Re: 1977 evinrude 115 reverse problem
Proper shifting of the lower unit depends on the lower unit shift rod being set at the correct height. Always possible that the shift rod was screwed in or out during the water pump install. That will change the adjustment and make for odd shifting. I'd remove the shift cable at the engine end and see if you can get the engine to shift properly by hand. If it will shift normally by hand, you can probably reset the position of the cable by turning the thumb wheel on the engine end of the cable. If you can't you will probably have to remove the lower unit again and reset the shift rod height. The "height" is measured from the top of the lower unit casting, to the centerline of the shift rod eye, set in neutral. For a 20" standard lower unit, the height meassurement is: 21.411" +- 0.36"