Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
1978 115hp Johnson on a Glastron. Unfamiliar with boats but do car/engine/trans stuff all the time.

Very light pressure from two fingers will stop the shaft from spinning even as the motor is turned by hand. No noises.
*I assume this is a problem and the prop shaft should be direct connected to the engine?

In forward, reverse, neutral, the prop spins freely by hand in either direction (engine off). Spins easier in neutral, FWD and REV have some resistance but easily spins.

I searched but couldn't see where to diagnose past the prop which everyone mentions.

Engine runs fine but prop doesn't spin in any gear that I can see...if it's spinning (i only started it in the water which was dark and turbulent) the boat doesn't move.

Was running fine and then sputtered once, then completely went out about 500 yards later, nothing.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

Turning the propeller easily by hand in neutral = normal.

Turning the propeller when in gear and encountering just a slight bit more resistance = Broken/sheared driveshaft, usually just below the water pump.
 

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

Turning the propeller when in gear and encountering just a slight bit more resistance = Broken/sheared driveshaft, usually just below the water pump.

great, so drop the lower unit and that will likely show the issue?

what makes you say the driveshaft and not the prop shaft?
 

82rude

Rear Admiral
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
4,082
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

driveshaft is usually made of lighter material than the propshaft.it is not really that uncommon to shear a driveshaft under certain conditions.
 

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

driveshaft is usually made of lighter material than the propshaft.it is not really that uncommon to shear a driveshaft under certain conditions.

thanks. so drop the lower unit to get to it?

i'll get the repair manual - any special tools?

i imagine i should replace all seals.
what about bearings, water pump, anything else while i'm in there?
 

Pessemist

Seaman
Joined
Sep 14, 2002
Messages
61
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

thanks. so drop the lower unit to get to it?

i'll get the repair manual - any special tools?

i imagine i should replace all seals.
what about bearings, water pump, anything else while i'm in there?

I've done this. These units are incredibly intolerant to out of spec work. If not done eprfectly it will fail fairly quickly.

Some take special tools. and you must follow the steps EXACTLY checking torques, rolling torques etc exactly as specified.

There are some after market manufacturers that are cheaper for a whole new lower unit than the parts to fix one. Not sure if your unit is available. But you might check around.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

Broken drive shafts usually happen because the gearcase or exhaust housing is bent. But few people go through the extra work to check them, and just slap in a new shaft. May be fine, and may break another one. Feeling lucky??
 

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

Broken drive shafts usually happen because the gearcase or exhaust housing is bent. But few people go through the extra work to check them, and just slap in a new shaft. May be fine, and may break another one. Feeling lucky??
old motors are still a "usually"?
do they fail due to age, not changing oil...etc?
is there a difference in failure mode between one caused by a bent gearcase/exhaust verses something else?
how to test?
anyone know how to do this - or point to information online?
 

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

thanks - i'll check some lower units and compare to pricing.
thanks for the notes - i have the repair manual and will follow it.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

Well, maybe I should change "usually" to "often". And yes, age matters, the older is is , the more opportunity it has had to experience some trauma that bent something. That is a pretty tough motor though, so let's look at something else. If I am not mistaken, and maybe I am, the drive shaft is actually a stainless steel upper part and a high strength steel lower part, welded together at the water pump level. Sometimes the weld breaks. Sometimes it breaks because of a bent case, and sometimes it breaks for no good reason. If you have the factory service manual, does it give the procedure for checking alignment? Age and hours used do not matter by themselves. The shaft should never break......normally. Oil type does not matter either, unless the whole thing is shot.
 

grossgary

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
28
Re: Engine turns but prop doesn't (*the prop is not the problem*)

copy, looking at first half of the week to check it out. i do engine and trans swaps, assembly, rebuild wrecks, etc so i get mechanical stuff but completely clueless about boats, have never worked on one before at all, don't know anything about them. will look for that alignment checking stuff in manual when i get a chance, i guess that's normally in there? thanks.
 
Top