Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Davem3

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 15, 2011
Messages
542
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

GPS elevations are less accurate than GPS positions.
On a good day a GPS might locate you within 25 feet.
This is just fine for locating anything on the water.
If I intend on avoiding something, 100 yards is all the closer I want to get.
100 yards +/- 25 feet is workable in my eyes.
Locating a channel entrance buoy within 100 feet is acceptable.
But I would never attempt to navigate a 200 foot wide river, completely blind in fog wth just a GPS.

Using the GPS elevation to compute the water level +/- 25 feet is not of much use.

The aviation world is happy to know their elevation within 100 feet, but would never consider using GPS to determine any altitude.
They will use it to find the airport, but not the runway!

actually , my DeLorme Earthmate PN-60 is deadly accurate, usually with 12 inches, 99.995% of the time.
that, loaded with the topo lake info, my fish finder/depth finder, my bilge pump, anchor ARE MUST haves on any boat, or i do not go aboard, PERIOD!!!!!
 

Home Cookin'

Fleet Admiral
Joined
May 26, 2009
Messages
9,715
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

This is funny. How can anyone here answer the question "should I get a depth finder" with a no? Whether he has four wheel anti-lock brakes on his boat or not, how in heck could more information be bad?

I wouldn't say "no' to this particular OP because he says he has a 23' Chaparal (but then I hear he already has one built in so I don't know why he asks).

But when the discussion moves to more general boating, as it always does, and circumstances change, then the answer is not an unqualified "yes you must have one." Unless they are free, the suggestions have to include whether it is practical and worth the expense. Once you get away from his particular boat, it is true that a depth finder is not necessary or worth the cost for certain other boaters (after all, boaters have gotten along fine for centuries without them, as I have for almost half of one, in a variety of boats and conditions.) The extreme reactions to the contrary are, well, comical.

Furthermore, anyone who relies on gadgets better also learn to operate without them, because they will fail. That, and the fact that they are relatively new, proves that they are not necessities, but conveniences. Same as you tell teens about cell phones and other gadgets they insist they need.

It's like the discussions about "what kicker do I have to have?" and you find out it's a 16' tinnie he bought for $1200 and used on busy lakes in the summer, and he wants a $700 "spare motor" in case he breaks down. There are no absolutes but one--the plug.
 

CaptainKickback

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jul 23, 2011
Messages
1,060
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Nothing to do with the mounting configuration. The electronics on most sounders/transducers are not nearly fast enough to process the returns in shallow water.

What unit are you using with that capability?

So dingbat, are you saying when I buy mine for my project boat, I need to put my money into the transducer?
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

the answer is not an unqualified "yes you must have one."
Yeah, I get that. And my post was somewhat tongue in cheek except that some posts are suggesting that simply having a depth sounder will increase your risk of hazard as it will make you over confident. I say more info is mo betta. Always. I use a depth evaluating tool in my 14 ft. Tinny. If the OB won't drop all the way down, I'm too shallow :eek:
 

Jlawsen

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
810
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Tired... oops
 

UncleWillie

Captain
Joined
Oct 18, 2011
Messages
3,995
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

actually , my DeLorme Earthmate PN-60 is deadly accurate, usually with 12 inches, 99.995% of the time....

Directly from the DeLorme site.

Earthmate PN-60 GPS Details
GPS accuracy:
  • ? Position: < 15 meters, 95% typical*
  • ? Velocity: 0.05 meter/sec steady state

That's claiming to be within 50 feet most of the time, occasionally worse.

This accuracy really has nothing to do with what GPS you have, It is a matter of the physics of the GPS satellites.
At 25,000 miles per hour, they are moving over 36,000 feet per second.
If your clock is off by 1/1000 of a second, your position is off by 36 feet.
Many other issues come into play. 12 inches is just not feasable.

Set your GPS on a table in the yard and watch it a maximum zoom.
You will see a speed of 1-2 mph and a path that continually wanders around within 50 feet with the GPS just sitting on the table and not actually moving at all.
 

bruceb58

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 5, 2006
Messages
30,834
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Depends on the GPS but this Lowrance has an accuracy of 10 feet.
http://www.lowrance.com/Products/Ma...lectronic-Probes-EPs/LGC-4000/Specifications/

My golf GPS is consistently within a couple yards of the distance marks on the sprinklers as well as my friends who use laser range finders.

Of course depends on how they spec it. Some use CEP which 50% of the time accuracy and others use 2DRMS which is 98%. The last spec yields a bigger variation. If the GPS uses WAAS, you can get sub meter accuracy.

Vertical accuracy is much worse than horizontal accuracy. Not uncommon to have close to 20 meters of innacuracy for elevation so using it to determine the elevation of a lake is close to useless.

As far as I am concerned, relying solely on a depth sounder to avoid running aground is foolish. I always have my depth sounder on just in case but using good judgement will save you more times than your sounder will.

My depth sounder is mainly used for anchoring but I also use it alot going up slot canyons at lake powell but I am going extremely slow when that happens.
 

roscoe

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Oct 30, 2002
Messages
21,990
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

This is funny. How can anyone here answer the question "should I get a depth finder" with a no? Whether he has four wheel anti-lock brakes on his boat or not, how in heck could more information be bad?

Please don't answer with the underground obstruction simplicity. We all know that a hidden solid thing is bad. Heck I use my depth finder to tell swimmers how much water they have. My boys know to ask before they dive in. Next you all are going to say that they could dive into one of those hidden obstructions. Those of you who think that way how do you rationalize taking a shower? You could slip and die at any minute. Avoiding stinking a little is hardly a reason to risk dying . . . :facepalm:

Sorry QC, but OP didn't ask "should I get a depth finder".

He asked "how important are Depth Finders from a safety standpoint? "

So I say, not very, as not many people get hurt by running aground or hitting a rock.

Avoiding stinking a little is hardly a reason to risk dying . . .

I apparently work with a few people that believe that.



As for me, I wear my magnetic boots in the shower.

c%20_eudora_Embedded_pastedGraphic2.jpg


Along with my inflatable helmet.


4195NE9QE8L._SS400_.jpg



I'll be getting one of these soon, then I will be allowed to walk and chew gum at the same time.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7Oud3iGXWY&feature=player_embedded#!
 

oldjeep

Admiral
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
6,455
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I'm not saying don't buy one - I've got one in my boat. I'm saying that it doesn't do much good in terms of hitting bottom/objects around here.
 

gn85

Cadet
Joined
Nov 1, 2011
Messages
25
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I put a depth finder in my boat and had a few people scratch their head and wonder why. Last weekend, it came in handy in a way I didn't think of before.

I had a problem and had to be towed in by a nice guy in a sail boat. I knew coming back to the ramp was gonna get shallow. Real shallow for him. But since I had been paying attention to my depth on the way out, I could tell him what depths to expect and where he'd be safe. It helped him out and really helped me out.

Considering the cost and relative ease of installation I don't see why not to have one.
 

Texasmark

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 20, 2005
Messages
15,070
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

After not having one for so many years, my first was a Heathkit when they first started hitting the market. Have not been without one since. Just want to know what I am over, even if it is the water I boat frequently. If in water I don't know I will run it at low speeds until I know it. If I am in an area that may have obstructions, like lakes that filled prematurely and old structures still exist (bridges) I am especially careful. If in a lake known to have boulders I am especially careful.

Reading these responses has been more fun than watching cartoons on the kiddie channels.

Mark
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
17,405
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

So dingbat, are you saying when I buy mine for my project boat, I need to put my money into the transducer?

If you want good shallow water performance you need a transducer with as little ring as possible. The ringing is addressed as part of a transducers ?Q? value.

Ringing is the continued vibration of a transducer after each transmit pulse. Imagine the ringing of a large church bell. After the church bell is struck by the clapper, it continues to ring for a time if the vibrations are not dampened. In a transducer, these additional sound waves interfere with the reception of echoes. If a return arrives during the ring down it will appear on the sounder screen as a smear or it may even be hidden by the ring down and not appear on the sounder screen at all. Ringing, therefore, reduces the clarity of the display on the sounder screen and prevents the transducer from ?seeing? in very shallow water


Most off the transducers supplied with the popular brands of sounders have high ?Q? values. How high we don't know. They don't advertise that data. What we do know is that the P69 transducer, offered as an upgrade by some sounder manufacturers, has a ?Q? value of 24@ 50kHz and 30 @200kHz. In comparison, I?m running a B164 with a ?Q? value of 7@ 50Hz and 17@200kHz. The new HD and CHIRP transducers are running "Q" values of 8-9 at both 50 and 200kHz.

Be prepared. Performance comes with a price. My B164 runs @ $750-800. The HD and CHIRP transducers are much higher.
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Well the "Q" value in this thread is close to zero. I just can't get a proper troll going :facepalm: :D
 
Top