Re: Which Fishfinder to Buy???
Welcome to iBoats.
1st off, make absolutly sure you do not want gps on at least one of the units. Even if you are on small lakes that are easy to navigate, marking those tree tops, etc that you found crappies in, and able to get right back there without going through a searching pattern, would be invaluable. If you use a handheld or other seperate gps, I'll get off the soapbox.
By fish id, you want the fish symbols? Most have that option so it can be turned off. Off may allow better viewing of signal to have any hope of guessing the species.
A HB DI unit might serve you well to identify structure and still have 2D for fish finding. A color HB DI unit (no gps) wouldn't leave allot of cash ($200) for the 2nd unit.
What are your old units? It might be better to upgrade only one unit for now, and wait on the 2nd one.