Yamaha F150 or F200

[Spec-ulator]

I currently have a 2003 SeaPro SV2100 with a 2-stroke Yamaha Saltwater series 2 200 and a "Bobs" jack plate on it. I am purchasing a 2007 Tide Water that will be rigged to my specs from the factory. My question is after having the 200 2-stroke, will the 150 four stroke make the boat seem under-powered? Is the horsepower difference equatable to just speed? I have heard that the four strokes are somewhat more sluggish than the two strokes. Is that true? Should I spend the extra money for the 200 four stroke (It's about a $4000 upgrade)?<br /><br />I guess what I would like to know is if I'm taking one step forward and two steps back if I get the four stroke 150 instead of the 200.<br /><br />Which ever motor I get it will have a (Bobs) jack plate. The new boat will also have a T-top versus my Sea Pro which does not.<br /><br />Any thoughts would be much appreciated!

 

[mattttt25]

Re: Yamaha F150 or F200

size/weight of new boat and max hp it will take? really need those questions answered.<br /><br />but yes, go with the 200. you'll be much happier on the water and when you go to sell.

 

[Spec-ulator]

Re: Yamaha F150 or F200

boat is 21.5' with 8' beam and weighs 1900 lbs dry according to the literature. Max HP is 200, but recommended is 150. Website is tidewaterboats.net <br /><br />I'm ordering a 2100 Bay Max Monday pending a check ride in another boat (with a 150 on it) at the Marina.<br /><br />Thanks for the reply...

 

[mattttt25]

Re: Yamaha F150 or F200

if 200 is max, the 150 may be sufficient. but i'd take a test drive before deciding. good luck-<br /><br />i take that back.... i had a 19.5' center console with a 150 on it. you want the 200.

 

[JRJ]

Re: Yamaha F150 or F200

I don't think you would see a $4K difference between an F150 and F200. The F150 will give better fuel economy.