1959 super sea horse hard turn over

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
So I'm at a point where I don't know what to do next.
I'm hoping someone can tell me some reasons why my motor could be having trouble turning over. Both the electric starter and me both have major trouble getting the flywheel to rotate when trying to start.
Plugs out and it's fine. Almost as easy as my 9.5 sportwin.
The starter can rotate the flywheel but only at about 1 rotation a second or so. It gets resistance at what seems to be the compression strokes.
I know the coils aren't rubbing on the magnets because I fixed this already and torqued the flywheel to 60lbs afterwards.
The plugs are also not hitting the cylinders. I checked
I tipped the motor up and poured some oil in each open cylinder and used the starter without the plugs in to get it lubricated in there. It seems that most of it poured out into the area with the shift arm linkage and water pump.
I think the compression reliefs are mostly gummed up. They will hiss slightly when I rotated by hand and engage them.
I also hear a similar hissing internally at one point during the rotation of the flywheel.
The flywheel will encounter a lot of resistance that builds up and if I slowly rotate through it it will spring forward a bit then go back to the resistance.
It's in neutral when I try all of this

Any ideas? Could something be plugged up internally to cause this?
The impeller seemed to be in functioning order when I checked it out. Not sure when it ran last. I was told a year or 2 ago when I got it. Carb was very clean. It was winterized.
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Do basic prep. Disconnect and clean each wire connection, then reconnect. Start with the battery connections -- sandpaper them until shiny, and do the same with other connections in the starting circuit. You may find that the starter needs disassembly and cleaning, but do more basic prep first. Make sure you have a fully charged battery. You can test the starter by jumping from another battery or your car (positive to the stud on the starter, negative to the bracket.)

Take a compression test and see what you have -- plugs out. Spin until needle stops, and make a note of the reading.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Just so you know, the starters on those motors were just adequate and everything had to be right for them to have enough power to crank the motor. Do you know how to do a voltage drop test? That is the best way to find voltage loss in the system. Otherwise, do as oldboat said. Begin with the battery. Have it load tested. Many places will do that for free.

Then remove and clean all battery cable connections shiny bright. Hopefully by now you have found the problem. If not, you may have to look into the starter. Many will have thrown solder from over abuse. If it comes to replacing the starter, get one for a later 40hp motor. It will be taller and needs a bottom support bracket.

The compression relief valves are normally closed except when pulling the recoil starter rope.

NOTE: The screw holding the cable to the side of the motor is the ground cable connection.
 

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
So in my opinion if I'm out in the middle of a lake and my battery is dead for whatever reason then I should be able to use the pull cord to manually turn the motor over. At this point that is not an option. It's impossible to get the motor to turn over fast enough this way. When I pull the cord out it comes to pretty much a complete stop 4 times. If I keep pulling on the cord when it stops, the motor slowly hisses and the cord moves out 6 inches or so before hitting another wall.
I'm not all that concerned with the starter. I already took it apart and buffed off the little bit of rust on the surfaces and put it back together. It's not the reason why I can't turn the motor over quick enough to start it.

And reason why this could be happening and why on my 10 horse I encounter almost no resistance when starting? They both have compression
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
The 10 hp has the magic eliptical rope sheave to turn you into " high school wrasling champion "
 

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
Any educated guesses? Something inside that needs cleaning? The boat is registered to the end of the year which makes me think that someone used it within the last 2 years.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
If it turns nice and easy with the plugs out then there is no problem !---Other than a bad starter and weakness in your arms and shoulders.----Is the compression release working when recoil is operated ??
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Adjust the compression release valves so that a .020 gap exists... no more, no less, than .020 .

Does the underside of the manual starter resemble this setup?
71_18hpM-Starter_zpsa86a6cad.jpg
 
Last edited:

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
I tightened the compression valve screws so that no gap exists when at rest. If they are depressed too much does the valve close again? I thought if they got pushed in further when using the recoil that they might open up more and release more pressure.

I don't think it looks like that under the recoil. I'll take a picture after work. I know it has 3 teeth that engage when the cord is pulled that grab the "cog" that's held down with 3 bolts on the top of the flywheel.

It really feels like the compression is too much. It's like hitting a wall. I'm not that weak I don't think.
What could the hissing noise I hear inside during one part of the flywheel rotation. In sounds just like the compression release valve when it's working. A sputtery hiss only once during a rotation
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
The 0.020" gap is to ensure the compression relief valve are closed when the recoil is not being used. Zero gap could open the valves as the engine changes temperature.
Does the engine spin more easily without the spark plugs in? There will be some crankcase compression cycles still. If the engine is still hard to rotate, then you need to drop the gearcase to see if the problem is in the powerhead or the gearcase
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
The 35 has a large, round rope starter pulley. It is harder to to pull than a 10 hp because it has much larger pistons. The compression pressure is exerted on a much bigger area. Pie are square, or something like that, that we learned in 9th grade geometry class.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
I tightened the compression valve screws so that no gap exists when at rest. If they are depressed too much does the valve close again? I thought if they got pushed in further when using the recoil that they might open up more and release more pressure.

I don't think it looks like that under the recoil. I'll take a picture after work. I know it has 3 teeth that engage when the cord is pulled that grab the "cog" that's held down with 3 bolts on the top of the flywheel.

It really feels like the compression is too much. It's like hitting a wall. I'm not that weak I don't think.
What could the hissing noise I hear inside during one part of the flywheel rotation. In sounds just like the compression release valve when it's working. A sputtery hiss only once during a rotation

The compression release set at zero will allow the valve to open slightly as the temperature increases. This allows the combustion explosion to enter the small and thinner aluminum domes which will cause the domes to melt, burning the valve seat and blowing a hole in the domes.

Yes I know that the manual starter incorporates the 3 Pawl and Ratchet setup to grab and crank the flywheel. I was trying to call your attention to the fact that some pulleys Are Not Round where the rope attaches, hence the "aligning" marks when installing a starter cord..... This type cord setup compensates for the high compression by reducing the pulling power needed as the pistons go into compression mode.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Just for the heck of it, I crunched some numbers. A 10hp has 2-3/8" bore, making for 4.430 square inches of area on the piston top. Multiply that by a nominal 100 psi compression, gives 443 pounds of force you are pushing against when you pull the rope.

A 35hp has 3-1/16" bore, making for 7.855 squae inches of area on the piston top. Multiply that times a nominal 100 psi compression gives 785.5 pounds of force you are pushing against when you pull the rope (disregarding the compression relief valves)

Of course it pulls hard. I'm old enough to remember hand cranks on cars. Try that on a V8.

BTW, the compression relief does not vent to the outside atmosphere. It only vents into the closed chambers beside the valves. So they should not hiss. Well I suppose they could hiss if the o-rings are bad on the valve stems.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
I did not think the 35 had the eliptical sheave !------I give up on this thread !
 

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
Yeah I don't think it's oval to compensate for the compression. But I'll check later. I'll also back the screws out a little to adjust for temp if it ever get hot enough.
Ando it does turn over easy enough with the plugs out
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
racerone;n10447665[B said:
]I did not think the 35 had the elliptical sheave[/B] !------I give up on this thread !

I couldn't remember whether it did or not... probably not, hence the compression release valves and domes.

Now, why did you give up Racerone? :)
 

Globejs86

Seaman Apprentice
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 6, 2017
Messages
43
They made this motor come without the starter option. The rd-21 I believe. It must have been doable enough to sell it with the recoil only.

There shouldn't be much difference with the lower unit off if I'm trying in neutral. The only added resistance would be from the impeller right?
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
I've had a number of Big Twins and a couple of Johnson 35s (all electrics in my case), and I don't think I was EVER able to easily crank one with the recoil starter -- add that the compression relief never worked right as far as I could tell. I'm pretty sure the compression relief would have been an issue anyway, getting the thing to fire. I guess if it's tuned perfectly and warmed up, you should have a chance.

Both feet on the transom, both hands on the starter cord....

Plugs out is a different story though. If able to pull it over only with the plugs out, think I might tinker with the recoil starter a little -- maybe the top nut is too tight. Beyond that, I might be on the lookout for a donor starter, while getting the electric start system up to prime time. Kicker motor or a good set of oars is a good option, rather than that blasted recoil starter.

I like the idea of filling the cylinders with lubricant, and letting it leak down -- have used ATF on a couple of motors, and think it helped. I turned the flywheels by hand. Messy, but potentially effective.
 
Last edited:
Top