1972 hydro electric 65 HP Johnson 65ESL-72S shifting problem

Too Dogs

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 16, 2013
Messages
20
1972 hydro electric 65 HP Johnson 65ESL-72S

I bought a project boat and the lower unit was missing from the above motor. I bought a second motor of the same model # and swapped the lower unit (low compression on the second motor). When swapping I installed a new impeller and Evinrude/Johnson "Electric Shift" lower unit oil .

In the driveway, connected to a hose and muffs, the motor shifts fine and has 11+ and zero volts as required to the wiring (grn/blue wires).

In the lake I only have FWD; no R or N.

In the lake, on the trailer, when I power the boat in Fwd. or Rev, I push the tow vehicle Fwd. No reverse at all.

Any ideas?- Thank You- TD
 

orbanp

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
324
Hi TD,

Do you have the voltages on the GRN/BLU wires when you are on the lake?
Also, check the resistance of the solenoids, they are around 6 - 8 Ohms.
There also could be a misalignment of the plungers for the solenoids.
Here are two pages on the plunger adjustments. It is the same for the 60HP and 65HP models.

Good luck, Peter

 

Too Dogs

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 16, 2013
Messages
20
Thank You Peter. How do I check the selenoid resistance? Do I have to take the lower unit off?

Also, I just checked the Lwr. unit oil and it has water in it. I guess I have a gasket problem too. Could water in the lwr. cause the selenoids to short?-Thanks Again- TD
 

Too Dogs

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 16, 2013
Messages
20
Peter- thanks again.

I checked resistance by touching the green knife connector with the red lead on the V/O meter, black to ground and read 3.1 ohms. I did the same on the blue wire and read 5.8ohms.

Does the 3.1 indicate a bad selenoid?

I do not know about voltage in the lake, should I check?-Thanks TD
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Ohms test is a valid test, however I prefer to first do a voltage check. With key turned on, and control in neutral, check voltage on green wire that goes down to the lower unit (do not disconnect it for the test). Should be approximately battery voltage. Do same on blue wire AND green wire (separately) with control in reverse. Low voltage could mean bad shifter switch (common) or bad wiring.

That water in the oil is a bad sign. Don't be surprised if it is needing total lower unit rebuild.
 

kbait

Commander
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
2,488
I believe that the type 'c' lower lube used on those is special - it doesn't conduct electricity, so the solenoids can work correctly. If water gets in, it will conduct electricity, and could screw up the solenoid function..
 

Too Dogs

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 16, 2013
Messages
20
FR, from first post;
In the driveway, connected to a hose and muffs, the motor shifts fine and has 11+ and zero volts as required to the wiring (grn/blue wires)."

I drained and re-filled the lower, then measured resistance again and it came out the same. No water this time, didn't start motor or run water thru the lower.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Conductivity of the oil has nothing to do with the way the solenoids work !!!-----------Water has to do with the oil pressure side of how the unit shifts.
 

orbanp

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
324
Hi TD,

You need to fix that water ingression into the gearbox, oil/water mixture is not the preferred lubricant!
You really should do it now, using the motor like that the repair would get expensive...
The specs for the coils are between 5 and 6 Ohms, that is for a '70 60HP motor, same solenoid part numbers as for the '72 65HP.
So you need to investigate that why is one of the coils only 3.1 Ohm, there could be shorted turns in the solenoid wiring.
Adjusting the plungers as per the manual is also important. The plungers close ball valves in the gearcase, if not correctly adjusted, the ball valves do not close properly, there is no oil pressure to the piston for gear shifting.

Send a PM with your e-mail address, I can send you a couple of pages about the gearcase.
Not sure if the inclusion of those pages in my previous reply are legible enough.
After all, this is the "new and improved" version of the bulletin board.

Peter
 
Last edited:

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
FR, from first post;
In the driveway, connected to a hose and muffs, the motor shifts fine and has 11+ and zero volts as required to the wiring (grn/blue wires)."

I drained and re-filled the lower, then measured resistance again and it came out the same. No water this time, didn't start motor or run water thru the lower.

So you are telling us that it shifts in the driveway but not in the water?? That's interesting, to say the least. How about the prop, totally spun hub???

EDIT: Ignore the prop question. You said it has forward, so that ain't it.
 
Last edited:

Too Dogs

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 16, 2013
Messages
20
Yes, shifts fine in the driveway.

Yesterday, after it would not shift in the lake, I pulled it out of the water and started it on the ramp and it ran in all three; F,N,R.

I changed the oil yesterday. I drained the old oil, let it drain well and then refilled with the proper lube.

I don't think the hub is spun as I can see it turning in Fwd. in the lake and when I give it power, the boat pushes against the trailer causing the car to move. Same in R; moves the car as in F.

I'm puzzled by the, "shifts normally in the driveway, on the hose and muffs but does not shift in the lake".-TD
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Remove the lower unit.---Clamp it in a vice in the normal running position.---Now lightly grip the driveshaft with a vicegrip.( I use the special socket )---Now clip 12 volt black to the case and 12 volt positive to green wire.----It should shift to nuetral after about one quick turn of the driveshaft.-----Now put 12 volts to both wires and it should be in reverse after about 2 quick turns.---If it fails this test the unit needs work.
 
Top