56' Johnson FDE-10, not going into forward gear

run&gun83

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
5
Hello, new here and have found a ton of good info but could not find a topic on "linkage"... I recently picked up a 56' Johnson FDE-10(15hp), took out to a local river after rebuilding the carburetor and the motor worked perfectly - put it on the trailer, ran it to the lake the next day(70miles) and it wouldn't go into forward gear... removed lower unit, took apart the lower gearing and all looks good, went through and replaced the impeller and related items at the same time.... with the lower unit off I can manually get the gearing into forward/reverse/neutral... Is my issue in the linkage itself? Any tips/pointers of where to look next and figure out the root of this would be appreciated - Thanks Guys
 

run&gun83

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
5
I should add it will go into reverse and neutral without issue, sometimes when I would bring it back from the forward position to neutral it would engage reverse in the neutral position, then stay in reverse when I brought it to the reverse position but would go into neutral when coming out of reverse
...
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
On the brass coupler , both notches on the shift rods MUST line up with holes before bolts are put in.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Sounds to me like the inner shifter lever (inside, under the powerhead) has come loose. Just a guess, mind you. Undo the brass coupler and see if you can move the upper shift rod up and down without moving the shifter handle. It should not. If it does more than a very small amount, off with the powerhead.
 

valvebounce

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Mar 18, 2014
Messages
102
I have a '63 18hp Evinrude,I found that plenty of light helped to locate the bolts in the shiftrod.It's crucial to get them lined up.
 

Roberthill

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
317
Just went thru this , same problem upper shift rod connection under powerhead corroded thru , exhaust and hot water been hitting this for 61 years . It's already been said in above post . If upper and lower shift rod is attached to brass coupler I would think this is the problem area .
 

run&gun83

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
5
With the lower off I could not move the upper shift rod up/down with a screwdriver(access hole) without moving the shifter handle. When originally removing the lower unit I removed the lower bolt to the brass coupler to get the shift rod to release(left the bolt to the upper shift rod in place). I plan to check the brass couplers connection to the upper shift rod tonight, then remove completely, then reassemble the brass coupler to both the upper/lower shift rod and see if this was just a loose connection.

If that's not it and the powerhead is coming off, do you guys have further suggestions on what parts/gaskets I should automatically replace since I'm already in there?

I did put this project on hold until the parts schematic arrived in the mail, still waiting for the dang thing but need a project for this afternoon.
​
Thank you in advance
 

Crosbyman

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
6,298
http://boatinfo.no/lib/johnson/manuals/1922-1964johnson.html#/0

​well unless I missed somthing here if the shift rod is operating ...only with the shifter that is not bad...

the issue now is can you shift the gears F&R manually with the shift rod alone on the LU ( use pliers to pull/push the rod down and up... can you confirm that the prop will rotate in alternate directions by shifting manually

if not... the problem is not above the shift link it is below... in the gearcase. no need to pull the powerhead
 

run&gun83

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
5
Crosby: With the lower off, while spinning the driveshaft in one direction, the prop will rotate in alternate directions when I manually shift the gears into forward/reverse... you noted to use pliers when shifting the lower rod manually, I can easily flip to either gear with my hands... I don't know if that tells you anything but figured I'd share just in case.

​If my terminology/explanations on anything is confusing to anyone please ask me to clarify. The day before this shifting issue happened I had this motor out with zero shifting issues on my half hour long cruise. After that spin I trailered, woke up and went to the lake the next day, started and could then only go in reverse/neutral.

Much appreciated All
 

Crosbyman

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
6,298
well sounds like the prop is rotating properly and in both f&R manually

you need to go back up reconnect the shift rods together with the clip and make certain the bolts lock in the recesses of both rods

retry the shifter

​set in frwd rotate the flywheel clockwise and check the prop go in reververse while rotating the flywheel clockwise still and the prop should reverse
 

lindy46

Captain
Joined
Nov 27, 2008
Messages
3,886
well sounds like the prop is rotating properly and in both f&R manually

you need to go back up reconnect the shift rods together with the clip and make certain the bolts lock in the recesses of both rods

retry the shifter

​set in frwd rotate the flywheel clockwise and check the prop go in reververse while rotating the flywheel clockwise still and the prop should reverse

Agree - sounds like one of the shift rods is loose in the coupler. Forward is up, so gravity is working against you. If one of the rods is slipping, you'll have reverse (down) and possibly neutral, but the loose rod will pull out of position when you try to shift to forward.
 

run&gun83

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
5
No Title

First off, Thank you everybody for all the help/knowledge, I might have a new hobby - learned a lot about this motors mechanics with your help and know where to go if I ever have any questions. I'm still not 100% that I truly fixed this shifting issue but seemingly got it figured out last night when tinkering. Lindy46 --> your "gravity is working against you" comment struck a chord, after hooking up the LU for about the 3rd time I finally told myself that the brass coupler just isn't going north enough to engage forward gear when using the shifter, thus leaving it in neutral. But when I put some upward pressure on the coupler with a screwdriver through the peephole, it engaged into forward gear perfectly. I feel dumb saying this, kind of a newbie mistake here, but I completely overlooked the lit up bolt in the pic as most of my attention has been on the LU. That bolt was essentially "fall out" loose all along and once tightened the linkage starting working perfectly w/o any encouragement through the peephole. Still waiting for the parts schematic but ordered orings/seals/parts today in hopes to get this motor on the lake by Memorial Day!!! Next step is the bucket test and then a good degreasing/clear coat to save the patina on this old girl!!!

​Never again will I make it to the lake, have this problem, and head home in disgust again boys - Thank you All - my apologies on the rookie mistake/overlook.
 

Attachments

  • photo265275.jpg
    photo265275.jpg
    378.8 KB · Views: 0
Top