If you have a look in this section, you'll see that I've been here for a long, long time, helping people figure out what they have and how to get parts to fix what they have. In fact, in this very thread, I posted information to help Eska owners identify their outboards and find parts for them.>
Entirely true----for which I applaud you!
Here's what I've seen in Other Outboards here on iboats:
<1. Most of the people who ask questions here have bought an old Eska-based, or Clinton-based outboard that is private-branded, really cheaply, and they're trying to fix it to use on their boat.>
True.
<2. Most of them are inexperienced with working on outboards and air cooled two-stroke engines.>
<3. Most the the outboards they're asking about are at least 25 years old and made by companies that are no longer in existence. Most have engines that originated on lawnmowers.>
This too is largely true but frankly I consider a 25 year old engine as 'virtually new' from my own unique perspective. As with ALL orphaned outboards there will be times when finding a particular part becomes a bit if a
waiting game. Truth to tell I enjoy the search for obsolete parts in much the same manner as treasure hunting---an undeniable thrill when I "Strike it rich".
<4. Few of these posters have come back later and told us how easy it was to repair their outboard and how reliable that outboard has been for them. Most, quite frankly, have given up on their bargain "find" and have moved on to something a little easier to deal with.>
While true in basic essence we should try to bear in mind that very often indeed those bargain "finds" are OMC or other 'major' makers. I have noted in the short time that I've been aboard that there are almost as many posts concerning Gale Products such as Sea King and MANY others as the air-cooled motors. And many of them too are abandoned when the newbie runs head-on into his own wall of ignorance and general parts availability. Frankly I'm quite a fan of the OMC built Gales that followed WW2 up until 1963 when OMC figured out that they were competing in too many respects with the OMC 'high-priced spreads' of Evinrude and Johnson.
<Those rebranded air-cooled outboards were great when they were new. They were less expensive, ran just fine, and weighed less than the equivalent Mercury or Evinrude or Johnson or Scott-Atwater. Millions of them were sold. The ones for sale today are, for the most part, worn out, used up,in dire need of repair.>
I readily agree with "---in dire need of repair". Where my brakes lock up is with "The ones for sale today are, for the most part, worn out, used up,".
Such has not been my experience to date as far as the Tecumseh powerhead is concerned. IME most of them are in great mechanical condition and can be readily tuned-up to start and run easily and satisfactorily. I admit that could be a function of the different parts of the nation we live in.
You in the water wonderland of MN and I on the North central Ozark Plateau of Arkansas. We have many more rocky streams than lakes and that is reflected in the banged up cavitation plates, L/Us and skegs I so commonly encounter.
<For someone like yourself, or even me, they're a fun challenge and an interesting project. But that's not who's asking questions here. The people asking questions here are trying to go boating on a budget. They're not small engine mechanics. They're not tinkerers. They just want to go boating.
For them, a used up air-cooled outboard that needs work is a very bad bargain. They not only have to locate parts, manuals, etc., but don't have the experience needed to actually know what the heck to do with these things. We try to help here on iboats, but the result is usually the same. The outboard isn't repaired, even though money is spent on parts, etc., and we end up with a frustrated boater.
Up in the Johnson Evinrude forum, there are lots of nice folks that will talk someone, step-by-step through getting their JW-13 going again. They can get the parts easily, and there are people here who know those outboards inside and out.
Not so in the Other Outboards forum. That's why I'm here. I can at least direct people to parts sources and information sources. But, for new boaters, who just want to get on the water, I don't recommend a broken air-cooled outboard. It's a bad choice. It can be a terrible choice...one that leads the newcomer to abandon boating altogether.
But I'm still coming here and offering what help I can, with identification and parts sources. I've been doing that for some time. I'm not here in the Winter, but as soon as boating season begins, I'm back.
So, if you're sincere about helping people fix their Eskas and Clintons, I hope you'll be here every day, offering advice based on your experience. Heaven knows the many people who show up here need that kind of hand-holding help. Many don't know the names of the tools they'll need, much less how to use them. If you can help, more power to you.
But, I'll be here, in any case, offering what help I can. Sometimes, my suggestion to someone who has no experience is to get rid of their cheap anchor and go buy a running outboard.
It's all my opinion. You may have a different one. You're welcome to share it.