That 12 footer will make a nice little Captain's Gig! Good stuff! :encouragement:
As for power, I can only relate my experiences.
Back in 1984 when I was stationed near Spokane, WA our site had a 14' Lund similar to your SC. With a 7.5HP Honda it chugged along with 2 fit guys on board but was no powerhouse. It took a long time to get anywhere. My favorite spot on Long Lake was a 20 minute trip from the ramp with that boat.
A year later I was a civilian again.
In 1985 I rented a 12' V-bow john boat like your SC and a buddy and I used it to go bass fishing on Lake Casitas, CA. The little boat only had a 4HP outboard and man was it slow! We were "cruising" along at full power just plowing through the calm lake when we were PASSED by a ladies sculling crew with 6 rowers plus the coxswain!
Talk about embarrassing! :embarassed:
So a year later I took my new Bass Tracker Tournament TX-17 with 50HP Mercury from southern CA where I lived back up to Long Lake in Spokane to go fishing with my military buddies who were still stationed there. Talk about a difference! Three guys in the boat and the other two looked at me funny when I turned my baseball cap around backwards. But the trip from the launch ramp to my favorite spot dropped from 20 minutes down to 3! My buddies almost lost their hats! That's what I'm talkin' bout!
Maybe you could install some of those roller wheel thingies on the tender so that you could plop a 9.9 on there without having to haul it down to the lake? Options, options... :frog: