Forklift dropped boat on ground - damage?

Status
Not open for further replies.

SeaSteamer

Recruit
Joined
Jun 3, 2022
Messages
1
The bow of the boat was dropped about 1-2ft onto the forklift arms and ground. Besides obvious cosmetic damage, what other possible damage could have occurred that would be hard to see? One toon got a 3X2 size dent on the starboard bow exterior area. I looked at welds and they look ok. Anything else I should be concerned about? Only the bow was dropped so stern and motor should be fine.

Here’s the full story if you need pleasure reading.

I have a 10-year-old pontoon that I bought used a few months ago. Has normal wear and tear, toons had no damage… until this week.

I’ve had the boat at a marina for a month, it’s a forklift operation. I had to provide my own blocks for the boat to sit on. The marina owner (the same guy who drives the forklift) recommended that I use the Attwood pontoon storage blocks, $100 for 4, easy enough. There was one other pontoon in the marina on the same blocks, and several other pontoons were on larger EPS foam blocks.

We lined up blocks for the first drop off from the trailer with the boat hovering just above them. After the first outing, the boat was put on blocks without me there and was a bit off, the midpoint of the toon with metal was not sitting in one of the block grooves. I mentioned it to the owner. He kicked the block back into position.

Next outing when the boat was being brought off the water back to the blocks, I told the owner it looked like blocks had moved so we should probably line them up again to be safe. We did.

Next outing I go out with wife and 3 kids in tow, nice morning on the water. Marina is empty, I’m the only boater there on return, no hurry. The boat comes off water and as it’s being put down by forklift I can see the stern is lined up on blocks (all the forklift driver can see) but I can see one of the front bow blocks is off so much I’m not sure the toon is even going to make contact, and as I start to holler for him to stop, he releases the hydraulic and boat rapidly descends, all toons make contact but bow section of toons quickly disconnects from front blocks and slips off crashing about a foot or two onto the forklift arms and the ground.

Owner raises forklift, we adjust blocks and boat is re-lowered. The owner then parks forklift and walks back into the office, business as usual. Yeah. Meanwhile, I’m inspecting boat and immediately see a large dent in one of the toons, obviously caused by the ground impact. Needless to say, my mindset is not good.

My wife and kids are sitting in the car. I’m starving and worn out from the water. I make the decision to hold off on confronting him about the incident that just happened until I’ve had more time to process it and know I’m able to calmly have a rational conversation.

From what I’ve read, the dent is best left alone if it’s just cosmetic. What’s done is done and I’m willing to let it go. The stern of the boat was on the blocks and just the front fell so there shouldn't be any issues with the motor. I haven't put the boat on the water yet, but thinking it's going to be okay. Though not sure what other damage to look for except for damage to welds, which also looked fine, I don't know for sure.

The owner of the marina obviously could care less, he walked away after the incident as if nothing happened. This marina is one of few that takes pontoons in my area, Tampa Bay Florida. I know it's crazy after how the owner handled the situation, but I want to keep the boat there for now until something else opens up, which means I don’t want to get into any arguments with him unless necessary. I'm a weekend boater and basically solo since my wife is handling 3 small kids when we're out. Public boat ramps aren't an option, been there done that.

I’m going to point out the dent on the toon to the owner, and tell him that so long as everything else is in working order then what's done is done and I’m letting it go, but if there’s any structural issues then he'll need to do the right thing and cover cost of repairs.

So besides obvious cosmetic damage, what other possible damage could have occurred that would be hard to see? Appreciate your thoughts!

SeaSteamer
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
13,446
It should have been Documented, photographed at the time of the Incident, with the Forklift and Operator in the pics. Delays doing so only hinder your case. Also were there any Independent Witnesses?
 

captmello

Captain
Joined
Jun 30, 2008
Messages
3,845
I would have the poons pressure tested, at the marinas expense. if he refuses, I'd do it myself. only need 2 psi to find a leak.
 

gpfishingdude

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
538
I would have the poons pressure tested, at the marinas expense. if he refuses, I'd do it myself. only need 2 psi to find a leak.
Do you do that off of a dock so you can see the bubbles. Do you snorkle around and under the boat to look for bubbles? I hear a lot of people talking about shooting 2 PSI into the toons but I've never seen it done. Do you hire a diver to look for leaks while you hook up the air compresser? Or are you just giving the same advice that you read somewhere?
 

gpfishingdude

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
538
Sorry to hear that your boat got dented most of the time when I run into the corner of the docks everybody worries about damage to the dock.
I guess that they don't make these new boats the way they did ones like mine from the mid- late 90s.
We don't have the luxury of having somebody else put our boats in the water and take them out around here. I've got one of those old bunk trailers and the upright guide posts have been hit so many times that I worry that one will fall off every time I skid the boat onto the trailer crooked.
If I wasn't so old I would get a better, used trailler but I'm betting that the piece of junk I've got will outlast me.
Good luck to you and I hope that your new boat don't fall apart.
 

undercover500

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 21, 2022
Messages
42
I don't typically get fired up about much anymore, and it sounds like you're fairly similar. That said, there is a point where enough is enough. The fact is, the marina damaged your boat. Doesn't matter how old the boat was, or what condition it was in, they damaged it. Since the owner doesn't seem to care, I would go through insurance. Do you have insurance on the boat? I would contact them and have them go after the marina. That's what you're paying them for. I would also make sure you have all documentation of this incident ready.

There is a time to play nice, and a time not to play nice. My time to stop playing nice is after I have tried to have it made right. I understand this marina is one of your only options, but do you really want to keep your boat somewhere where they obviously don't care about damage THEY caused IN FRONT of you?

If it were me, I would tell the owner I want this boat fixed, on your dime, at the dealer of my choice, or I'm taking this through my insurance and you'll be hearing from them. In reality, he should be bending over backwards to fix your property that he damaged, but it may be time to get nasty.
 

captmello

Captain
Joined
Jun 30, 2008
Messages
3,845
Do you do that off of a dock so you can see the bubbles. Do you snorkle around and under the boat to look for bubbles? I hear a lot of people talking about shooting 2 PSI into the toons but I've never seen it done. Do you hire a diver to look for leaks while you hook up the air compresser? Or are you just giving the same advice that you read somewhere?
I did it in my driveway. I could hear the air leaking. if it doesn't leak, it will hold the pressure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top