step 1.... do you or don't you see 12 volts arriving at the selenoid control post (from the start switch) when you turn the key to START... if yes proceed to step 2 if no... find out why by working back to the switch
step2- if you do get 12volts on the control post when you turn the key apply a ground manually on the other small control post post (not the big ones handling high amp bat +12 !!!!!!!) IF it fires the starter then you have a missing ground and you need to track it down why (bad wire, bad neutral switch, bad connection ground side of the neutral switch etc....)
http://www.aomci.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=15012
go to the aomci site and look up the picture in the JAVALIN 35hp issue you will see an example of how the selenoid is wired..essentially waiting for 12v from the START switch but having a ground source with 2 protections... both are normally closed allowing the ground to reach the selenoid's 2nd small post
Either device would go OPEN in case the selenoid needs to be prevented from starting the starter. ....
if your start key 12v source reaches the selenoid post you are likely missing a ground condition due to broken wiring, or bad safety interruptors .
You need to get yourself a 15$ volt/ohm meter and learn how to use it if your are not familiar with one. It is not a hard issue to resolve and learning how to use the meter will in the long run save you hundreds of $$$