1962 Evinrude 75hp run without tstat?

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
I have a 1962 evinrude 75hp after multiple weeks of diagnosis of the cooling system I have been through a new water impeller/ pump housing and new thermostat that was incredibly hard to find online and I still have overheating issues. So I was fed up and Took it to the local boat service shop here and what do ya know... they don't work on boats older than 80's models not enough money in the older boats. He suggested take the vernatherm/tstat out only if it was just a overheating issue. Well I got home and pulled it all apart and took everything out of the thermostat. Fired it up and it ran in water for 1.5 hours and never got above 120. So what's the deal it must be something in the tstat housing that is restricting the water flow and why does it run like a brand new engine without it. Even idles better.

Thoughts on this?

Can it really be that bad since the mechanic told me to do this?

The only thing I can see bad about not having it in is maybe
1. More carbon build up- which there are hundreds of products specifically for that.
2. More fuel consumption


PS I live deep in the heart of Texas and all lakes I run in are warm water.I Don't boat in the winter
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
The worst I can think of is that with constant flow of "Cool" water, the engine may not ever reach full operating temperature and so you might not get all the power out of it that it's rated for...,
​That's at least true in engines in general.. (Automotive etc...)
​I just don't know if there is anything specific to outboards that would be different than that.

​Personally, I'd still try to find out what was blocking it.. (too high a temp on t-stat?) and fix it so it's right, but it shouldn't "Hurt" the engine necessarily to run without it for a bit I wouldn't think.
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
Have you tested the stat in a pot of water to see when it is opening?

There is more to the temp control than just the stat. The stat really only controls the temp at low speeds. At higher speeds more cooling water is needed than what can flow through the stat so some spring loaded valves open to allow more water through.
 
Last edited:

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
Yes it opens up around 140 the tstat is brand new there is nothing in the passage way perfectly clean it pumps way more water. Before I took the tstat out I just had a fine mist coming through exhaust and when I took it out I had a nice stream coming out that was hot water. So it is cooling and before I couldn't touch the heads for more than a second without burning and with it out. I can hold my hand on it up to about 10 seconds till I feel it getting too hot to touch.
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
I have took 2 springs out that was in the thermostat housing so now there is nothing controlling how much water is going through. There is more than enough now I had up at 3,000 rpm for 30 minutes constant and never had a problem with the heat rising.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
You just totally messed up the cooling system. OK, it might work for you, but the fact remains, it is messed up. Let's start at the beginning. That motor has a thermostat controlled, recirculating cooling system to maintain a more or less ideal engine temperature. The water pump supplies water to the powerhead, and after circulating through the powerhead the water is presented to the thermostat to see if it is warm enough. If it is not warm enough, it forces open that second white valve and returns to the water pump for recirculation. But a bit is expelled out the exhaust to keep the exhaust cool. You will see that as a fine spray out the back.

Ok, now lets assume the thermostat decides it is warm enough. It opens the valve with the heavy spring, allowing water to discharge instead of returning to the pump. You will see a stronger spray out the back in this mode.

You must remember that the 'stat is constantly monitoring the water temp and opening and closing as required to maintain the ideal. It is NOT a matter of warming up, opening and staying open!! In fact, at idle speed it may not get warm enough to open at all. The point here is that the spray constantly varies in amount.

So, when you took all the innards out, you not only defeated the temperature control, you also opened the return path to the water pump. So, now part of the water is constantly being recirculated. That is the only reason it is getting as warm as it is. If you had not opened the return path all the water would be discharged and it would run very cool--somewhat depending on lake temperature. That would be an issue for our friends up north where the water temp gets only slightly above freezing.

I politely suggest you put it back together the way it was designed.

Otherwise, I just wasted a bunch of time typing all this.
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
"At idle speeds it won't open at all" then what's the point of it overheating within 5 minutes and with it out I ran it for over an hour with no problem what so ever. If my temperature never gets above 120 hell im happy with that because it was getting up to 220! Within MINUTES with the tstat in. As for carbon build up that's calling for stabil once a month.

I'm going off what the mechanic told me. This boat has costed me a total of $137 in parts as it was given to me. Not to worried about it if I fry the engine I fry the engine I have 2 boats and 2 jet skis. I just liked the fact that this one is antique. So I'll run her till she doesn't run any more. And I will buy a Motor after that.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
OK. Fair enough. As for what your mechanic told you, I was a mechanic for an Evinrude dealership when that motor was new and knew them backwards and forwards. If it is boiling within minutes, it might be wiser to figure out the real reason than to suggest something harmful to others' motors. Over and out.
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
What do you suggest? I have pulled the heads I have looked for blockages I have soaked in vinegar I have replaced parts hoses everything possible that I can do. Since nobody will work on a older boat motor. What would you do if it were YOUR boat. I understand you know the full workings of the motor I have but I don't have your skills. I have done what I am capable of doing and then started to go off of what the mechanic was telling me.
 

77kingfisher

Seaman
Joined
Apr 24, 2017
Messages
71
Ok im no expert and this could be messy. That being said im suggesting that you take out the t stat temporarily leaving the t stat housing off and run it both low speed and high. My theory here is if there is and debris in the water jackets that cant be ran through the stat or exhaust it can easily be pumped out. My other question is ok so you put a new impeller in, but did you clean out the water intakes?? If you have ignore the rest im covering my bases here because some people are over thinkers and future readers might be curios. Both the screen part and the side cover with the holes in them? Iv had great luck with a propane or map torch (DO NOT try to clean it with brake clean first!!! cause you know FIRE!!) and burning the screen out then blowing the crud out with compressed air. As for the side cover remove it and make sure you don't have some crud in there restricting flow. If your still having flow issues try cleaning your cooling system with neutra salt its volvo's cooling system cleaner and dosen't even seem to damage aluminum.
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
What do you suggest? I have pulled the heads I have looked for blockages I have soaked in vinegar I have replaced parts hoses everything possible that I can do. Since nobody will work on a older boat motor. .

One guy's antique is another guy's cheap old beater -- pass it along to somebody who wants a '62 Starflite. Offer it up on the Antique Outboard site (free or for what you have into it). Then find a cheap '80s or '90s motor to play around with (should be able to find a shop for backup too, if needed).

Of course the guy who buys it may be a newbie with lots of confidence and few skills (and no money), but so it goes.
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
Ok im no expert and this could be messy. That being said im suggesting that you take out the t stat temporarily leaving the t stat housing off and run it both low speed and high. My theory here is if there is and debris in the water jackets that cant be ran through the stat or exhaust it can easily be pumped out. My other question is ok so you put a new impeller in, but did you clean out the water intakes?? If you have ignore the rest im covering my bases here because some people are over thinkers and future readers might be curios. Both the screen part and the side cover with the holes in them? Iv had great luck with a propane or map torch (DO NOT try to clean it with brake clean first!!! cause you know FIRE!!) and burning the screen out then blowing the crud out with compressed air. As for the side cover remove it and make sure you don't have some crud in there restricting flow. If your still having flow issues try cleaning your cooling system with neutra salt its volvo's cooling system cleaner and dosen't even seem to damage aluminum.



​Okay I already have the thermostat removed so I took of the cover for the housing and water was shooting into the housing free of debris. I put it back together. as for the intake grate it looks brand new there definitely is no debris blocking the entrance of the water. there is only one water intake and its on the left side. I may now try to clean it with what you said but with this boat being raw water cooled what's the best way about for the engine to suck in the cleaner?
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
One guy's antique is another guy's cheap old beater -- pass it along to somebody who wants a '62 Starflite. Offer it up on the Antique Outboard site (free or for what you have into it). Then find a cheap '80s or '90s motor to play around with (should be able to find a shop for backup too, if needed).

Of course the guy who buys it may be a newbie with lots of confidence and few skills (and no money), but so it goes.

​A beater huh? if you were to see this motor you would jizz your pants over how clean it is... it is no beater. And you sir are no help by far. Just because some old guy that was about to pass away gave this boat to me for free does not mean I will turn around and give it to someone else for free. If you would like to help I'm hear to listen. FYI I know a a lot about engines just not one from 1962. What I do know is with the t stat out it is cooling about 100 degrees cooler. it takes a little longer to warm up and it burns a little more fuel other than that runs like a champ!
 

boobie

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 5, 2009
Messages
20,826
Blue, hang in there. I ask dumb questions. Is the thermostat installed correctly and not backwards ??
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
Yes I installed the thermostat correctly. With the nipple sticking up and it fits into the plastic plate with the spring on top. I removed the thermostat housing a little earlier and did notice some rusted flakes inside i picked it out then closed it up ran it some more checked and it was clean. I'm going to reinstall the tstat tomorrow after work to see if it is still overheating but without it, it runs so great!
 

77kingfisher

Seaman
Joined
Apr 24, 2017
Messages
71
Okay I already have the thermostat removed so I took of the cover for the housing and water was shooting into the housing free of debris. I put it back together. as for the intake grate it looks brand new there definitely is no debris blocking the entrance of the water. there is only one water intake and its on the left side. I may now try to clean it with what you said but with this boat being raw water cooled what's the best way about for the engine to suck in the cleaner?

Ok I would think water should be gushing out all over the floor more holy bat flaps Batman less im looking more for volume and less pressure. Try one more thing before the chemical cleaning remove your water passage cover from the top of the motor and look down in. On marine engine .com under model number 50525 (as close as you can get to your model) under crankcase and cylinder #44 is the cover #45 is the gasket. Pull the cover and you should be able to see your water jackets and if there is any buildup of minerals. As for entering the cleaner into the jacket id pour it in that same inspection port.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
That water intake on the side is not the main water intake. The main water intake is on the leading edge of the snout that sticks down behind the prop. If it or the screen is missing, it will overheat.
 

Bluemagoo42

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 23, 2017
Messages
17
Can someone explain to me how to add a picture to my post. It will not accept it for some reason and I need to put pics on so people can see what I'm talking about
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
Running without a stat can cause a condition called "cold seizing" which is caused by the pistons expanding faster than the block during warm up. This is a rather uncommon problem but it can happen. It is more likely to happen on a less worn engine than one that is "well used" since the clearances have opened up from when the engine was new. This would likely happen after the engine is started and then you head out with hammer down before things have warmed up (which it can't do because of the lack of a stat). The other reason for a stat is to ensure the engine is cooled "evenly". Water under pressure tends to take the path of least resistance so the upper cylinder may be deprived of sufficient cooling water while the lower cylinders get too much cooling. The stat was put there by the designers for a reason. There is another cause for the overheat. I can't see your engine so you need to follow the suggestions already offered.
 
Top