There are three possible reasons for poor shifting. 1. The shift cable is not adjusted correctly under the cowling on the starboard side. There is a thumbwheel which screws in/out and will adjust the cable slightly. This is the easy adjustment. 2. When you remove the lower unit (perhaps for a new impeller) the shift rod gets exposed. If during the changeout of the impeller, the shift rod and get twisted-that can wind up being a big problem. During factory assembly, the shift rod height is set to a very specific height. (like with a 1/32" tolerance) If this rod is not put back in the exact position, the engine won't shift correctly. Have to pull the lower unit down again to reset the rod height. 3. If the gears get worn from years of shifting and use, it is possible the gear faces and the clutch dog faces will get worn. When they get too worn, the gears do not want to stay engaged, even if the shift is set perfectly. This is a more major job, which could result in a new clutch dog, forward and pinion gear. You may want to have a skilled tech look at this for you.