major overhaul 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp?

wkisting

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 16, 2004
Messages
16
I'm in the process of stripping down and rebuilding a 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp outboard motor. At present, I have removed the carburetor, intake manifold, head, flywheel, magneto, armature plate, and starter hood. Aside from pulling the head off, the powerhead is still intact and on the motor.<br /><br />I'm wondering... How difficult a job is it to remove the powerhead to inspect/service the pistons, bearings, rings, etc.? I feel like I should do this since I'm so far into the engine already, but is it unlikely I (a novice) can do a good/accurate job servicing and reinstalling everything without sophisticated equipment to measure bore, wear, etc.? Should I be taking the powerhead to a small engine repair expert instead? (Yes, I do have the Seloc manual, by the way).<br /><br />Next, the spark plugs I removed from the head (2 of them) do not match exactly. One is "J6C" and one is "J6J"... The Seloc manual specifies "J6J", so what is the "J6C" plug? Do the top and bottom piston really use a different plug, or is one of them improperly installed (I just bought this engine from a marina, haven't run it yet), or is "J6C" a new code for essentially the same plug?<br /><br />Also, the 2 coils on the magneto do not match. One appears to be coated metal or ceramic (hard rough texture) while the other appears to be a (newer?) plastic coated coil. I'm guessing one is a replacement put there by the last person to service the engine, so could this be why the spark plug codes don't match? Should I be replacing the other coil and plug?<br /><br />Lastly, any tips for removing stuck screws that go into the exhaust cover and the powerhead? Some are EXTREMELY tight and refuse to break loose.<br /><br />Thanks so much for any feedback,<br /><br />Wes
 

Paul Moir

Admiral
Joined
Nov 5, 2002
Messages
6,847
Re: major overhaul 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp?

Welcome to Iboats, Wesley!<br /><br />I'm of the opinion you shouldn't disassemble a powerhead just to inspect it. It's like surgery, and you'll just end up contaminating it. On the other hand, if you can get a hold of a new set of rings for the pistons, it can be worth while to 'freshen' the powerhead with them if your compression could use improving. Of course, you'll also need a new head gasket, the appropriate sealer for the crankcase halves, and an inch-lb reading torque wrench to put it all back together. You'll need some sort of gauge too to check your bore clearances, or your work will be wasted.<br />The best idea is to get a hold of a compression tester, pop the flywheel back on (no need to torque it) and check your compression. If it's good, then don't tear it apart.<br />Since your 5.5hp engine has to have it's powerhead removed to access the shift coupler so the impeller can be serviced, the powerhead should come off pretty easily. The head, bypass covers and crank halves will doubtless come apart with no problem either. I would hesitate to remove the exhaust cover, since you are very likely to break a screw or two removing it.<br />The J6C spark plug is an update of the J6J spark plug. The J6J is no longer made, but the J6C is a perfect replacement for it. It's just got a slightly different ground electrode design. <br />The ignition coils are known to fail, and replacements are frequent. When one coil fails, both should be replaced. Clearly someone hasn't done this once. The coils fail by having their insulation crack and then they arc over, often only at higher RPM. If your coils don't have cracks, and they can produce sparks 3/8" long they're good. There have been many designs of these coils over the years - better than others. Since they're so common, they're also inexpensive. I think IBoats wants around $17 each for them, and NAPA not much more. Different coils do not require different plugs.<br /><br />For removing stuck screws - the tools for the job are heat and an impact driver. Liberally heat the bolt with a propane torch and then try removing it. Don't worry, it's nearly impossible to heat the block enough to cause the aluminum to melt with just propane. An impact driver looks like an oversized screwdriver that you hit with a hammer, and I find it's an essential tool when working on old outboards.<br /><br />Good luck!
 

wkisting

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Oct 16, 2004
Messages
16
Re: major overhaul 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp?

Thanks so much for the info!
 

OBJ

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 27, 2002
Messages
10,161
Re: major overhaul 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp?

Wes....just to add to Pauls' good info....if you do decide to "get into it", I would really recommend getting a reprint of the original OEM service manual. The generics, Seloc and Clymers, can be very general and may not give the specific info you need. If you want a reprint of the manuals....check out the sites below. Good luck!!<br /><br /> http://ww3.kencook.com/evinrudejohnsonmanuals/ <br /><br /> http://www.marineengine.com/manuals/evinrude/order_pre-1980.html
 

Chinewalker

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Aug 19, 2001
Messages
8,902
Re: major overhaul 1959 Evinrude 5.5 hp?

Hi Wesley,<br /> I think the old adage, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" works here regarding the powerhead rebuild. Paul is right on - do a compression check and go from there. Sometimes a simple decarbon will bring the compression up on those old motors because of all the carbon that can be found in them.<br /> Another thing to look for on those old 5.5s is rod play. If while you're turning the powehead over, one piston stays at top dead center longer than the other, there may be some wear to one of the connecting rod bearings at either the crank or wrist pin end. A lot of those motors have ventilated crankcases due to connecting rods flying out at high velocity, usually caused by running them excessively lean on oil (do NOT run that motor on 50:1 mix! 24:1 only!), or running them too hard (don't try to push a 16-footer with four guys, coolers, gear, etc. at wide open all day).<br /> As for the coils, as long as neither one is cracked, they're probably good to go.... <br />- Scott
 
Top