I was riding the high of work going smoothly and it was still too cold to epoxy so I made a right turn and started on the engine. It had been sitting for 3 yrs and I wanted to give it a tune up, impeller, and rebuild the carb. It had never run right. Well, I should say, it was always hard to start. It would start, run for a few secs and then spit and stall. It would do this for 5 mins until it would warm up. I figured I would take the carb off and have it sonic cleaned, then rebuild it. For some reason I decided to take the head plate off. I think it was to replace the thermostat. That's when things got interesting.
I was not happy. I took that pic, texted it to my brother, who had taken pity on me and joined me in the build, and my buddy, who was planning on coming up for the launch. I didn't have the time or money to fix this or buy another engine by June. It was over. I was standing in the garage staring at the piston cursing the evinrude gods. Then it happened, I could swear I heard a bugle playing off in the distance as my buddy came down the driveway. He is a machinist and owns a speed shop. He gets out of the car holding a port grinder (I remember him holding it high above his head and a warm glow surrounding him...he insists I had had too many bud lights and was in shock). He takes a look at it, plugs the grinder in and starts smoothing away. If you can believe it, that is what happens to a piston when an engine pings for a long time. That is the product of detenation. Luckily, the piston was solid under the scar and there was plenty of meat under it so once he smoothed it all out he deemed it less then optimal, but it will run. And it does still. I make sure to run plus in her and she doesn't ping. I'm fine with it. A bit less compression in the top cylinder if it is even detectable.