Johnson 115 1997 Ignition Circuit Problem

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Tried to start my 1997 Johnson 115 outboard the other day where it cranked 5-10 time then just quit. Did diagnostic check on the solenoid, key switch, and starter, all okay. Circuit has got continuity and voltage in all the right spots with exception that no power is getting to the instrument gauges yet it will not turn over. Stumped. Any ideas as to where else to look? BTW, all fuses are good.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
All fuses?.... Including the "in line power fuse" located a short distance from the starter solenoid within one of the smaller wires leading from the battery cable terminal (unless the design has changed)?
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Yes, the 20 amp in-line power fuse under the engine cover is good. I've got 12 volts to the battery connection on the key switch and got continuity from the key switch starter connection to the S connection on the solenoid. Got good continuity on the ground side of the solenoid also. Checked that the key switch for proper continuity at all key positions, yet I can't get power to the solenoid or to the fuel gauge and the RPM gauge. One would think the problem resides with the key switch but it tests out good at each key position.
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Also check neutral start switch which also tested out good because I had good continuity to the S connection on the solenoid. Also put the shifter in forward and reverse which broke the continuity as expected.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
You obviously know what you are doing, so I hesitate to say anything. But I gotta wonder--you keep saying "continuity". Are you making those tests as a continuity (Ohms) test, or are you actually testing the VOLTAGE at each test point (while attempting to start it)? It does make a difference, maybe enough difference to bamboozle you.

And I really, really, hate to ask this: Are you sure you're sure it isn't dirty or loose battery cable connections? Don't just look at them, take them apart and clean them shiny bright.
 

Chris1956

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 25, 2004
Messages
29,328
Batteries with one bad cell read good voltage with no load. Put a voltmeter on the battery posts and then turn the key. See if it goes below 8.5VDC. If so, starter is shorted, or more likely, battery is bad. If the battery voltage does not change, when the key is turned, the connections are dirty.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
You obviously know what you are doing, so I hesitate to say anything. But I gotta wonder--you keep saying "continuity". Are you making those tests as a continuity (Ohms) test, or are you actually testing the VOLTAGE at each test point (while attempting to start it)? It does make a difference, maybe enough difference to bamboozle you.And I really, really, hate to ask this: Are you sure you're sure it isn't dirty or loose battery cable connections? Don't just look at them, take them apart and clean them shiny bright.

That was going to be my next question but since F_R picked up on it, I'll just sit back without repetition on that area.

A voltmeter connected between the "B" terminal of the ignition switch to ground should read a strong 12v... BUT... if that 12v drops away when the key is turned to START = Bad battery, loose or dirty connection, something causing a voltage drop!

Run good known jumpers from a good know battery directly to the starter simply to make sure the starters okay.
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Wow, lots of good suggestions. Thanks everyone! I once worked in a marina as a mechanic's helper when I was a teenager some 40 years ago so I know my way around an engine a little bit.

With respect to the continuity question, I checked continuity (ohm resistance) on all wires coming to the key switch from their source to ensure none of the wires were broken creating an open circuit situation (battery power, accessory, starter, choke, and both magneto wires). Using the procedure described in the service manual, I removed the key switch and ran the continuity checks on the connections to ensure the key switch was not faulty. Also removed the starter solenoid and checked it to ensure it operated properly (clicked) when powered with 12 volts. The first thing I did with both batteries in the bilge was remove them, cleaned the terminals, and charged them up. I did not load test the batteries because they were new in 2016. I also did not connect 12 volts directly to the starter to see if it would turn over the motor because the starter was also new in 2016. Given Murphy's law that simple things make people look stupid, those items will be tomorrow's project.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Check those voltages while attempting to crank it, starting at some convenient point and work forward or back in the circuit according to what you find. For an example, if you find you have 12V at the "S" key switch terminal you know the power is getting at least that far, so go forward to the white wire posts on the solenoid. No voltage there? Then you know the problem is between the switch and solenoid. Etc, Etc.
 

Fed

Commander
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
2,457
And when testing always be aware of where you are testing the ground from.
Everything you have said so far point directly and only to the solenoid not having a connection to the battery negative via the block.
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Checked the battery voltage across the battery terminals with the key in the on position, start, and choke - had a good 12 volts. Pulled the batteries and loaded tested them at O'Reillys - check out good. Pulled the starter and also had it tested at O'Reilly's - test OK. Pulled and rechecked the solenoid - tested OK.

Now here's the weird part... Connected negative on the voltmeter to negative terminal on the battery and connected the positive to the key switch battery connection - had 12 volts. I then turned the key to "on" and battery voltage dropped immediately to 0 volts. Turned it to start - 0 volts. Pushed in the key to choke - 0 volts. Disconnected the purple wire that connects to the on position of the key switch and connected the voltmeter to the ON terminal - 0 volts with key in the OFF position and 12 volts with key in ON position. Turned the key to START - zero volts. Released key to ON position - 12 volts. Pushed in key to CHOKE - 0 volts. Confirmed wires were connected to the key switch in the correct positions - all OK. Something is causing the the voltage to drop out when the key is turned to on, choke, and start. Stumped more than before....
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
Still pretty new, and NOT very great with wiring etc... but I think I have to agree with Fed on this one..
I had a similar situation on mine (Older 50 hp, but...) not too long ago.. Would sometimes crank, then it just wouldn't. choke wouldn't even work... Sometimes it'd blow fuses Sometimes not.. ..
​Turned out I had a bad connection in my grounding lug on the engine (where the ground from battery bolted onto head) to the engine block..
​Had to take out and clean the post that you bolt on to..

​Point is, make sure the ground side wires, terminals, lugs etc are all clean and shiny and have next to 0 resistance.
​I found my lug issue by testing continuity (ohms) between the lug I bolt the negative cable on to the block, and the block itself..
​Would be low, but then jump around up to 3 mega ohms..

​Yours could be the lug, or the neg battery cable under the insulation (corrosion wicking the wires) or at the battery etc...

​Or any other ground wire/connection..

​For what it's worth, that's my relatively inexperienced 2 cents worth.. LOL

​Hope it helps even if just a little..
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Yep.....Sounds like a bad connection somewhere. You can get a 12v reading out of a bunch of AAA batteries but as soon as you hit START or turn something on, that'll drop to nothing. Best thing to do is to start removing all cables, wires, whatever pertaining to the starting system, including the battery terminals. Clean the terminal ends and also the components they attach to.... battery, solenoid, starter, ground, everything!

Tighten all nuts etc with a wrench or pliers... NOT with your hand if wing nuts are encountered.

Also.... run your hands down the length of the larger cables... a very hot spot indicates a cable possibly corroding internally.
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Another strange symptom is the RPM gauge is pegged despite that no power is getting to it. Could it have failed and causing these problems?
 

Chris1956

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 25, 2004
Messages
29,328
Probably not a tach problem. Your starter uses 100+ amps, which would melt the tach down, if it drew that much current. I still think you have a dirty or bad connection somewhere.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Well, have you taken any of the above expert advice and cleaned the cable/wire terminal ends and the components they attach to?
 

Fed

Commander
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
2,457
Key to ON with no voltage at the key switch. (B)

Test from battery negative to battery positive.
Test from battery negative to solenoid positive.
If you have power at the solenoid positive then the only things between it & the key switch is the fuse & the harness plug.
The fuse may be good but the connection of the fuse inside the holder may be bad, remove & inspect for bad connection.
The same goes for the pins & sockets inside the harness plug.
 

Chip884

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 16, 2016
Messages
15
Tested from battery neg to battery positive - 12 volts at key positions - ON, START, and CHOKE.
Tested from battery negative to solenoid positive - 0 volts at key positions - ON, START, and CHOKE.
Fuse inside holder is good, even replaced it just for the sake of it.
Cleaned all connections on the engine terminal block.
Will check all other connections whenever it decides to stop raining here in Michigan.
 

Fed

Commander
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
2,457
Tested from battery negative to solenoid positive - 0 volts at key positions - ON, START, and CHOKE.
Then the fault is between the battery positive and the solenoid positive, the big fat wire or the connections at either end of it.
Do you have a battery isolating switch?
 
Top