Tach appears inaccurate ?

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
My pontoon has a 2004 Johnson 50hp 4str and I'm having a problem with rpm readings. First off when I bought the boat the tach would read 5400 rpm wide open when manual says should be around 6000 with a 13p prop, which it had. Replaced the prop with a flatter 10p recommended by a dealer who looked up the numbers in his catalog and now the rpm reads 5000 wot yet speed is a couple mph faster (18)! Go figure. Should have given me about 4-6 hundred more rpms. Now I'm thinking I may have a tach issue (2004 Bennington 18.5) so I bought one of those Tiny Tachs that hook to a spark plug wire, but that won't work as my motor is coil-on-plug, hence no high tension plug wires. Motor runs great. Starts right up, idles fine, and runs good throughout the power band. Does anyone have any advice how I can determine if my tach is reading right or maybe somewhere else I can hook the Tiny Tach to or do I just install it on my zero turn? Any input much appreciated.
Thanks,
Deke
 

Scott Danforth

Grumpy Vintage Moderator still playing with boats
Staff member
Joined
Jul 23, 2011
Messages
53,415
pull the cowl and use a photo tach to compare your dash tach (they are $11 on amazon).

on a pontoon, motor height is critical. too deep and you can over-load the mtoor
 

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
Thanks for the response. I'm a little lost here. Do I just point it at the flywheel? If so do I need to put some tape or something on it for the laser to count? Sounds like a handy gadget to have around.
Deke
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
They "look" at the rotating flywheel. A piece of white tape or a dab of white paint helps.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
I'm betting you may have a slight cavitation issue.
 

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
I'm betting you may have a slight cavitation issue.

I'm still awaiting the arrival of the laser tach counter so I can compare with my boat tach see what I'm dealing with here. Thanks for your response, but doesn't cavitation generally cause an increase in RPMs ?
Deke
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
There is a calibration dial at the back of the tach. Over time the contact wiper can become a bit corroded/dirty. Note the cujrrent setting and then sweep that dial back and forth (gently) several times and set it back to the original setting.
 

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
There is a calibration dial at the back of the tach. Over time the contact wiper can become a bit corroded/dirty. Note the cujrrent setting and then sweep that dial back and forth (gently) several times and set it back to the original setting.

Ah-so, Silvertip. Just the sort of thing I was looking for! Now, if I can squeeze this old body up in there...
Thanks,
Deke
 

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
Ah-so, Silvertip. Just the sort of thing I was looking for! Now, if I can squeeze this old body up in there...
Thanks,
Deke

I tried your suggestion, but no change was noted. Meanwhile I received my laser tach counter (Scotts suggestion) and same day I tried it out according to directions and it shows that my tach was reading pretty close to the same as laser counter (within 20 rpms at 5000) so my thoughts about the tach being inaccurate are closed.
So just to see what would happen I decided to replace the 11p prop back to the 13p that started all of this and now I'm maxing out at 4100 when previously when I used that same prop I was getting 5400 rpm!!! Even though the engine appears and sounds to running perfectly, I'm getting less and less rpms which is now leading me to think that my problem might be in the throttle itself. Is there any adjustment on the engine or control lever/cable that can be loose/worn and causing this phenomenon? Possibly where the throttle cable connects to the engine? Is this something I can troubleshoot while in shallow water or do I need to take the boat home? I did notice that it takes a good bit of throttle before I get an increase in rpm above idle. Seems to be some slop somewhere.
Help!
Deke
 

Sea Rider

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 20, 2008
Messages
12,345
Check if possible to wrap induction tach pick up wire signal somewhere prior IC is plugged to spark plug. issues to know : Bought that 50 HP brand new or it's a second hand one. If second hand, previous owner could have messed with throttle, carb, timing advance are out of correct factory synch and OB is not revving properly ? What's strange is the gradual rpm power loss..

How loaded was your toon when achieved those strange rpm readouts. what's the max HP that toon can handle ?

Once toon is on plane, fast displacement speed, whichever, check at which lower leg height is water flow passing by.

Is it passing above, under upper plate, middle of both plates or above lower plate as to check how much water drag lower leg is working with. The least water drag the heigher the rpm OB will achieve, that's without going to the other extreme for prop to aerate. Test on calm flat no wind water with OB trimmed to 90° for best prop thrust. Report your findings...

Happy Boating
 

DekeMeister

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 19, 2018
Messages
7
Check if possible to wrap induction tach pick up wire signal somewhere prior IC is plugged to spark plug. issues to know : Bought that 50 HP brand new or it's a second hand one. If second hand, previous owner could have messed with throttle, carb, timing advance are out of correct factory synch and OB is not revving properly ? What's strange is the gradual rpm power loss..

How loaded was your toon when achieved those strange rpm readouts. what's the max HP that toon can handle ?

Once toon is on plane, fast displacement speed, whichever, check at which lower leg height is water flow passing by.

Is it passing above, under upper plate, middle of both plates or above lower plate as to check how much water drag lower leg is working with. The least water drag the heigher the rpm OB will achieve, that's without going to the other extreme for prop to aerate. Test on calm flat no wind water with OB trimmed to 90° for best prop thrust. Report your findings...

Happy Boating

Thanks for the response. Motor is 2004 and came with the boat when new. Last test run was just me in it (180lbs) and only got 4000rpms. Lets see now, the motor starts, idles, and runs great so I doubt that is my problem yet my full power rpms keep dropping. Changing props gets erratic results with a decrease in rpm. Tach is good and tested accurate, so that is eliminated. However, there seems to be a lot of mechanical slop in the control so for lack of any better idea I'm going to focus on that, starting on the engine. Question: I've only had the cowling off the engine a couple times so I'm not real familiar in there. What I would like to check first is if when I go full forward throttle is if the butterfly is completely open, if I have visual access to it. Any words of wisdom here?
Thanks.
Deke
 
Top