John, the purpose of the timing fixture is NOT to set set the timing in relation to TDC. The purpose is to make the points break at the precise correct time as the magnets pass the coils. If you did it right, that is happening, no matter what the points gap is.
Do me a favor and set the points according to the timing fixture method, then measure the gap without changing anything except to position it so the points are on highest area of the cam. They should be somewhere in the vicinity of .020" If they are WAY, WAY off, either you are doing it wrong, or you got a defective timing fixture. That never has happened yet, with all the many I've made, but it is possible. I would have had to be drunk when I put it together, and I don't drink. Personally, I suspect you are getting faulty meter readings due to poor test lead connections to the points or armature plate. Or you are letting the armature plate rotate as you adjust the points.
EDIT: I just read your post where you said you got it working. That bothers me. Send the timing fixture back to me for inspection. I'll pay the postage. Or give you a complete refund if that is what you prefer. I still don't drink.