Cost wise, not sure any of them will qualify as "best bang for the buck", but Magemarine on Ebay is probably the cheapest by a little bit. Chris Carson is also a reasonable alternative and very good customer service. Both sell complete sets for $70 - $80. Boyesen is also another one but more expensive. As far as performance, they're all about the same. All of the aftermarket reeds are made from a composite or carbon fiber material. I don't know how long they will last, but I've seen some original reeds from the 1988 125HP motors that were original and looked almost brand new.
You can also check any of the local auction sites for good deals on Force lower units too.
1988 - 1989 85HP motors are 2:1 ratio. Note: The earlier 85HP were also 2:1 ratio but you have to check to be sure.
1990 - 1994 90HP - 120HP are 1.93:1 ratio. Note: Some of these units have a two piece drive shaft with a coupler. You need these for it to work on your rig.
150HP were all 1.93:1 ratio
1995 - 1999 120HP are 2.07:1 ratio, but I'm not sure that they will fit your motor as that are the Mercury style lower and use a different adapter plate on the bottom of the motor.
Note: When purchasing a lower, always check the gear ratio. You can do this by putting it into gear and turning the drive shaft. Put a mark the propeller or propeller shaft and the drive shaft. Turn the drive shaft until you see the propeller or propeller shaft start to turn. This takes up the slack in the clutch dogs. Put another mark on a lower unit case that lines up with the one on the drive shaft and another mark that lines up with the one on the propeller or propeller shaft. Turn the drive shaft. If it takes two turns of the drive shaft to make the propeller or prop shaft turn one time, you have a 2:1 ratio. If it takes 1 3/4 turns of the drive shaft to make the propeller or prop shaft turn one time, then you have a 1.73:1 ratio lower. You get the idea.