This is my guess, the old one was quiet the new one hollering. Did you get a thrust washer?Have you replaced the old prop for same new one ? If not, probably the rear prop spacer is too short or different and the back of the prop it's grinding against the front of the prop shaft housing ?
Happy Boating
I would expect a "clunk" unless he moved the shifter at a snail's pace, not a grinding noise.Surely it’s possible it’s just out the water and the usual straight cut shifting noise ? Simple things first
Possibly. He did say it happens when he shifts into gear.I would expect a "clunk" unless he moved the shifter at a snail's pace, not a grinding noise.