Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

UncleWillie

Captain
Joined
Oct 18, 2011
Messages
3,995
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

If you use a depth finder in conjunction with up to date charts and use elevations from your GPS you can pretty well know what the depth of the water you're in and headed for is. ... If you have GPS the NMEA 0183 sentence contains the elevation and most chart plotters use it. The first step is to get the current elevation on the body of water minus the distance from the antenna to the water line. Then you subtract the elevation at the time of mapping and the difference can then be used to compare to the contour lines or depth numbers of the navionics map. I do this once when I arrive at my favorite lake and put a sticker on my plotter with the correction number.

For instance: My favorite lake was mapped when the lake surface was at 5101.7 feet. The current lake elevation is 5096.3 feet. The difference is 5.4 feet so I look at the Navionics Map on my Plotter and if it's normally 10 feet deep its now 4.6 feet. That rock pile that was always 6' deep and easily clearable is now a prop killer.

GPS elevations are less accurate than GPS positions.
On a good day a GPS might locate you within 25 feet.
This is just fine for locating anything on the water.
If I intend on avoiding something, 100 yards is all the closer I want to get.
100 yards +/- 25 feet is workable in my eyes.
Locating a channel entrance buoy within 100 feet is acceptable.
But I would never attempt to navigate a 200 foot wide river, completely blind in fog wth just a GPS.

Using the GPS elevation to compute the water level +/- 25 feet is not of much use.

The aviation world is happy to know their elevation within 100 feet, but would never consider using GPS to determine any altitude.
They will use it to find the airport, but not the runway!
 

CaptainKickback

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jul 23, 2011
Messages
1,060
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Sorry, but anyone relying on the depth sounder to stop for a rock at high speed is a captain I don't want to boat with. Unless you are really that good, then I'll bring the beer. lol

The only time I use the depth finder is when pulling into an anchorage of 3 to4 feet, so we can get in the water and walk around the boat. At our usual spot, I motor slowly until the depth finder gets to 3, drop anchor, and fall back. This leaves me in 4 feet of water.

With outboards, you can go a bit shallower, but the problem with most depth finders is they can't read anything less than 2 feet. They just start blinking. If anyone knows of one that can read super shallow. please let me know. I want one.
 

ssobol

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 3, 2010
Messages
503
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

If you pay attention the depth finder will help you avoid mishaps in shallow water. When you notice the numbers trending down you can slow down or alter course.

Where I boat (Potomac River) you usually can't see the bottom. There are plenty of places where you can be out in a wide part of the river and suddenly find quite shallow water. The depth finder will tell you if encounter an area like this and when you leave it. A good chart plotter will show you the charted depth under your boat, but a depth finder is a good backup.

Before I had a depth finder I could unknowingly find myself in shallow water and my prop shows it. In some cases I would check the water depth using a paddle, but that was a pain. Now I still sometimes end up in shallow water, but at least now I know it and am usually traveling very slowly.

Cruising is more relaxing now that I have a depth finder and a chart plotter.
 

Trooper583

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 19, 2010
Messages
134
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

the last depth finder I bought I found brand new on ebay for 70 bucks. It was a Humminbird brand. I have been very pleased with its performance over the past couple of years. I think for the amount of money we're talking about here, a decent depth finder is a no-brainer. Nothing is going to work under every condition, every time in every set of circumstances. Even the nicest depth sounder, chart plotter, bottom mapper, etc will not save you if the boating gods decide it's your turn to fork over some more cash.

I boat on Lake Barkley is Western Kentucky most of the time. Because it is a manmade lake, in a region where there are lots of "hills" and "hollers" the water depth can get crazy at times. There are old home foundations, tree stumps, road beds submerged bridges, etc that can ruin your day. I know my way around pretty well and know where I can go safely without worrying about depths. I usually pay close attention to where other boats travel on a regular basis and take that into consideration when thinking about going there. That $100 depth finder if used with good common sense could save you a prop, outdrive or worse. That is some cheap insurance.
 

Home Cookin'

Fleet Admiral
Joined
May 26, 2009
Messages
9,715
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Mine will read to 18". Is that shallow enough for you? :D

mine covers <1 foot.

Consider how you set it, too. Surface/hull bottom (keel on a motor boat) Keel on a sailboat or rudder (motor skeg) on a motor boat. I have mine on the latter.

Whether one is "needed" or "nice to have" cannot be answered generally. I've never had one until I got a 21' deep V, and I think for boats that size and certainly larger, it's important;for a cabin boat moreso. But not for a small boat under 19'. The test? can you push off with a shove pole/oar/paddle?
Another factor is the type of water you're in. For me, if you bump, it's a sand bar/mud flat with gradual dimensions and usually you can back off, or raise the motor,or move the crew around, so a depth finder is not that important. I woudl imagine, and these posts support it, that rock boating is a different world. Thus there is no answer to the basic question.

Don't get me wrong, I love mine and have used portables in the small boats and piers (wireless remote type). They are great fun, and great for fishing. But that's not "need."

One truth for all boaters is that at speed, they tell you what you didn't hit; they do not tell you you are about to hit. They should not be used for "safety" in that regard.
 

jayhanig

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jun 27, 2010
Messages
836
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I live on a barrier island off the coast of North Carolina and I ws told when I first moved here the big difference between boating in our sound compared to boating in a lake is that just because you see water all of the way from Point A to Point B doesn't mean you can actually get there in a boat. We run aground all of the time here. I can't imagine trying to run without a depth finder in anything bigger than a row boat.

True, it only tells you the depth of the water under your transom but it does give you good information about trends in bottom contour. Good stuff to know...
 

Ciscovet

Seaman
Joined
Sep 4, 2011
Messages
73
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Would have been nice to have this thread a month ago when I managed to run over a rock pile in the Gulf of Mexico. A new upper/lower unit and 4000 dollars later I learned my lesson.
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
17,404
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

mine covers <1 foot.

Consider how you set it, too. Surface/hull bottom (keel on a motor boat) Keel on a sailboat or rudder (motor skeg) on a motor boat. I have mine on the latter.
Nothing to do with the mounting configuration. The electronics on most sounders/transducers are not nearly fast enough to process the returns in shallow water.

What unit are you using with that capability?
 

Ciscovet

Seaman
Joined
Sep 4, 2011
Messages
73
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I plan on using the chartplotter mainly. The marina is half way between Anclote key to the south and Hernando beach to the north. I plan on plotting a course while taking it very slow all the time looking for submerged objects. I will then use and always follow the plotted course.
 

Home Cookin'

Fleet Admiral
Joined
May 26, 2009
Messages
9,715
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Nothing to do with the mounting configuration. The electronics on most sounders/transducers are not nearly fast enough to process the returns in shallow water.

What unit are you using with that capability?

I know the mounting and sensitivity are unrelated; that was just an additional comment.

Mine's a garmin that was on the boat when I got it; I don't recall the # but it's between 2003 and 2009. Although i see readnigs on the screen showing ".6" I have not tested the accuracy and low depths and even suspect that it has a margin of error in my favor (shows shallower than it really is). I don't need to know exactly for the extreme low (due to that margin + soft bottoms) or for fishing/cruising depths.
 

Home Cookin'

Fleet Admiral
Joined
May 26, 2009
Messages
9,715
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I live on a barrier island off the coast of North Carolina and I ws told when I first moved here the big difference between boating in our sound compared to boating in a lake is that just because you see water all of the way from Point A to Point B doesn't mean you can actually get there in a boat. We run aground all of the time here. I can't imagine trying to run without a depth finder in anything bigger than a row boat.

True, it only tells you the depth of the water under your transom but it does give you good information about trends in bottom contour. Good stuff to know...

Me too (barrier island boating) but few of us who boat up there (hunt/fish club) use them.

Learning to estimate the depth based on the shape of the banks and vegetation is a good skill to have. Polarized glasses make a big difference, too.

A bay 2 miles across with be 1-2' deep and a gut 20' across will be 10' deep. Boaters from other parts of the world typically learn this the hard way. Then there's the 3' tide.
One of the best markers are the crab pots; if you don't see the top you have 18", enough to run on a plane. Also crabbers usually set them in natural channels so the floats are a good way to find deeper water.

because equipment malfunctions so easily, the old time skills are more important. But few people acquire them if they have the modern devices along. it's like the Chart and compass v. GPS discussion.
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Yes, if you are watching just the number. If you have a graphing depth finder (which is what I'm assuming he is referring to, vs a round dash mount number display), its fairly easy to see trends. Most lakes don't go from 30 feet to 3 feet instantly, there is some transition.

Oh really -- I can and have boated on exactly that kind of water. Running wide open in 60 - 70 feet of water. In a heartbeat I am in 6 feet. By the time I yank back on the throttle I am in 40 feet again. What was it? A land bridge that connected and island to the mainland. A dam installed years ago to create the very large impoundment covered the ridge. Was I close to either the island or the mainland. No! I was in the middle of about a 1/2 mile wide pass between the island the mainland. KNOW THE WATER! Yes -- a depth finder/locator/graph/GPS/mapper are all beneficial. But unless you know the water or are very up on how to read terrain none of those devices will help you at high speed. They are very beneficial when running a river channel provided you understand what you are seeing and again understand water flow. Running downstream for example, if you are hugging the right side and cut to right on sharp right hand bend in the river there is a good chance you will run aground or hit something. Current will flow straight until it bounces off the shoreline on the other side of the curve. An example of this is a mud flat on the right side of a bend. The far side of the bend has 25 feet of water. You shoot straight ahead rather than bugging the right shoreline. Maps with channel markings on rivers are essential for safe navigation. If you travel strange water without a map you better do it at part throttle or at least watch where other boaters are traveling at high speed.
 

jkust

Rear Admiral
Joined
Aug 2, 2008
Messages
4,942
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

The OP's Chaparral has a Faria Depth Finder guage as standard equipment in the dash. I have the same depth finder in my Chap. At a minimum I want the guage with its adjustable min depth alarm. I'd really like a large screen combo fish locator/depth finder but there just isn't a spot to mount it.
 

haulnazz15

Captain
Joined
Mar 9, 2009
Messages
3,720
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Nothing beats being familiar with the water you are boating in but the depth finder helps give you that confidence. Is it necessary no but if it wasn't a valuable tool they wouldn't put it standard in almost all new boats.

^This. The only boats I've had depth finders on have been bass boats, though. The best solution is to be very familiar with the body of water you are in, and take standard precautions as far as distance from shoreline and marker buoys. I suppose depth finders are about like speedometers on a boat: nice to have and can provide useful information, but isn't usually necessary to safely operate. If you are on plane and the shallow water alarm goes off, you don't likely have time to do much to save the prop/outdrive anyway. In fact, it may be detrimental to yank the throttle back as you will increase your draft as you come off plane. The main convenience I'd have with the depth sounder is in navigating unfamiliar bodies of water and slow speed operation near shore.

Side note: many inland lakes do not have maps with soundings available, so GPS/chart plotter data could be unavailable. I've only chewed up one prop a bit, an aluminum one on the bass boat (which had the fishfinder, but wasn't turned on). I was familiar with the area, the lake was a few feet low, and I was moving at idle speed so it wasn't catastrophic. Probably would have saved the prop if I had the fish finder on, but oh well. $100 lesson learned.
 

DavidPJ

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
41
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I've also been contemplating a depth finder for my recently purchased boat. My last boat had one and at times I found it useful, but definitely not when cruising the lake. Sometimes it was useful when just idling without an anchor and the boat would drift to shallow waters and the alarm with sound off. Also it was useful when just puttering near the shore enjoying the views. When cruising it typically didn't give accurate information. I also liked knowing battery voltage and water temperature.

Regarding installation of a depth finder, how easy is it to install one? I'm thinking of doing it myself or having my dealer install it.
 

QC

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 22, 2005
Messages
22,783
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

This is funny. How can anyone here answer the question "should I get a depth finder" with a no? Whether he has four wheel anti-lock brakes on his boat or not, how in heck could more information be bad?

Please don't answer with the underground obstruction simplicity. We all know that a hidden solid thing is bad. Heck I use my depth finder to tell swimmers how much water they have. My boys know to ask before they dive in. Next you all are going to say that they could dive into one of those hidden obstructions. Those of you who think that way how do you rationalize taking a shower? You could slip and die at any minute. Avoiding stinking a little is hardly a reason to risk dying . . . :facepalm:
 

aharper00

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
42
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

I'm seeing mixed answers here... most are saying "wouldn't go without one" but are justifying it by saying that they have deep water surrounded by something that reduces the depth like a rock or stump or something. By the time your depth finder shows you the new depth it's kinda too late, isn't it?

I'm of course asking because my boat doesn't have one and I'm considering adding one. I don't know if getting something that is thru hull or transom mounted makes most sense, though. Would be nice to have the water temp so I'm leaning toward transom mounted but am nervous about figuring out how to mount it.
 

haulnazz15

Captain
Joined
Mar 9, 2009
Messages
3,720
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Regarding installation of a depth finder, how easy is it to install one? I'm thinking of doing it myself or having my dealer install it.

Most all of them just require a single wire running to a transducer you mount with a couple of screws (and some 3M 5200) on the transom of the boat (or inside the hull if you choose that model). The gauge itself can be mounted anywhere and just has the positive/negative to power the gauge coming from the instrument panel distribution block. I'd imagine it takes 30 minutes or less to install one.
 

CaptainKickback

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jul 23, 2011
Messages
1,060
Re: Question about necessity/importance of depth finder

Mine will read to 18". Is that shallow enough for you? :D

Works for me. Tell me about it. Is the extra sesitivity due to the unit or the sender?

Sorry to hijack the thread.
 
Top