Garage find 1974 JOHNSON 40hp won't start.

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Hi everyone! Love the forum, been a long time lurker but but I feel I need to post because this motor is driving me insane. I recently purchased a 1974 Johnson 40hp pull start that the owner had in his basement for YEARS. This thing can't have more than 10 hours on it. The guy started it up when I bought it on the first pull. It sat for a few weeks before trying to start it again (when rigging up onto my boat) and now it won't start. I cleaned the carb twice, rebuilt with brand new oem kit. I got it to start a few days ago after trying for a while but it didn't idle for very long. Now it won't do a thing except *occasionally* backfire? Or spit out the back exhaust when I change the idle screw and try pulling again. Has a white spark on both plugs. I'm going to have a heart attack pulling this thing over and over again. Doesn't make any sense why nothing is happening when the motor is basically brand new. Please help. Haven't been on the water at all this summer. Please let me know if you need any additional info or would like pics of any parts. Not sure what to do but it shouldn't start on the first pull.
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Think you will want to change the impeller to make sure it's going to cool properly without an old pump disintegrating on you. I have to believe the PO had this motor prepped to run for you (guessing warmed up if it started on the first pull), and maybe he recently did the water pump. A little curious why you rebuilt the carb if it was running well when you picked it up -- might describe your procedure. The idle speed mix needle (air/fuel) should be set at about 1 turn from seated, and adjust from there when the motor warms up. Use a 50:1 oil mix.

I would measure spark again just to be sure -- should see about a half inch using an adjustable open tester. Maybe your starting procedure is the issue. Need to choke to cold start. Primer pump pushes fuel to carb for starting (should hear it). Bulb should be reasonably hard when carb is primed. Tank vent needs to be open.

pics would be nice if you get around to it (sounds like a nice find) -- hope you get it up and running,
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
Never wear yourself and the recoil starter out on any OMC motor. If it isn't running after 4 or 5 pulls there is something wrong with it or your procedure.
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Thanks, I rebuilt the carbs because after I brought it home it sat for two weeks and when I went to start it it wouldn't go. Priming the bulb poured gas out the front hole to the right of the carb throat. Nothing changed at all and nothing was done to the motor I'd don't know why it wouldn't start after the guy pulled it once and it fired up. It's a manual start. When it was running it spit plenty of water out the back exhaust holes.

What is the correct starting procedure? The guy did this:
-Prime bulb until hard
-Pull out Choke
-Pull starter

There isn't a priming pump since it's not an electric start right? Just the fuel pump with the fuel filter on it that leads to the carb. No electrical hookup to a primer or anything.
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
I'll try and post some pics. Need to host them somehwere I guess. Can't just upload from my phone directly.
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
One thing to note is that it looks like the float isn't hanging like it should but I'm not sure. Here is a pic. https://i.imgur.com/Z3IskeD.jpg
Looks like the little tab on the back of the float is really long keeping it from opening
https://i.imgur.com/sL9Avtj.jpg

It's weird, occasionally it will fire up but hardly ever and then die immediately and sometimes it sneezes out the back.
 
Last edited:

Michawilden

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Apr 4, 2015
Messages
153
Are you sure the coils have been replaced? If they are old than they can't be trusted. Sometimes they perform well, other times they spark on the wrong moment ( whick can cause the backfire) Look into that. I assume there is a hole in the flywheel where you can inspect\ adjust the ignition.
 

hardwater fisherman

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Mar 19, 2010
Messages
1,725
If it is a 1974 model then it will have 2 external coils which are pretty reliable. Both my 40hp from that era have the same coils that it left the factory with. If inspecting the driver coil, points and condensors then you need to remove the flywheel. Make sure the choke is closing and staying closed while trying to start it.
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
The motor has her clearly never been used or has only like 10 hours. No way it would be as clean as it is for being 40 years old. The cowling is in new condition.

How about the starting procedure? What is the correct one? The external coils on the outside are in good condition, no rust or anything.

I don't want to pull the flywheel and mess around in there if I don't have to. I don't see why anything would be messed up in there.
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Ok guys, thanks for talking it through with me! I swapped out the new float that looked wonky and replaced it with the old one but kept the new needle and seat. Motor started up after a few pulls making sure the choke was staying choked and now it starts on first pull, one handed. I also tightened the slow speed idle screw packing nut which wasn't fully in all the way and adjusted the needle/screw to 1 1/4 turns. Here's a video of it running. Does that idle sound right? Thanks again!

https://youtu.be/7JFMBsqKyO8
 

gm280

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
14,605
Ok guys, thanks for talking it through with me! I swapped out the new float that looked wonky and replaced it with the old one but kept the new needle and seat. Motor started up after a few pulls making sure the choke was staying choked and now it starts on first pull, one handed. I also tightened the slow speed idle screw packing nut which wasn't fully in all the way and adjusted the needle/screw to 1 1/4 turns. Here's a video of it running. Does that idle sound right? Thanks again!

https://youtu.be/7JFMBsqKyO8


Sounds pretty good. In fact it looks pretty much like my '76 40HP Johnson OB, but mine is electric start. Other then that, it seems laid out near identical. I completely tore mine down and completely rebuilt the entire engine with a new different paint job. If you care to see it, click on the engine link below and take a look. But your seems nice. :thumb: :thumb:

And please forgive me, :welcome: Gjkelley31 to iboats. Very nice to have you aboard...
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Sounds pretty good. In fact it looks pretty much like my '76 40HP Johnson OB, but mine is electric start. Other then that, it seems laid out near identical. I completely tore mine down and completely rebuilt the entire engine with a new different paint job. If you care to see it, click on the engine link below and take a look. But your seems nice. :thumb: :thumb:

And please forgive me, :welcome: Gjkelley31 to iboats. Very nice to have you aboard...

Thanks, I've been a long time lurker, I appreciate all the feedback. This forum really is great!

And I actually read through your entire rebuild post a few weeks ago. Your 40 looks so nice that I wouldn't want to use it for fear of dirtying it up! I would prefer electric start and I believe I could convert it right? but that seems like an involved (and expensive) job and I'd need a new flywheel etc but I don't know.

Thanks again!
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Hey! Think you got a keeper there.

That plastic screw on the leg just under the powerhead is the throttle idle stop. To my ear, sounds just a tad high (might try to set it a little lower). Sounds ready to run.
 

gm280

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
14,605
Thanks, I've been a long time lurker, I appreciate all the feedback. This forum really is great!

And I actually read through your entire rebuild post a few weeks ago. Your 40 looks so nice that I wouldn't want to use it for fear of dirtying it up! I would prefer electric start and I believe I could convert it right? but that seems like an involved (and expensive) job and I'd need a new flywheel etc but I don't know.

Thanks again!

Honestly, I don't know how many parts it would take to convert to electric start. Of course you need the starter, and the starter soleniod, and maybe a new flywheel. But beyond that, I honestly have no idea. But you could find those parts used on EBay maybe to keep the cost down. They probably used the same starer and starter soleniod on multiple engines, and probably even the flywheel, so those parts may not be so hard to find. :noidea:

Remember if you do a conversion, your old but good parts can be sold off to off set the costs as well. Just an idea.

Oh, if you ever need bearing and such, don't buy factory or OMC versions. They used off the self Timken type bearings and races and you can buy them locally and save a ton of money. Same things for some other parts as well.
 
Last edited:

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Honestly, I don't know how many parts it would take to convert to electric start. Of course you need the starter, and the starter soleniod, and maybe a new flywheel. But beyond that, I honestly have no idea. But you could find those parts used on EBay maybe to keep the cost down. They probably used the same starer and starter soleniod on multiple engines, and probably even the flywheel, so those parts may not be so hard to find. :noidea:

Remember if you do a conversion, your old but good parts can be sold off to off set the costs as well. Just an idea.

Oh, if you ever need bearing and such, don't buy factory or OMC versions. They used off the self Timken type bearings and races and you can buy them locally and save a ton of money. Same things for some other parts as well.

Thanks for the tips! I'll look into that stuff and see if I can make a spreadsheet of costs etc. I wasn't sure if I'd need new ignition set up or not under the flywheel. Probably an alternator and rectifier etc too.

Quick question since our motors are almost the same set up, does yours have bolt holes on the clamp bracket to bolt the motor to the transom? Or are these motors supposed to only be attached to the boat by the two clamps?
 
Last edited:

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Hey! Think you got a keeper there.

That plastic screw on the leg just under the powerhead is the throttle idle stop. To my ear, sounds just a tad high (might try to set it a little lower). Sounds ready to run.

You are talking about the nylon screw on the linkage where where the throttle control cable connects right? I'll see about adjusting thanks!
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
yup. Think it's counterclockwise to lower the idle (may need to move the lever a little by hand). When tuning, that throttle stop is usually set when adjusting the idle mix needle (top of the carb). I would set the throttle stop lower, then tweak the idle mix a little (clockwise -- leaner -- should increase rpms). Your idle mix might be close as is (idle speed should technically be around 650-700 rpms warmed up and in gear).
 

Gjkelley31

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 2, 2016
Messages
21
Is there a way to install a tach? I have an unopened one thats been on the shelf for years but don't know if that's a motor specific thing or how to even install it. Otherwise not really sure how to know what the rpms are
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
sorry -- can't help much on matching up a tach, but others here can help. (Test without a tach, though, is pretty much to get a smooth idle low enough to shift in and out of gear without either jarring or stalling. You may be very close to that.)

[ed. probably need an induction tach for your pull start model -- might do a search or two for one of those.]
 
Last edited:
Top