2024 NFL/CFB News and Nonsense

FLATHEAD

Captain
Joined
Dec 29, 2002
Messages
3,271

FLATHEAD

Captain
Joined
Dec 29, 2002
Messages
3,271
Eh, that’s just an article designed to create talk, full of conjecture and facts that don’t really support anything.
It take that back. These calls against the Texans for roughing Mahomes are a complete joke.
 
Last edited:

redneck joe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 18, 2009
Messages
11,143
Agreed, the one I can see as a pov issue tho. But I always defer to Marty, it is a part of the game you have to play thru it.
 

WIMUSKY

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 26, 2009
Messages
19,981
Danials was run way out of bounds then an extra shove.....
Crazy game. 52pts in the 1st half... Wash up by 10. You'd never guess Danials was a rookie..
 

FLATHEAD

Captain
Joined
Dec 29, 2002
Messages
3,271
Open up a discussion here. Will see how today’s games go, but the league really needs to get a handle on the officiating. Both games yesterday were poorly done, as well as throughout the season. Every football fan I know and all of social media ( the little bit of it I do) are talking about it. I’m sure some is the quality of televised replay. They need to look at all this stuff in the booth and make a call within a minute or less. The whole country knows the outcome minutes before it’s called on the field. Drags the game out.
 

WIMUSKY

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Sep 26, 2009
Messages
19,981
Hit high to the neck, helmet. Should have been called, even the booth ref agreed...
 

redneck joe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 18, 2009
Messages
11,143
ok, on the ref thing and on laptop not tablet sitting on the couch....

To expand on my above post - when Schottenheimer was our coach I watch the after game presser and he said something like 'if it comes down to one or two calls in a game we were not playing well enough and missed calls are part of the game and we have to deal with it'. I've always respected that thought process.

It is easy to sit here as a chiefs fan at this point and time and say this, but i said the previous paragraph because the last 40 plus years i've been a chiefs fan - especially during the 90s when we were the most winning team but alway flopped at the end - that a call or two changes the game, maybe. It can, depending on the team and the teams leaders, coach or QB or...

Same **** went on during the brady years but guess what - they won even when they have calls go against them. Montana, Elway, Bradshaw etc all of them as players and leaders in sports or the real world win because they are leaders and players, as a team and deal with what they have in front of them.

Now to the specific calls in yesterdays game:

imo, the refs in the NFL have the hardest job as refs, quickly followed by the NBA. Baseball, soccer, hockey etc all relatively easy to judge. If you watch a complete coverage of 99% of any NFL play there will be 2-5 missed calls. There is sooooo much happening at once. So that covers uncalled fouls.

Incorrectly called - two thoughts on that. One is acting has been a part of football for YEARS. If it is your team it is ok, if not then the refs are being paid. If your team then it is just the game.

Back to my thoughts on how hard it is to be 100% correct, being on the field, real time, is really an untenable situation. Imaging having to watch 22 humans rushing around a few acre field to see if everything is perfect. Armchair refs are same as couch refs. Watch a replay 30 times yes you can be almost perfect. Be on field level and in real time? Hell no. If you are a vet, think of the 'fog of war' theorem.

The two calls in this game, at field level, were called correctly from the ref's perspective imo. Now, do we need a challenge flag for issued calls or some other appropriate change? Absolutely. Back in the day the current challenge flag system and reffing by replay was going to kill the game. It didn't. Time to put some new guardrails in place for missed / incorrectly called fouls.



Here are the two play in question. Look at ref's position and the action. Wrong call but totally understandable.

https://www.si.com/nfl/ref-explains...ies-benefitting-patrick-mahomes-chiefs-texans
 

redneck joe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 18, 2009
Messages
11,143
Over losing a football game....no grow a set.
Disagree. If your life's passion is football, or whatever your life passion is and you are not some fat guy on a couch or mom's basement but invested in the passion with a warrior spirit as part of that team and you do not become emotional when you do not succeed to get the highest pinnacle of your lifes work, no need to 'grow a pair'. This is not some corporate drone job or cashier at Walmart....this is passion and desire for excellence. Emotions must be involved and I would guess most of them have 'grown a pair' to get to this point in their career.
 

DeepCMark58A

Commander
Joined
Aug 17, 2015
Messages
2,469
Disagree. If your life's passion is football, or whatever your life passion is and you are not some fat guy on a couch or mom's basement but invested in the passion with a warrior spirit as part of that team and you do not be emotional when you do not succeed to get the highest pinnacle of your lifes work, no need to 'grow a pair'. This is not some corporate drone job or cashier at Walmart....this is passion and desire for excellence. Emotions must be involved and I would guess most of them have 'grown a pair'.
Children cry when they do not get their way, not leaders of men. I get men showing emotion, but not when you don't get your way.
 
Top