Took the tiller handle apart, got all the old caked up grease off, pulled that control arm out, made sure both sides of the plastic pin was intact where it went into the slots, sprayed some PB Blaster into the worm gears to make sure they moved freely. Greased the shaft inside the tiller handle and put back on. Reseated the metal speed indicator ring and the rubber handle. Now it turns freely and the cam roller lines up where I think it should. At the first of the 2 marks, throttle plate is barely open and by the time it's at the end of the cam, that arm is pushed away as far as it goes and the throttle plate is perfectly horizontal. This is when it's in forward gear. If it ever warms up around here, I will fill the trash can up with water so I can crank her up and see how she runs.