MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

WEYLAND2

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 16, 2003
Messages
1
HEY GUYS, I NEED SOME ADVICE FROM SOME EXPERTS ABOUT OUTBOARDS. I BOUGHT MY FAMILY'S OLD SKI BOAT FROM MY PARENTS LAST YEAR. IT HAS BEEN SITTING IN THE GARAGE FOR ABOUT 10 YEARS. THE MOTOR IS A 1977,78 JOHNSON SEAHORSE 175HP OUTBOARD. MY FATHER AND I CHANGED THE OIL, GAS AND PLUGS AND CRANKED THE ENGINE UP. THE OLD GIRL FIRED UP LIKE A CHAMP (EVEN AFTER ALL THESE YEARS). I TOOK HER OUT AND WHEN YOU PUT HER IN GEAR THE ENGINE WOULD CUT OFF. SHE WILL CRANK RIGHT BACK UP AND IDLE AS GOOD AS SHE EVER HAS BUT WHEN YOU PUT HER IN GEAR SHE WILL SHUT OFF. WHEN YOU CAN GET THE MOTOR INTO GEAR SHE WILL STILL RUN ABOUT 55 MPH BUT JUST KEEPS HAVING THE PROBLEM GETTING FROM IDLE INTO GEAR.I TOOK THE BOAT TO THE DEALER AND THEY SAID IT WAS A CARB PROBLEM, SO THEY REBUILT THEM ($400). IT DIDN'T FIX IT. I FINALLY TOOK IT TWO DEALERS TO CHECK THE COMPRESSION AND THEY BOTH AGREED THAT THE MOTOR NEEDED REBUILDING ($2500). STILL NOT TRUSTING THEM I BOUGHT A COMPRESSION TESTED AND CHECKED THE COMPRESSION MYSELF. I HAVE 5 CYLINDERS AT 90-95% AND ONE AT ABOUT 40% (I BELIEVE IT IS NUMBER ONE CYLINDER--BOTTOM RIGHT HAND SIDE). IS THIS THE REASON THE ENGINE WILL NOT GO INTO GEAR AND WHAT CAN I DO TO FIX IT? DO I NEED TO TOTALLY REBUILD THE ENGINE OR IS THERE A WAY TO SALVAGE COMPRESSION IN THIS CYLINDER? I HAVE TALKED TO DEALERS ALL OVER FLORIDA, SOME SAY I NEED TO JUST SCRAP THE ENGINE AND PUT A NEW ONE ON ($1500-$6000), SOME SAY THAT THE SEAHORSE IS A GOOD ENGINE I JUST NEED TO PUT NEW RINGS IN IT ($2000), AND OTHERS SAY I NEED TO REPLACE THE POWERHEAD ($2500-3000). WHAT DO I DO. IS MY ENGINE THAT RUNS THAT HARD AND EXPENSIVE TO FIX. CAN I FIX THIS PROBLEM MYSELF AND WHAT TYPE OF MANUALS SHOULD I USE? I WOULD GREATLY APPRECIATE SOME ADVICE FROM EXPERTS WHO ARE NOT WANTING A CHECK FROM ME.
 

Dhadley

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 4, 2001
Messages
16,978
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

STOP SHOUTING!! Youre not helping my headache!<br /><br />The bottom "right" (starboard) is number 5. Pull the heads and lets take a peek. cant hurt and we will learn more about whats really going on.<br /><br />Let us know what you see!
 

Kenny Bush

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Mar 24, 2002
Messages
564
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

Man your in a predicament.......... But its OK.. We have all been there before. Now, I wish I knew what your compression was on each cylinder, in pounds. As stated earlier, your problem cylinder is number 5, not 1. All six cylinders should be about 120 lbs. If you have a cylinder that is more than 15% less, it is time to rebuild. Rebuilt powerheads can run up to $3500.00 . So as stated earlier, lets pull the head on the starboard side and look at the cylinder walls. This observation will decide your course of action. If it is clean, no scoring, you can problably get out cheaper be letting a local shop rebuild it. Post back with your compression readings...
 

Fouled Plug

Ensign
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
935
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

You may also want to try a can of Mercury's Power Tune as a decarb treatment. Possible after 10 years of storage the rings are stuck. Not likely to be a miracle cure, but what do you have to lose?
 

St. Bennett

Cadet
Joined
Jun 15, 2003
Messages
21
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

Also, check your fuel tank, if there isn't a mesh net on the end of the fuel distribution stick, then your may have encountered some problems with debris. This could lead to more problems with cylinder walls or cylinder sleeves. It's a good place to start.
 

Sal G

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
May 30, 2003
Messages
76
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

I have a similar problem with my 140 rude.<br />Stalls when put in gear<br />I would start smaall and work upwards.<br />De-carbing the engine is good advice.<br />You claim you changed the fuel - does that mean you drained the tank dry? If you haven't, check to see if water is still in the tank. Open up your fuel separator and dump fuel into a clear jar.You'll see water at the bottom of the jar if any.Amazing what a little water can do to an outboards performance. A boat that hits 55mph can't be in that bad of shape. That's common sense.<br />Check to see if you are idling at the right speed.<br />Maybe you can turn it up a notch just to get her going.(easy though, you don't what to overload the lower unit)
 

SeaMasterZ@aol.com

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 21, 2003
Messages
1,924
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

well ... two thoughts<br /><br />One ... that motor should kick azz running on five holes, with one weakling ... 55 MPH on five aint bad, kiddo!<br /><br />and<br /><br />Two: take her down, hone out #5, put fresh rings in and GO, hey, its a mickey mouse fix, but why rebuild it for one sloppy hole?<br /><br />but first, Ive read that a lot of guys have good luck with this Deep Creep decarb deal, apparently the rings get stuck, do a search on decarb and youll find a lot of info<br /><br />good luck!
 

SeaMasterZ@aol.com

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
May 21, 2003
Messages
1,924
Re: MOTOR STILL RUNNING FINE BUT HAS LOST SOME COMPRESSION IN ONECYLINDER

how did the decarbing work out?
 
Top