The starter is new so I'm guessing the slave
sorry for the delay response. the previous owner said the boat ran fine last year he said when he was winterizing the boat that he put the new starter on the boat but it had a problem starting so he jumped the slave solenoid and the boat ran fine. i have not put the boat in the water to test to see if the solenoid is bad, he is my dads friend so i trust in what he says. he kept the boat in tip top shape,