89 to 85 Evinrude powerhead swap

Flats Fishing Goon

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
10
So I've got an 89 evinrude 100 xp (V4 Crossflow Flatback) with the powerhead removed, I was going to rebuild the powerhead but im worried about the integrity of the cylinderwalls. There is quite a bit of corrosion on the outter walls. I've found an 85 evinrude 185 (V6 Crossflow Flatback) powerhead. Are the heads interchangeable and if im easy on the gas will the driveshaft and gear box hold up to the extra 85hp? Thoughts Please,
Thanks!
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
I think the 100 XP should be / came with the bubble exhaust.
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
Even if a V6 powerhead could be mounted on a V4 midsection, the Exhaust tuning would be all wrong. There would also be durability issues with the V4 gearcase, Full throttle runs would be needed to determine correct propping, which in itself would be a problem.
You mention corrosion on the 'outer walls'. Do you mean the in water jackets?

BTW, the 185hp is the old crank rated Too Thirsty Five(235), just prop rated
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
?-----I believe the 185 is the 200 hp with a new propshaft rating. Has 3.500 bore and not the 3.625 bore of the 235 HP model.
 

Flats Fishing Goon

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
10
Even if a V6 powerhead could be mounted on a V4 midsection, the Exhaust tuning would be all wrong. There would also be durability issues with the V4 gearcase, Full throttle runs would be needed to determine correct propping, which in itself would be a problem.
You mention corrosion on the 'outer walls'. Do you mean the in water jackets?

BTW, the 185hp is the old crank rated Too Thirsty Five(235), just prop rated

They are both flat back motors, and wouldn't the exhaust tuning be done on the power head itselft? Would the legs of the v4 and v6 truly be that different if the shaft lengths were the same? And let me get this right, the motor itself isn't 185hp but 235hp? 185 is hp at the prop? Also the prop from the 100 wouldn't work? Im going to ask the guy who's selling it to get me pictures of the exhaust ports to see if they are the same as mine. Yes the water jacket around the cylinders are some what corroded, the plan was to just rebuild the 100xp but im concerned that boring the cylinders will only cause more issue down the road. I can post pictures of the 100xp for some opinions on what route i should take.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
The 235 hp models were not --flatback motors---as far as I know.-----The 100 XP models were bubbleback motors.----Why do you think boring may cause problems ??
 

Flats Fishing Goon

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
10
I'm just concerned that the corrosion in the water jacket on top of the bore is going to take away to much integrity.. Pieces of the pistons broke off causing scoring in 2 of the cylinder walls. The plan was to rebuild this motor. The guy at the machine shop says the he believes he could get away with .30 or .40 over but I don't know. I'm just worried I'm investing into a lost cause. Just trying to weigh my options.. :thumb:
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
I was incorrect regarding the prop rating of the 185. In 1985 OMC was still crank rating the crossflow V6s and offered a 185(149cu in block) and a 235(160 cu in block). The 185 would have been a flatback, and racerone is right that the 235 was a bubble back. Though I'm not sure about the 100 XP having the bubbleback. I thought that was only on the 110, 112, 115(prop rated), 135, and 140 engines.
In 86 OMC started Prop Rating the V6 and relabeled the 235 as a 175.
The midsection of any V6 is larger than that of a crossflow V4.
Not all of the exhaust tuning is done up in the block, some engines have a megaphone that extends down in the midsection.
A V6 with 50% more displacement than the V4 is going to have a major increase in torque and the V4 gearcase internals will be steel filings in short order. The smaller dia V4 props will simply not have have enough blade area to keep from blowing out on acceleration.
You are worried about 'lost causes'. what do you think putting a V6 powerhead on a V4 midsection is?
 

Flats Fishing Goon

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
10
Thanks, that's all i wanted to know was weather or not it would work. I haven't worked on outboards enough to know that the midsections of similar models would be so different. I understand why 🖒

So I've recently come across a 2000 evinrude 135/V6. The guy wants $2500 for it, does that sounds like a good deal? I'm also wondering if it'll be too heavy for my boat. I own a 89 17.5' Hydrasport VS120 bass boat with an Evinrude 100xp V4.

Thanks again.
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
If that is one of the FICHT engines, don’t walk away from it, RUN!!! Those ticking bombs are a case of not will it blow up, but when
 

Flats Fishing Goon

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
May 21, 2017
Messages
10
If that is one of the FICHT engines, don?t walk away from it, RUN!!! Those ticking bombs are a case of not will it blow up, but when

I do beleive it as a FICHT engine, from the cowling it says Evinrude 135 Ram.. I've read alot of great reviews, but i did see a few reviews that stated having issues with the EMM. Could they really be that bad?

I've also talked to a guy who's selling an 85 evinrude 115 powerhead. Said he just rebuilt it and still needs to be ran through the break in process. The rebuild consisted of him having 2 cylinders bored .20 over. 2 new pistons, all new rings 2 new wrist pin caged bearings, gasket set and rebuilt carbs. Now i was going to go this route and buy this powerhead, he says it will fit on my 89 evinrude 100 leg, but being that he left 2 pistons from 1985 in the motor with the original wrist pin bearings and original main bearing im quite concerned. He's asking 900 and my 89 evinrude core for a new build. Would this be a reliable route? Im open to suggestions..
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
Ram was a name they gave the FICHT after all the trouble they had with it in 1998 and 1999. These were still troublesome. Rarely see any of them on the water around here. Mine 1998 FICHT received a complete 2001 Ram Powerhead as a warranty replacement. It had about 40 hours on it and already had, what the mechanic said "a neat little score" on one of the cylinders when I traded it. It was still under warranty so it didn't affect the trade in value.
To break-in a FICHT/Ram engine the ECM needs to be reset so it will meter extra oil during the break-in period.

A 1985 115 would be a prop rated powerhead, close to the crank rated 140. If it is an 85 115hp it will have a bubble back exhaust plate
 
Top