While we are at it, why don't we bash "whale tails" and Ethanol in gasoline. And then for good measure, let's "discuss" merits of various TWC-3 oils.
Like any other product, there will be lovers and haters--just look at the Ford-Chevy-Chrysler-Toyota people.
Bearing buddies have their place and are neither as good as nor as bad as some will make them out to be. I have trailers with posi-lube and bearing buddies systems and am satisfied with both.
In fact, I had a trailer with leaking rear seals ( From wear) and bearing buddies. Too lazy to pull the hubs and replace the seals, I simply filled the bearing buddies with grease before each trip and dragged the boat the 35 mile round trip. The bearings lasted for 25 years and I only retired the trailer when I acquired a much heavier duty trailer for the boat--the original bearings are still good on the retired and disassembled trailer. I may yet change the seals. BTW: The all steel fenders were never in danger of rusting with their undercoat of "rust preventative" LOL