Purpose of the whale tail is to provide lift at the stern. 50hp on a pontoon, makes it wishful thinking
These two are spot on. I ran a dole fin on my previous boat (17 ft sea ray 3.0). It did help with planing until it cracked my cav plate…I am thinking it is just additional drag on your pontoon. I would suggest running it with and then without. My bet is you will leave it off.