Re: Pulling a tube problems
OK then, I think you have your solution. The tube checks out on a different boat -- check.
You have a speed prop and get a ton of bow rise -- check.
I would just pick up an aluminum 4 blade Solas Amita from iboats -- $100 bucks. Your only out a little money, and if you like how it performs overall, you then can step up to a nice stainless steel 4 blade, or go with the ultimate stainless steel 5-blade hi 5, from the performance shop. You then still have a high speed prop and have one for water sports.
You might also consider smart tabs or a foil to help with the bow rise on start up. People swear by the smart tabs and say they don't kill your top end. I have a foil, so I can't vouch for the tabs, but people love em and write droves about them.
However, trying a different prop is task number 1.