So should I go with a 10" or 11" pitch?
I checked the prop again and the diameter is actually 12 1/4", not 11 3/4" as I earlier stated. Does diameter have a big effect?
Thanks in advance.
no...you are overpropped as stated.
to increase rpm you reduce pitch, or diameter, or # of blades.
yes, diameter plays as much a role as pitch.
So, you go to an 11x8....or 11 1/4x8...maybe get 5600-5700 max rpm, maybe more...might be less...
see what happens.....but you want to be no less than 5500@max throttle...
propping a boat is not exact science. and can get expensive...