The reality with boats is that fixing any sort of damage is time off the water, trailering it to the city and taking my time away from me. The smallest fix that requires a professional is a huge hassle. If I had a fishing boat, I wouldn't care about shoes because they are set up completely differently. Our boat is for cruising and wakeboarding and skiing and that's pretty much it. I have a no shoes rule on the boat as well. If we go to a resort for dinner, people will bring their Crocks and sandles and put them back on when we get there. I really like the fact that you don't have to walk over the upholstery and that the manufacturers made the walk through at the transom. As for pontoons...a mediocre new one is 60k around me and when we add one to the fleet, we will continue with the no shoes rule. Even if I had an ultra cheapo 30k model, I would still have a no shoes rule given there are many opportunities to put feet up. Pontoons rule our lake and the prices have become very high. Shoes cause premature wear and tear and we keep our stuff longer than most folks. When given the choice between something with wear and tear or without wear and tear, I choose without.