Johnson 65hp with low compression

billybl

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
4
Hello, I have a 1973 Johnson Stinger 65 hp ( 65ESL73R ) that hadn't been started in 20yrs. This summer I replaced all the seals in the lower unit. Along with a new impeller. rebuilt the fuel pump along with all new gas lines. Pulled and cleaned all 3 carbs. She started right up and seemed to run pretty well on muffs. Took it to the lake for a test run and when I put the throttle to it she came right up on plane like it used to do, but then it started cutting out. You could tell that one or two cylinders were cutting in and out. I could play with the throttle and it would kick in and haul a** for a minute or two, but then start bogging out again.

When I got it home I put the muffs on again and started it up, this time you could hear the cylinders kicking in and out just at idle. It was pretty obvious, so I know It wasn't doing that before on the muffs.
I checked for spark by pulling one plug at a time. No spark at all on the top cylinder, the middle was good and the bottom was weak. Then I did a compression test and only got 60lbs on all 3 cylinders. I know 60 isn't good at all, and it's hard to believe that all 3 are going to read exactly the same psi.. but they did.

I also find it kinda surprising that when all 3 cyl were firing, even with such low compression that it still had as much power as it always did.
I am at a loss as what to do now. I hate to throw more money into it trying to find out whats wrong in the ignition causing it not to fire in two cylinders.
The low compersion wouldn't cause it to misfire, would it?

I welcome any and all thoughts, ideas, suggestions and recommendations!

Thanks for reading!
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
I've only had a boat for about a year, so I'm new..

I have a 71' 50 hp..
​With what you describe, I might test spark with an open air gap tester.. It's a 7/16 inch gap for mine, so I think yours might be about the same.
Should be crisp blue spark with a "Snap!"..
​That'll tell you if ignition is an issue..
​Could be coils.. Are they cracked at all?

​Anyway, I guess what I mean is yes.. 60psi is LOW, but you describe relatively good running at first...
​I think I might (as a newbie) troubleshoot my ignition first and see what if anything is wrong there..

​I think I'd also try to recheck compression with a different gauge to rule out a gauge issue giving the low readings..

​Once I had spark gap test results, and new compression results from a different gauge, then I'd post that here and see what the experts thought.
Wouldn't buy parts or fix anything yet..

​If ignition checks out good, and rechecking compression shows the same results, then I'd consider pulling the head and checking gaskets, rings etc..

That's a broad stroke of what I might do, but the experts here can help better for sure..

For whatever it might be worth..
 

Chinewalker

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
8,902
60 psi on all three is unusual. 99% of the time, if a motor is blown, it'll be one cylinder going down, not all three, and not evenly. As noted above, try a different gauge.

Issue sounds more like a power pack going down, or possibly a coil or two failing. Both can be intermittent issues. You can sometimes confirm/eliminate a coil being the issue by swapping the coil from the firing cylinder to the one that isn't firing, and vice-versa, to see if the issue follows the coil.
 

interalian

Commander
Joined
Jul 23, 2009
Messages
2,105
If it's been sitting for a long time, you could have connection issues to the pack or other parts. Open all the plug connectors to wipe any fretting corrosion of the terminals. Fretting is a tin on tin oxide buildup that can pry the joint to an open circuit - cycling the connection cleans the joint.
 

billybl

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
4
So I did as interalian suggested and cleaned all the terminals & connections. That got cyl #1 firing again, but #3 is still putting out a very weak spark when I ground out the plug.

So then I did like Chinewalker said and took the good Coil from #2 and switched it with #3. Now it's firing on #3 cyl.

I haven't been able to round up another compression tester yet, can't afford to buy another one.
I guess I could test mine out on something that should have a known compersion.. not sure what that would be unless I test it on my car

But just for shtz and giggles, Let's say my tester is correct and all 3 cylinders are only coming up to 60lbs. Do you think it's even worth it to spend the money on a new coil? Keeping in mind that a couple of weeks ago when I put it in the water, When all 3 cylinders were hitting, the boat got right up on top of the water and performed like it used too, 20+ years ago. granted that it was only hitting on all three for a minute or two before bogging down.

I'm leaning at throwing another $60 at it for a coil... and if it still runs like crap. Off to the scrap yard! :(

Oh, and thanks a lot, guys, for the help and great advice!!

I forgot the crack in the coil...
0822171812-01.jpg
 
Last edited:

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
So I'm guessing that picture is the #3 coil where it wasn't firing right.. lol
​Swapping the coils and now getting spark would seem to point directly at a bad coil wouldn't it..

I replaced one of mine with a crack like that. Doesn't look like much, but what a difference! (on mine anyway..)

​As Chinewalker said, it's unusual to have compression on all 3 low and even like that (although not impossible I guess)..
That's why I thought of using a different gauge..

I've heard, (again, new so don't quote me! lol) that sometimes a "decarb" can bring low compression back up a bit...
​That's supposed to clean up things a bit and possibly free up stuck rings (if stuck) which could increase compression numbers.
​Not a magic fix. Don't think it'd jump from 60 to 170 or anything, but just something to try I guess.
Here's a link to a post I found on it. (There are several.. lol)
http://forums.iboats.com/forum/engin...ng-an-outboard

​I'm sure others can advise on that if you choose to do that.. :)

​If you have the means, I guess throwing a coil at it and seeing how it goes isn't that bad..
​If you're already thinking scrap yard instead of rebuild or whatever, then if the new coil gets it to run, and it runs good, then you could just use it till it dies, then junk it.. (Maybe keep some of the good parts just in case for possible spares??)

I don't know..
​Again, still new, and no expert here.. lol

​Just some thoughts I had on it..

​Hope it helps, even if just a little..
 
Last edited:

Trains1938

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jun 30, 2015
Messages
75
Hi, I have a 68 model and had the same problem. Turned out that the charge compositor was bad in the power pack.
 

Faztbullet

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
15,938
Hi, I have a 68 model and had the same problem. Turned out that the charge compositor was bad in the power pack.
68 has totally different ignition system....
 

jakedaawg

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
4,275
I'd be willing to bet that you have more than 60 psi. I doubt you could get it to start with 60. Most likely a gauge or technique issue. The even reading is good. Get a new coil and go boating.
 
Top