Too much power???

kamora187

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
5
Hello,
I have a 12 ft Aluminum boat and think I have found the electric trolling motor that I want, but before dropping the cash I wanted to get some opinions. I am looking at the 24v 70lb Motorguide Brute wireless. My only concern is that this might be too much motor for slow trolling. I see guys talking about having a 45 or 55 on a 17ft bass boat and want the 70lb to get around quick when needed but dont want the lowest setting to be too fast to troll slow. I am guessing that some of you might have a similar setup and will have some thoughts about the power to weight ratio or also just comments about this choice of motor?
Thanks,
Travis
 

Tacklewasher

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Sep 18, 2002
Messages
1,588
Re: Too much power???

You will need to carry 2 batteries to power this which, in my mind, makes it a bit awkward for a 12 footer.

Also, unless I mis-read the ads, this is a bow-mount motor. Don't see them on 12 footers much as you usually see transom mount motors. Difference is are you trailering your boat or tossing it on the roof of a truck? Most bow-mount need some kind of plate that may get in the way of it being on top of the truck.

I've got a 14 foot tinny and am running a 46lb Motorguide. More than enough motor for trolling and getting off the lake quick. It is 12v so only needs one battery and is a transom mount. It also is a variable speed control so I can slow it down as much as I want. Nice for dragging flies around the lake when I don't feel like casting.
 

bkwapisz

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
441
Re: Too much power???

I have a small 12V 30# Minn Kota Walmart cheapie on my 14' tinny and it's MORE than sufficient for positioning, slow trolling and moving to and from the dock. I have it clamped on the bow via a small wooden adapter that I made so that the mounting surface is flat. I think I made it out of a little section of 2x4. Only needs one battery and goes all day (for a few days even) on one charge. I won't be winning any races, but it's quick on/off, 5 forward speeds (2 reverse) and it works well for our needs.

Just my $0.02.
 

kamora187

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Too much power???

Hey Thanks for the input. The boat is trailored so no worries about the bow mount getting in the way. So I wanted the 24v because I hear that you can get alot more time on the water between charges. And 70lb for a couple reasons. First on some of the lakes here you have to travel a little way from the ramp to get to some hot spots and if I am out a ways and need to get back quickly I will have a bit more speed to get it in quicker. I know that I would be just fine with a small motor, but more so just wondered if 70 would put me over the top when trying to troll slow. The motor is variable speeds so hopefully the lowest setting wont be too much. There are three bench seats the small one in the from would hold the batteries.

Thanks,
Travis
 

Boss Hawg

Lieutenant
Joined
Apr 9, 2009
Messages
1,433
Re: Too much power???

Hey Thanks for the input. The boat is trailored so no worries about the bow mount getting in the way. So I wanted the 24v because I hear that you can get alot more time on the water between charges. And 70lb for a couple reasons. First on some of the lakes here you have to travel a little way from the ramp to get to some hot spots and if I am out a ways and need to get back quickly I will have a bit more speed to get it in quicker. I know that I would be just fine with a small motor, but more so just wondered if 70 would put me over the top when trying to troll slow. The motor is variable speeds so hopefully the lowest setting wont be too much. There are three bench seats the small one in the from would hold the batteries.

Thanks,
Travis

I think its more than you need but better too much than not enough i guess:rolleyes:
I seriously doubt the lowest speed will be too fast for you-
I have the same motor as bkwapisz on the back of my 16' Deckboat to use in a emergency or just to move a short distance when i'm feeling lazy & don't want to start the main motor & it pushs it fine :cool:
IF it was me i'd look at a 55# 12 volt :)
 

kamora187

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Too much power???

I think its more than you need but better too much than not enough i guess:rolleyes:
I seriously doubt the lowest speed will be too fast for you-
I have the same motor as bkwapisz on the back of my 16' Deckboat to use in a emergency or just to move a short distance when i'm feeling lazy & don't want to start the main motor & it pushs it fine :cool:
IF it was me i'd look at a 55# 12 volt :)

Thanks Boss! I have not made my mind up 100% yet between the 55 or the 70 but am leaning heavily towards the 70, just for the extra "get the heck off the lake" need, and also because I hear that the 24v system lasts a lot longer. I am a rookie when it comes to owning a boat so just trying to get it right.
Appreciate the info!
Travis
 

kamora187

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Nov 16, 2009
Messages
5
Re: Too much power???

Well I finally made a decission, I went with the Motorguide bowmount 12v 50# wireless. It helped to get everyones input and that helped me decide that 50# will be more than enough but it will save me around $300.



Thanks!!

Travis
 

Boss Hawg

Lieutenant
Joined
Apr 9, 2009
Messages
1,433
Re: Too much power???

Well I finally made a decission, I went with the Motorguide bowmount 12v 50# wireless. It helped to get everyones input and that helped me decide that 50# will be more than enough but it will save me around $300.



Thanks!!

Travis

WOW- $300 will buy a bunch of beer to enjoy on your boat :D
Good luck :cool:
 
Top