Re: How can I tell if my engine is making the amount of power it should?
usually they are stamped on the backside of the prop. my boat has the same load rating, and if i were to have to run w/ a full load often, i'd get a 14x15. at full load my boat struggles to get on plane even w/the 17" pitch. my usual load includes me, wife, 6 yr old son, and a jack russell, and the 19 pops us on plane quickly.
the diameter is not going to change the performance as much as the pitch will.
how does your boat perform w/ just you in it? you need to check and see if your tach accurate before swapping props, and make sure the engine is tuned properly.