I totally respect your years of experience and welcome your knowledge here on the Forum. As I stated previously Spraying Gelcoat on an existing hull and spraying it in a Mold are two completely different processes. There is a chemical process in the curing of Polyester Based products but...Gelcoat and ALL polyester resin products are Air-Inhibited cured. ALL of them. Again in a Mold situation the Gelcoat is applied to the mold that is treated with a release agent. After the Gelcoat has been sprayed in The fibeglass resin is sprayed over it. This SEALS the Gelcoat from the air and thus allows it to fully cure
quickly. ALL polyester resin
will cure to a Non Tacky surface eventually but temps and humidity can make this a Long process and getting it fully cured as quickly as possible is the desired method, especially with GelCoat. Even though it will eventually cure with time, It won't be as Hard and durable as it would if Air is not allowed to get to it while the chemical process is occuring. When it's sealed from the air it occurs very quickly. In a mold once the glass has been shot over the Gel the resin doesn't need to cure quickly and remain tacky for an extended period. Additives do help with the flow of the product and thin it which aids in the spraying. . Thinning with styrene is the recommend method but it's some nasty stuff . Thinning is a necessary evil but it should be the minimum to allow for application. All I'm doing is passing on what I learned from two of this Forums Resident Experts. OOOPS and Ondarvr. Ondarvr has been in the Resin Business for over 40 Years and Testifies in Court cases for ALL the NorthAmerican Resin Manufacturers. He's forgotten more about this stuff than I'll ever know but during his time on this forum he taught me and the rest of the members a LOT about the right and wrong methods. The reason for removing the old gel is that it will absorb contaminants over the years and this can cause blistering and cracking of the new Gel. It's NOT absolutely necessary to do this but a really good sanding of the overall hull IS if you want to ensure good results. Everyone is free to do as they see fit, Me and the others here on the forum only try to give answers based on our experience and knowledge. Everyone has to make their own decisions on what to follow. I stated in my previous answer that Wax if used, ONLY goes in the final coat. PVA is sprayed on about 20 minutes after the last coat of Gel is applied and then washed off in about an hour. For small repairs you can tape plastic over the area and get the same results as Wax or PVA.
I'm just an Dumb Old Okie trying to pass on my knowledge from Experience and "Lernin'" that I've gained from the Forum Members. Use it as you see fit.
Here's a thread from 11 years ago where Ondarvr talks about Gelcoating. I sure wish he was a part of this Forum.
https://www.boatdesign.net/threads/gel-coat-cure.22713/
https://www.boatdesign.net/threads/g...actions.36424/