1971 Johnson 50HP hydro shift problems with reverse running smoothly.

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
So I swapped out my lower unit recently. The new lower unit works great in Forward gear but is a little clunky in reverse. If i shift into it at low rpm sometimes it wants to die and there is a sweet spot with the throttle. if I got beyond the sweet spot it revs a ton but the power to prop cuts out. ( I wonder if this is a safety thing)...i'm wondering if my reverse gear is just completely messed up or if for some reason the electric shift wires are not supplying enough voltage to the solenoid?
any help is much appreciated.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
There should be no clunk when reverse is selected.----The oil pressure basically slams it into reverse instantly and that prevents wear and tear on reverse gear and the clutch dog.----To me it sounds like there are oil pressure problems or dirt in the shift piston bore.---OR someone has messed with adjustment of solenoid for some unknown reason.--Easy to fix in my opinion.----These units are very simple and well engineered in my opinion of course.
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
There should be no clunk when reverse is selected.----The oil pressure basically slams it into reverse instantly and that prevents wear and tear on reverse gear and the clutch dog.----To me it sounds like there are oil pressure problems or dirt in the shift piston bore.---OR someone has messed with adjustment of solenoid for some unknown reason.--Easy to fix in my opinion.----These units are very simple and well engineered in my opinion of course.

How would i check for an oil pressure problem? I just filled it up with brand new type-c oil.
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
I'll absolutely leave the internal of the LU to others.. I DO suggest you follow others advice before mine because I'm still new, but I also have a 71 50hp Hydro-Electric.

​As far as your question about the solenoids and the switch..
​No, there is no safety thing that limits or cuts out the prop in reverse..

Forward is the default if no power is to either solenoid.
​If power is supplied to the green wire only, then you should have neutral.
Sounds like that is working fine..
Power to BOTH green and blue wires is reverse.
​It's possible the shift switch has an issue. IF (and I do mean if) it has an issue, it'd probably be providing power to the blue wire for the reverse solenoid.
​If it's intermittent on the blue wire, then it'd clunk in and out of reverse/neutral..

​I'd check resistance on the solenoids by using a multimeter on green to ground, then blue to ground..
Both should be about 5-6 Ohms...

​Then I'd check continuity from the shift switch when in neutral and reverse..
​
​The big problem is IF (Again big if) the shift switch is bad, it's no longer available, and costs $$$$$$ if you can find one..
​My shift switch was toast, so I came up with a low budget solution which works well for me, so if you find you have a switch issue, let me know..
​I'll point you to what I did if you like..

Again.. I'm NO EXPERT here.. racerone IS a pro.. So are many others..
​I only offer this since I have the same engine too, and went through some of this myself...

​For what it's worth... :)
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
so I still have the old lower unit where both F/R worked fine....but the top of the drive shaft snapped off, hence replacing the entire lower unit.
Would it be worth it to pull the drive shaft off the one I have on now and put it into the old lower unit? Looking at the diagrams it seems daunting and like there are just so many parts to pull.
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
Ahh..
​Well if the old LU worked fine, then it's probably not the switch..
Still might be an issue with the reverse solenoid in the replacement LU. Might check the resistance anyway, but since I'm still very new, I'll go back to the shadows and leave it to the real pro's

​I apologize.. Didn't mean to intrude.. :cool:
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
Ahh..
​Well if the old LU worked fine, then it's probably not the switch..
Still might be an issue with the reverse solenoid in the replacement LU. Might check the resistance anyway, but since I'm still very new, I'll go back to the shadows and leave it to the real pro's

​I apologize.. Didn't mean to intrude.. :cool:

haha, any shed light is appreciated...even if it's from the shadows.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Always check the easy stuff first. Translated, that means electrical tests. And clean, correct oil is absolutely essential, since it doubles as the hydraulic fluid.
 
Top