Well...it's not good.
Cylinder #1 105 lbs compression 10% leakdown
Cylinder #2 110 lbs compression 20% leakdown
Cylinder #3 105 lbs compression 15% leakdown
Cylinder #4 95 lbs compression 40% leakdown
I purchased the motor 18 months ago and it was supposed to be "rebuilt", including new Wiseco racing pistons, rings, and bearings at all cylinders (among other things), but I don't see how that is possible. We started having power loss issues, stalling, etc. from the get go & went back under warranty to the seller early on and was told it was a loose screw & were sent on our way. Our last trip out was when we had the "drop to half throttle & never came back" issue I originally posted about. The boat only has about 10 hours on it since the "rebuild", since our new work schedule & health issues has limited our lake time over the last year and a half.
I have already confirmed via pictures, calls, and emails with a representative at Wiseco that these are in fact not Wiseco pistons, since they dot etch the size, model, and run # on the dome of all of their pistons. I also confirmed that Wiseco does not make "racing" pistons for old outboard motors like my 1978 Evinrude 115hp.
Piston #1 looks like a newer piston...2, 3, and 4 appear to be old pistons, based on the carbon buildup present on them and not on #1. The carbon buildup on #2 was lightly scratched off to see if there were any numbers on it & there are clearly not any numbers. The shop that did the compression/leakdown tests (where we took it for a second opinion) said they (2,3,4) look like pistons that haven't been made for 30 years. They also said that a proper rebuild that they do would include boring the cylinders to the next oversize & putting all new oversize pistons/rings/bearings in the rebuild.
When I asked the "rebuilder", he said he doesn't keep records of what size pistons he uses. He also said that a proper rebuild does NOT require boring, & that he did not have records of what bore size was used, if any. He said that boring all cylinders was also not required because there is not a balance issue with a 2 stroke. He said only honing was needed to establish a cross hatch pattern prior to piston installation.
From what I have determined in my research, the fact that the pitting is present would be an automatic reason to bore the cylinder. Low compression/high leakdown would be another.
I am considering legal action under civil law for fraud...since we paid for a "rebuilt" motor & clearly didn't get what was stated in the sales contract. My next step is to pull the pistons to have them examined.
Opinions???