Basic Question : Cylinder Miss

atomboat

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 14, 2018
Messages
3
I have a different question to ask about a project Evinrude, (1995 E60TLEOC), but thought I would start with a simpler question. I am working through the CDI troubleshooting guide, but have settled on this:

What does it mean for a cylinder to "miss." I assume "miss-fire", which I thought meant it didn't fire at all.

I put a timing light on cylinder one (did on all of them) and the highlighted number changes, in concert with the hesitation in the idle (which is pretty bad, hence working on it). I would think that the number would stay the same (the CDI would fire at the same point) but am curious what this would mean? Does this begin to incriminate the CDI system? This is only at idle. There are other things that I looking at, like the Quick Start not working like it should, cracks on boots from CDI, etc, but seeing different numbers on a timing light seems like a problem?

BTW ... it might be hopping back and forth between the Quick Start advance and the standard idle setting (10 BTDC to 4 ATDC) but I have more work to do in better lighting to validate that)

Any advice?

Thanks!
 

Rustywrench

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 10, 2018
Messages
209
As is with many terms that mechanics use the terms can get mixed up? To me the term mis-fire means an event (chance for the engine to make power didn't happen). Could be lack of fuel, ignition, or any number of things.
What you may be referring to is firing at the right time? You are correct in saying QuickStart may be causing you to see erratic things on your timing light. Depending on your timing light they can also be very sensitive to being close to another plug wire? They can pick up interference. Once QuickStart has cancelled out it should not come back on unless you hit the key switch to engergize the start circuit again. Any double firing or firing at the wrong time is not good.
You can lay out the flywheel for your other two cylinders (just use a screwdriver fir a top dead center tool, close enough) write the cylinder number in white out so you know which one you are looking at. Attach the timing light to each plug & see if the other cylinders are doing the same thing.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
First thing to do is a compression test on those motors.----# 2 cylinder has a high failure rate.
 

atomboat

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 14, 2018
Messages
3
Compression test recently (week ago) cold was 114/104/107.
I did mark the other cylinder positions and haven't seen a fire on the wrong cylinder event, but the timing light does oscillate back and forth between a couple of numbers. I will mark better and try again (this time only highlighted the numbers with a number 2 pencil). If I give a little gas, the timing position does seem to stabilize (and the fuel pressure, 3psi at idle with large jumps on misfire, does stabilize a bit) but the engine still runs rough. Clear fuel hose found a leak at the tank connector, but fixing that didn't affect the rough running.
The timing light clamp pickup does lay on top of the number 2 wire when clamped on the top wire, so maybe I will try to move that a little bit.
The Quick Start doesn't want to cancel, even if I remove the black/white wire and ground it and the engine is at 1300 rpm and doesn't cancel it either, which is a bad indicator according to the manual and the CDI doc.

Removing the plugs while running causes arcing across the coils on each of the three cylinders, but affects the bottom cylinder more than the other two. Recently rebuilt all three carbs with new Sierra kits. Replaced all 5/16 fuel line (5/32 lines look OK) New fuel pump, replaced VRO. New factory designated plugs. New portable tank with new lines and bulb. New fuel with no alcohol with 1:50 and Sea Foam. Checked and reterminated plug wires. Less than .2 ohms each. Checked resistance of coils, met book numbers. Plugs get oil coated, but I am only idling. Recent plug check wasn't too bad - no dark oil coating but a fuel coating.

If I cover inlet of carb during idle, idle drops for each cylinder. If I cover idle circuit air jet, effect not so clear - but still jockying with idle settings.

All of this is on ears. If I put it in a tub, things are a little different, but not much - which I will go back to this weekend.

Large indicator is that if I put it in the water, wont go past 3k rpm (tried a couple of times). Doesn't shake bad. Did link/sync but stuck on timing at this point. Haven't checked timing on the water yet.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Head gasket is cheap.----Pull the head and have a look in there.
 

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
I never remove plugs while running, i always have them grounded, stresses the coils like you noticed.
Ive seen many powerpacks go bad with these symptoms
 

Rustywrench

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 10, 2018
Messages
209
I am leaning with racerone on this. Pull the head. May save you a lot of time. I don't like the compression numbers are far as being even enough. The '95 was after oval exhaust port & much better, but something may have gone wrong. Look for cylinder scoring.
 

atomboat

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 14, 2018
Messages
3
Ill pull out the acetone and transmission fluid. Broke two heads on the exhaust cover due to corrosion. Several of the head bolts are rusted so I fear that I will be helicoil/retapping a lot of head bolts which means pulling the power head. :(

Thanks!
 
Top