25 hp impeller pin keeps breaking; other possibly related issues

Tahawus

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
4
Hi, my first post here. Running into trouble with my 1969 Evinrude 25 hp. Here is the deal. Last fall, I had what was a suspected worn clutch dog. (I can't get the gearcase apart to check because there is a nasty stripped screw). The motor would jump out of forward and wind out at high rpms. It got worse and worse on one trip and had to use the trolling motor to get back to the dock. A few weeks later I found a 74 Johnson 25 hp, and picked that up thinking I could use that motor if it was better or harvest it for parts.

Turns out the Evinrude had better compression, so I focused on that motor. I put the lower from the Johnson on the Evinrude and everything seemed to be in order, once I got the shift linkage lined up to where I think it was supposed to be. I ran it in a barrel. No problems. Took it to the river and ran it there, no problems, but I couldn't open it up to more than about 3/4s throttle because of the narrow width of the river. Took it to the lake and almost right away, it was popping out of forward again just like it did in the fall, and before I even made it to 1/2 throttle. I also noticed that the water pump, which had been working at the dock, was now not working.

Once I got home and took the lower off again and got into the water pump, I noticed the impeller pin in the drive shaft was sheared off. I had another pin from the other motor and replaced that pin. I looked everything over and made some additional adjustments to the shift linkage and ran it in the barrel again. Worked fine at first. Shifted great. Did not hear any grinding or revving or any popping out of gear. BUT....it stopped spitting water after a few minutes and after I started testing the shifter. I once again dropped the lower and got into the water pump. The impeller pin was again broken and in the same spot.

So, I was wondering if I needed a new impeller and I definitely needed a new pin. So I ordered an impeller kit and put in a new impeller and pin, reassembled everything, making some adjustments to the linkage and the two screws in the shift handle in order to make sure everything was tight, and ran it in a barrel. No problems. Water flow was great. Shifted great. No issues. I took it to the lake and at first everything ran great. Pumping good. Shifting good. When I got up to about 3/4's throttle again, the motor lurched slightly a couple times but otherwise was staying in gear. Then I noticed the water pump was not working.

I have not taken it apart again to check, but my guess is that impeller pin is broken again.

Anyone have any thoughts on what my next step should be, other than giving up and parting out both motors?
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Did you line up the notches in the shift rods with the holes in the brass connecter before you put the bolts in.-----I believe the instant acceleration when it jumps out of gear shears the impeller pin.-----Fix the jumping out of gear issue !!
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Lemme say that I've worked on literally thousands of those and related motors and never saw a sheared impeller pin. Something is weird here and I don't see how it could be related to the shift or jumping out of gear. Are you using the OEM stainless steel pin?

EDIT: I suppose a guess is good as anything. Impeller hard to turn because it is too thick, or pump cavity to shallow, or plate bowed up?
 

Chinewalker

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
8,902
I've had a couple of aftermarket impeller swell up a bit, creating a great deal of friction in the housing. OEM impeller cured the problem both times. Weird, because I've used Sierra impellers in hundreds of jobs over the years without issue...

Have you had either lower unit apart? Worn clutch dogs are not uncommon on those 22-cubers...
 

Tahawus

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
4
Thanks for the responses. Yeah, notches are lined up. I may have to double check the top one because I haven't had that one off yet. The bottom one certainly is.

I am using the Sierra impeller and pin. Not sure what the other two pins that broke were, they were what was on the two motors. Looked identical to the Sierra pin in the kit. I did not replace the housing. Just the metal plate, the impeller and the pin.

I have not had either gear case apart yet. I guess that would be a good next step to check the clutch dogs and gears. Interestingly, the drive shaft on the 74 I did not move to the 69 because the end that goes into the powerhead had worn splines. Also, that shaft, which I didn't use had a second hole drilled for the impeller pin, offset a few mms from the other one.
 

Tahawus

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
4
Here is my update on this. I got into both gearcases and sure enough, the 69 had a worn dog and gears. Looks like the dog had been flipped because there was a good deal of wear on both sides. I knew this was an issue though. The 74 dog and gears were also worn, with the dog not as as the 69, but still pretty bad.

So I tracked down some new gears and a clutch dog for the 69 and reassembled the lower unit. So far, so good. However now, when I push up or down on the shift rod, it doesn't "snap" into forward, nuetral or reverse. Instead, the shift rod only travels smoothly for about a half an inch, although when I spin the drive shaft by hand and do this, it is still shifting into gear correctly. Is this a problem? I do believe I got the pin into the shift rod/cradle correctly. But maybe I am missing something.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Two things make it snap into gear. The interlock bar on the side of the powerhead, and the detent spring and balls in the prop shaft & dog. However, the '69 model did not have the detent spring & balls feature.
 

Tahawus

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
May 3, 2018
Messages
4
Thanks for the feedback. I may have figured this out. When I dropped the lower before and did the swap with the '74, I simply didn't recall what the "feel" was in that '69 shift rod. I just assumed it was supposed to have that "snap" when pulled by hand when separated from the powerhead. Anyways, I have installed the new gears...found a decent deal for front, reverse gear and the clutch dog and replaced seals. Fixed a couple stuck, broken bolts/screws, and reassembled everything. I have had it on the lake twice and knock on wood, it has done very well. I could have probably gone with the newer style prop shaft with the detente spring and balls, but the deal on the older style was pretty good. I did not want to give up on this motor since it runs so good and is a great match for my boat in terms of power and weight. As for what happened to the '74 drive shaft, I may never know...the pinion gear was slightly different interms of the sleeve/bearing for the splines inside was not the same as the pinion gear for the '69, which it should have been according to the parts guide...same part number. The drive shaft end that goes into the powerhead was all chewed up, and someone had drilled a second hole for the impeller key/pin. Doesn't matter now...but just leaves me curious.
 
Top