Re: 1972 Chieftain MKIV 25 footer ver 2
Sorry, all my framing is primed and alkyd enamel painted not bare since SC decided to use ferrous T-bolts and screws. Everyone thinks that anything eats up aluminum but I've taken apart 100's if not 1000's of pieces, parts, nuts and bolts from tin boats. In my experience (not hearing it from somewhere) I've peeled off adhered silicone to see pristine both bare and painted aluminum surfaces under it. Seems that lots of boat owners try to use silicone. The silicone I used for bare aluminum is the DAP 3.0 without the acid that etches metal.
Not a lot of people hoping to seal a tin boat leak are actually looking for the acid free silicon. But they should be.
I personally simplify it to: Don't use silicone. I'd rather err on the side of caution, and it isn't bad advice.
I put it in the same category as foaming an aluminum fuel tank in at installation. Properly prepped, primed (?also debated?) & painted the paint protects the aluminum from any water that might get trapped in the foam against the tank. Unpainted aluminum tank, nope wouldn't foam it.
If the silicone lifts, and it often does, it'll trap water under it, possibly against bare aluminum. If water's trapped, it could allow corrosion to start, and if the silicon etched the aluminum as well, you've doubly lost the battle.
Not the war perhaps. As evidenced by several tin boat builds lately, corrosion is usually more pervasive & worse then expected once you start digging into a project, but it can often be overcome. Sometimes it takes some creativity and a well thought out plan, but it can be overcome.