FORUM RULES UPDATED - The forum rules have been updated to continue to provide a friendly and safe environment for our member community. Please take a moment to review the updated rules and our terms of use and privacy policy. Click here for Forum Rules which has links to the 'terms of use' and 'privacy policy'.
Same thing happened to me with my 35hp mercury. I tried head gasket, checked the wather jacket for cracks, but it turned out that the bolts that secure down the power head to the lower unit had become a little loose over the years and was letting a little bit of water into the cylinders. I replaced the gasket($6) and everything is back to normal. Do you have water on both spark plugs?