Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

  • Rustoleum Marine

    Votes: 2 16.7%
  • Interlux Brightside

    Votes: 10 83.3%
  • The venerated "Other"

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12

lakelover

Rear Admiral
Joined
Mar 26, 2003
Messages
4,386
In researching my one-part painting options, so far I'm leaning toward either Interlux Brightside or Rustoleum Marine. For those of you with painting experience, which would you prefer, considering all aspects of ease of application, durability & resistance to fading etc.

I'd appreciate your thoughts to get a rank amateur pointed in the right direction.
 

bigbad 4cyl x2

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Messages
334
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

Brightside ,no brainer
 

BlueDL1000

Cadet
Joined
Jul 6, 2008
Messages
8
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

I have not used the rustoleum products, but had great results on my first restoration, using brightsides. Paint came out great and is holding up well.

I used a combination of spray (large areas) and roll/tip on components.
 

drewpster

Commander
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
2,059
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

The upper portions above the water line, including all the deck surfaces of the 'Nostalgic' boat in the link below were painted using Interlux Brightside. The hull was painted using Interlux Perfection, (two part). I also used all Interlux products for thinning and cleaning. Everything was sanded, prepped, and primed before painting. (Interlux Prekote for Brightside and the twp part primer for Perfection)

These are exceptional products and I will be using them again. You must follow Interlux's recommendations, because these paints take a little getting used to in application, but the result is outstanding.

Worth a few extra dollars everytime.
 

jonesg

Admiral
Joined
Feb 22, 2008
Messages
7,198
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

Interlux briteside costs a LOT more and its worth every penny.
I brushed mine on (transom) with a $2 disposable brush and it looks great.
 

lakelover

Rear Admiral
Joined
Mar 26, 2003
Messages
4,386
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

Looks pretty lopsided so far!
 

drewpster

Commander
Joined
Oct 17, 2006
Messages
2,059
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

I have noticed through the years in here that most folks struggle with the decision of what paint to use. I think that most guys have a hard time believing that a paint rolled and brushed on to a surface simply cannot have a deep smooth look like sprayed paints have. Most of us are novice painters, including me, and we sometimes get the idea that the only way to get a great paint job is by spraying. Another consideration is cost. People who have sprayed cars in the past know that paint is expensive. Not to mention the cost of all the prep products and materials needed to do a good job. Roll/ tip type marine paints, like Interlux products, are somewhat expensive as well. (about $60 qt.) It is understandable why hobby painters that use spray equipment would have a hard time spending that much for a roll on paint.
I use Interlux because it works as advertised. It can be applied using rollers and brushes and will render a completely smooth, deep, shine. I think the same holds true for other marine roll on paints like Petit, Awlgrip, Epifanes, System Three and others. These paints are specifically designed to be applied using rollers and brushes. In fact, Interlux claims their paints look better when applied with hand tools rather than spray equipment.
Marine paints are also specifically designed for the marine environment. They contain U. V inhibitors to protect against constant sun. They are also far superior to automotive paints in surface durability against scratches and chemicals.
I purposely sing the praises of these paints because in my experience they work, and work well. And they look outstanding.
Given all that, there are some challenges using these paints. Most of which are minor and easily overcome. One is the equipment you use. You need to use thin nap phenolic core rollers. Some have great results using common closed cell rollers. They will work but you have to be aware that the solvents in these paints are very strong and can cause some cheaper rollers and foams to fall apart. So spend a little more for quality tools. The same holds true for the brushes you use. Cheap brushes will work but again the solvents can damage them. So if you are doing a big job change them often. The bristles also need to be very fine to aid the paint flow-out and leave a smooth surface. I recommend natural bristles (china or badger hair). I have the same badger brush I have been using for years. It has held up very well.
Another consideration is painting techniques and the conditions you paint in. Interlux provides a ton of information on how to properly apply their paint including video of the process on their website. You need to follow the guidelines the paint manufacturers provide. Unfortunately these paints are not as easy to apply as latex house paint, but it is pretty close. The paint works best if it is applied evenly with a roller then lightly tipped off with a brush to remove the bubbles left by the roller. The solvents in the paint will then cause it to flow out and cure smooth. Weather conditions can also effect that process. If there is too much moisture in the air or dew falls on under cured paint it will dull the shine. If there is wind, even slight breeze, the solvent will flash faster and it can leave brush or roller marks in the paint. Temperature can also effect it. In very hot weather it is better to add a little thinner to the paint to aid paint flow. It is always better to prep ahead of time and apply the paint early in the morning after the dew burns off and before the wind stirs up. The surface to be painted needs to be prepped smooth and paint ready before painting actually begins. Remember a good paint job is 90% prep 10% paint. Get everything ready to go before the can gets opened.

Interlux's website has great guides on using all their products. Including videos! I suggest researching it.

http://www.yachtpaint.com/usa/

I know I sound like a Interlux sales rep. I assure you I am not. I had a great time putting the paint on 'Nostalgic' and a huge sense of accomplishment. Its a feeling like none other. I want everyone in the forum to get that same sense and I believe in these products.

enjoy
drewp
 
Last edited:

lakelover

Rear Admiral
Joined
Mar 26, 2003
Messages
4,386
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

Hey drewp,

fantastic post rich with advice and info. Thanks. I've done a fair amount of general painting, but you know how a boat is! You want it to be perfect (and secretly) impress people. Then you can say you did it. Given what I've read here and on various websites, I do believe I'll go with the Interlux Brightside.
 

erikgreen

Captain
Joined
Jan 8, 2007
Messages
3,105
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

I like the brightside as far as one part paints go, but I've noticed the West Marine brand stuff isn't too bad... one of their paints almost exactly matches the color of my faded gelcoat :)

Their stuff seems to level ok and looks nice and glossy with roll and tip.

The only problem with it (and apparently most other one part paints) is drying time... I mean the time to get fully hardened. It took weeks for my hardtop to dry, and in the meantime it was vulnerable to scratches and chips.

I'm not sure if the brightsides would be better, but I think next time I'll go with a two part paint just to be sure it hardens up relatively quickly.

Erik
 

tallcanadian

Captain
Joined
Sep 7, 2006
Messages
3,245
Re: Those who have painted - Preference for one part paint

For sure Brightsides. I did mine with it and it's in it's 3rd season with no fading. Awesome paint. Not sure if you are going to trailer your boat or leave it in the water. If leaving it in the water you will need a bottom paint. Remember Brightsides is a topside paint but weekend trips in the water will not hurt it a bit.
 
Top