1974 Johnson 25hp Hard to Start

HaplessBoater

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
4
Hello Forum Members! This is my first post and I hoping to tap into your collective wisdom to get this old 25 running like a top!!

Here is the story so far ...

Purchased in semi-running condition. Would start and run on one cyl in a tank. Fuel tank was ? full of water and one of the hose ends was broken (this was not the tank that the motor was test run on). Compression was 95 psi in top cyl and 100 psi in bottom cyl at purchase. Since then compression check shows top cyl at 100 psi and bottom cyl at 118 psi. I am concerned that the top cyl is damaged (scored cyl, piston, broken ring).

Symptoms
Very hard to start, and if it does start will run on 1 cyl and then quit. If you are quick and get it in gear and advance the throttle to wide open it will run ok. Even at high speed there is an occasion momentary ?hiccup?, but it will keep going. Upon return to shore as soon as the throttle is reduced to ? or less it cuts to 1 cyl and then quits. Very hard to restart.

Done So Far
  • Discarded old fuel, cleaned and dried inside of tank (no corrosion :)), drained fuel line, replaced hose end. Noticed that the fitting on the fuel tank does not seal correctly when the fuel line is disconnected. Fuel continues to flow out of the tank with the fuel line disconnected, so the o ring in the fitting at the tank needs to be replaced. Have not done this yet but will.
  • Fresh premium fuel mixed 50:1, with stabilizer and SeaFoam
  • Removed electric starter motor, electric choke, electric start lockout switch, and what remained of the neutral crank lockout mechanism. Installed new lanyard style kill switch (when closed the switch connects the 2 coils - I have confirmed the correct operation of this switch) and a bolt to block off the threaded hole in the top cyl. (that holds the crank lockout mechanism).
  • Replaced fuel line from fuel pump to carb
  • Replaced hose from upper bypass cover to bottom of intake manifold (fuel recirculation hose)
  • Cleaned filter screen at fuel pump. Didn?t see anything on it.
  • New spark plugs (Champion J6C). Gapped at 0.030?
  • New coils, points (set to 0.020?), condensers, driver coil
  • New impeller, wear plate. There is some water in the gear case oil, and I have a seal kit to replace the seals and o rings. Just didn?t get to it yet.
  • Carb remove, complete disassemble, cleaned with carb cleaner and passages blown with comp air, and rebuild kit (float, float valve, gaskets). Set float as per specs (level when inverted, and correct drop down).
  • Removed intake manifold and reed valves to inspect. Looked ok. Some minor corrosion on lower left side of the manifold and reed valve plate where the fuel recirculation hose enters. But condition of reeds overall seems fine (no cracks, chips, sealing well, etc.).
  • Have not pulled head or bypass cover to look at condition of top cyl and piston.
  • Have not checked to see if the thermostat is in place. In high speed running there was no evidence of overheat.
What do you think?

Thanks for your help!
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
wow. lot of work done. Not sure if that one can be resuscitated, but would check spark with an adjustable tester (open air type, not the inline). Try for about a half inch (3/8 to a half) on both -- nice, sharp spark. If weak or no spark, will need to do ignition work -- decision will be to do that, given compression issues. You could try removing and resurfacing the head cover, replacing the gasket -- see if some compression is restored, then take on ignition.
 

GA_Boater

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
49,038
Welcome aboard.

With all you've done so far, did anything make difference?
 

HaplessBoater

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
4
Thanks for your responses. I should add a couple of points:
  • I have synched the carb and timing advance so that the throttle plate just starts to crack when the roller gets to the marks on the armature cam.
  • Starting and running is better when cold. Once warmed up things deteriorate.
  • With all the work done so far, I think it has gotten worse. When I first got the motor it actually idled at the dock on 2 cyl for about 30 secs (did this once), but since then it has not done this. About the only improvement is at WOT - it does run reasonably well if you can get it started and accelerate at WOT and hold it there. Let off and it quickly dies.
  • There is no external evidence of leaking gaskets (head, exhaust, intake) or seals (upper, lower crankcase).
Is the next step to pull the head to see how "bad" the top cyl is? If I do this is there any chance of reusing the gasket or is new a must?

Thanks again!
 

GA_Boater

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
49,038
Time to pull the head. I wouldn't try to reuse the head gasket.
 

HaplessBoater

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
4
Head is off. Obvious mechanical (and melt?) damage to the top of the top piston. Cyl walls look slightly scored. Ports intake and exhaust look ok. Bottom cyl looks fine, although bottom piston also has some small abrasion on its top surface. When I grab the top of the piston I can move them side to side a few thousands of an inch in the cylinders. I am thinking this just turned into a parts motor.... or i buy new pistons, rings and get a hone (1 oversize). For a motor this old likely not worth it. Will try to post photos later.
 

GA_Boater

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
May 24, 2011
Messages
49,038
Sometimes you have to bite the bullet and give it up. Sorry, Hapless.
 

HaplessBoater

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
4
Unable to upload photos - sorry guys. Quick question: If I am trying to find a used power head or will anything from the 22 cu in series (1957 thru 1976 18, 20, 25 hp) work or does the piston design change over the years?
 

TN-25

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 27, 2008
Messages
627
Ideally a 1973 - 76 25 horse powerhead. I'm thinking in terms of drop-in potential, like Fire Flash ignition or whatever they called it, the use of pressure-backed rings, the right intake etc...
I ran dad's 1971 25 on a Starcraft as a kid. It was surprisingly fast because the boat was light at 16". He bought a used 1971 instead of a new 1974 because new was twice the cost, and a long shaft manual came up.
 
Top