences.<br /><br />We all hear bad news, and we reflect on the state and morals of our society, but how much have you actually SEEN? (outside of law enforcement personnel). Therefore, I shall limit my discussion to only events and people I have personally witnessed.<br /><br />Let me tell you what I have personally witnessed. I have seen more ugliness, bigotry, and hypocrisy inside the church than I EVER have outside of it, by at least three-fold. I have seen so much hatred in the name of christianity that I hesitate to call myself a "Christian" because I do not want my person to be associated with that hatred and bigotry. <br /><br />All of this has not shaken my personal faith in God and my relationship with Him, but it has certainly shaken my faith in my fellow man, and my faith in the church. I am very strong in my faith, and my morals on conduct reflect that. And I am sure that there are many decent, honest christians out there. However, my personal experience is the very reason I have not set foot in any church (aside from funerals) for many years.
 

mikeandronda

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 13, 2003
Messages
1,888
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Wilkin did you ever think that if the Christians such as you took a stronger stance on how they felt........a public stance and stood against those who profess to being Christians with thier mouths and yet do the opposite with thier actions there would be less people out here that have feelings such as woodrat does. His view is distorted when it comes to Christianity but saddly his view does resemble many churches. I for one have felt the sting of being put down by a church for standing against what I saw as an injustice being done in the name of God, but I will never believe that it was a Christian type of thinking that caused these people to hurt others.....it was a human issue, but I, even though I and my family was hurt by this church and really pushed to the side, will never believe it was Christianity that was the problem it was just one Church and its misguided people that was the problem.
 

wilkin250r

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Messages
570
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

mikeandronda, you are correct, I'm certainly not putting forth much effort to correct the problem. But I pick and choose my battles carefully, and this isn't a battle I'm willing to fight. I have much more important things in my personal life to concentrate my efforts on.
 

mattttt25

Commander
Joined
Sep 29, 2002
Messages
2,661
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

anyone catch abc news last night? they ran a story on a church that is running a tv ad. the ad tries to show how they welcome everyone (all races, gays, etc). outside this "other" church, they have bouncers, who tell people of different races and that are gay, that they cannot enter. from the parts they showed, it looked like a good ad, and brings up my biggest beef with most christian churches (my own catholic church in particular).<br /><br />anyway, the news clip was more about how abc, their own network, had banned the ad. they said too many execs were afraid of "the strong conservative rights that are taking over this country", and how they would react to the ad.
 

mikeandronda

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 13, 2003
Messages
1,888
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Well more churches need to invite everybody........Christ did......he invited everybody into Christianity. Gods hates sin not people......those Christians who hate because someone is Gay or whatever are just as guilty of sin and in truth could be farther away from God then the Gay person. It angers me to no end when someone condems somebody else in the name of God,....... only God can and will do that but it wont be for your sins it will be for not repenting and recieving Christ who cleanses us of our sins. Its religion that scares people from Christianity. God wants a relationship not a ritual and too many churches teach ritual religion. Sad really. :(
 

1730V

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 14, 2004
Messages
563
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

One has to remember that people are making these statements and decisions. Last time I checked Christians, buddhists, muslims, athiests and humanists are all people. People are full of sin. <br />True Christ invited everyone. Christ was God on earth. He was without sin. As in most religious beliefs Christianity is a journey. Everyone is at a different place on that journey. The actions of some should not paint a picture for an entire belief system. People are people.
 

Boomyal

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Aug 16, 2003
Messages
12,072
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

...but herein lies the rub, the part that too many are unwilling to accept, the part that the 'anti-Christians' use to bash Christianity. "Inviting everyone" only goes so far, Biblically speaking.<br /><br />True, Christ invited everybody, but what do you think he invited them to, a big happy anything goes party? Nooooooo!<br /><br />He invited them to believe on Him and to change their sinful ways (well defined) as a way to Everlasting Life. That's the rub. The anti-Christians think they should be allowed to have their cake and eat it too. When told that that is not the way Christianity works, well then Christians are nothing but bigots, homophobes and hypocrites.
 

Boomyal

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Aug 16, 2003
Messages
12,072
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

oops!
 

1730V

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Feb 14, 2004
Messages
563
Re: Declaration of Independence banned from ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?!!?!?

Boomyal<br />If I read your response correctly I think I agree. Anything goes as long as it is not Christian?<br />This country was based on freedom. When one faction denies the freedoms of others it becomes tyranny. Tyranny has a nasty habit of sneaking up on people. <br />Then we get into what freedom is? We Christians have a set of rules we try to live by. We are not perfect yet we have set goals to strive for. Everyone has our playbook at their disposal yet we cannot see theirs. That is frustrating to say the least. Some would say and gladly so that we are doomed.
 
Top