1999 50hp Johnson - Help please!

Kvmundy

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5
Hello everyone,

This is my first time posting on this site. I would really appreciate any assistance with my circumstances.
My 1999 50hp Johnson 2 Stroke has been really acting up. When I attempt to start the motor it will not turnover when I leave the throttle in neutral. However, if I simultaneously turn the key and then throw the throttle into gear, it will fire right up. When I do this, I have to keep it in gear for it to run. The second I put it back down into neutral, the motor shuts down.
I?ve been reading a lot of forums on this site and my circumstances seemed like my fuel pump gone bad. I thought the fuel pump wasn?t pumping enough fuel while it was in neutral causing the motor to shut down. So I bought a brand new fuel pump and installed it. I also installed new fuel lines and new bulb. I also bought a little 6 gallon fuel tank, with new ethonol free gas, and 50:1 oil/gas ratio. This did not fixed the problem because the same issue was happening.
Then, I thought it could be the carbs so I spent a good part of a day removing both carbs and I thoroughly cleaned them. Reinstalled the carbs and tried it again. When I tried to start it. Same problem. It would only turnover if I threw it into gear while I was turning the key. The motor started up but when I dropped it back down into neutral, it shut off immediately.
After I do this a few times, when I try to turn it on it seems like the battery is losing juice. I think these circumstances seem like low RPM aspect of the stator isnt working. I am also thinking that maybe the rectifier or the pulse pack isn?t working properly either due to how it seems like the motor only working off the power being provided by the battery.
I got my hands on a meter to check the voltage going back into the battery while the motor is running. I started her up, she?s obviously in gear, took off the battery connections and tested them on the meter. When I took off the connections, while she is in gear, she continued to run. However, the meter read 0.03 volts while hooked up the meter. Does this mean barely no voltage is going back into the battery, causing the battery to die? I also put in a brand new battery last week so I know the battery couldn?t have died already. I?ve had to recharge the battery once already to be able to start her up.
Another issue is that when she?s in gear, the overheat light comes on. I had this motor fully serviced 4 months ago, when a new water impeller pump was installed. Could the overheating issue cause the motor to shut down while in neutral but not while it?s in gear?
Another aspect of my situation is that after I run her, an excess amount of oil/gas mixture comes out of the lower unit below the propeller. Why is this?
One last thing. When she?s in gear, she runs better when she?s trimmed all the way up. When I trim her down while she?s in gear, she shuts off easier. How can whether she is tilted up versus being tilted down effect how she runs? I?m baffled.
Does anybody have any insight on this? Any guidance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you ahead of time for assisting me!
 
Last edited:

Kvmundy

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5
Also, could my problem be the idle screw for the carbs not being tuned right?
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Welcome, Kv. A lot to take in there.

comment or two -- If you disconnected the battery leads while running, you almost certainly burned out the rectifier (battery would not charge, and tach may be affected if applicable.) I think the neutral safety switch might be out of adjustment -- probably in your remote box, activated by operation of the the throttle/shift arm. The neutral switch is intended to interrupt the starting circuit if the motor is not in neutral. But it's just a mechanical switch that operates by the position of the arm. If it's out of position or out of adjustment, you get some wonky operation.

Try this -- Hold the keyswitch in the start position, and try to engage the starter by operating the throttle/shift lever. If it starts to crank (i.e., starter operates) when you move the lever, the problem is probably the neutral safety switch. It may be a coincidence that the engine actually starts when you move it out of neutral -- could be an easy starting engine.

If you trim (i.e., tilt) the motor up out of the water while starting or running, you risk destroying the impeller or overheating the engine. That may not be what you are saying, though.

You should do routine checks -- get an adjustable open air spark tester, and measure the spark (plugs out, fully charged battery). Look for about a half inch sharp spark with the tester. (Start there and work back until you find spark, then note the measurement -- post what you find.)

Shutting off/cutting out when shifting to neutral may mean it won't run at idle -- could be an ignition issue or carb issue. Check the spark first. If the shop tested compression, find out what their records show.
 

jakedaawg

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
4,275
Hmmm, well, let's start with some basic terminology...

Turn over, turns over, cranking: let's define this as the starter engaged and creating sufficient rpm to actually start the motor. I.e. 300rpm.

Running, starts, started: let's define this as the motor is now running.

So what happens when you turn the key to start while in neutral? Does the motor turn over?
 

Kvmundy

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5
Oldboat1. Thank you for your insight. I am going to try the numerous things you proposed. I will repost tomorrow after I have a chance to complete those things you suggested! I am very interested to see if I am getting sufficient spark. What you say about the neutral safety switch makes a lot of sense to me as well. I?m interested to see what type of results I get after conducted those tests you recommended. Thanks again!

Jakedaawg. When I turn the key the motor does turnover but it will not run. It will only run when I throw it into gear while I am turning it over.
 

Kvmundy

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5
Could my low idle screw be not set properly? Maybe its off causing it not to start while in idle.
 

jakedaawg

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
4,275
Answer: When you cleaned the carbs were the jets behind the bowl drain physically removed and cleaned?

Answer: Has this ever run right for you?

Answer: Have you messed with the linkage at all? Turning any of the threaded rods and what Not?

Verify: With a spark checker verify that you have spark while in neutral and key in start position.

Verify: That both throttle plates are closed when in neutral and that both begin to open at the same time when throttle is applied.

Verify: That you are using proper starter method i.e. Push in The key while cranking to enrichen, use fast idle lever or pull out at base of throttle and twist forward to advance throttle while remaining in neutral all while cranking.
 

Kvmundy

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 25, 2017
Messages
5
Yes, I bought this motor for my 16ft center console approximately 10 months ago. I used it about once a week since I?ve had it and it always ran fantastic. This is the first time I?ve ever had a problem with it.
I removed the drain plugs on the bowls and thoroughly clean the bowls and the other aspects of the carbs with carb cleaner.
I did mess with the linkage because I removed the idle screws when cleaning the carbs. There was actually some hunk buildup in those jets but now they are fully clean.
 

jakedaawg

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
4,275
So, you need to know that behind the drain plug of each carb bowl is a jet that unscrews. This needs to be removed to be cleaned. It takes a small flat blade screw driver that is straight, no flare.

Do you use the fast idle function to start? this is either a separate lever, or pulling out on the handle, or sometimes a button at the base of the handle.
 
Top