feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Status
Not open for further replies.

big ken

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
200
ive been trying to ke this 800.00 boat that has already snowballed to 3400.00 to a minimum but now needs outdrive work. think im going to buy this outdrive se160 with 3yr warranty from iboat. anyone use these before? any luck? please let me know thanks ken
 
Last edited:

Fishermark

Vice Admiral
Joined
Oct 19, 2003
Messages
5,617
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

I've had one on my boat for probably 4 years now. No mechanical problems at all - the finish was not the best, but I understand they have improved that.
 

bigbroncoxlt

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Aug 1, 2008
Messages
39
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

I kept hearing alot of mixed reviews so I went with a used alpha 1 from a local boat shop. That way if I have any problems the parts are easy to get and the local shop knows the boat. Good luck whichever road you choose. Boatin aint cheap.
 

TilliamWe

Banned
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
6,579
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

$1195 for a BRAND NEW drive with a 3 year warranty that includes neglect, abuse, lack of maintenance, and collision? What more is there to ask?
I have never heard anyone say anything bad about them, let alone "mixed" reviews. fishermarks comment on the paint was the first "negative" I've ever heard.
 

JustJason

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 27, 2007
Messages
5,320
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

the paint does suck.... and if you've ever opened one up... they have a bazillion shims to get the gear backlash correct.... because the castings are inferior to merc
That being said. They do warrant the drives for 3 years..... 3 years for 12 hundred bucks... what more can you ask?
Here's my rule of thumb when I'm pitching a job. If you have a boat that's clearly worth less than 10 grand... go with the SEI, it's a no brainer.
If your boat is worth right around 10 grand.... you may want to consider having your merc alpha fixed... as a chineese drive may affect resale value. If your boat is worth more than 10G.... fix your alpha the right way.
 

TilliamWe

Banned
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
6,579
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

You know those drive are built in Florida right? Calling them "Chinese" is not a correct statement. They have some foreign sourced parts on/in them, but I'll bet you a quarter so does Mercruiser.
How do you think local yokel repair shops set the backlash on their gears?
 

JustJason

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 27, 2007
Messages
5,320
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

hmmmmmm Sterndrive engineering is in florida (i've been to the shop)
But all the drives are cast and assembled in china.
How do you think they make them so cheap. No EPA regs on the castings.
 

TilliamWe

Banned
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
6,579
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Again, Sterndrive Engineering states on their website:

"By directly contracting with manufacturers to produce parts, such as cases, gears and shafts, and then assembling them at their factory in Oldsmar, Florida, Sterndrive Engineering is able to offer replacement drives at a fraction of the previous market prices. These costs savings are then passed along to the customer."

And they do disclose this:
"Using the most advanced technology and materials is critical. While Sterndrive Engineering's gears are made in Asia, the 4820 steel alloy used a rather unique alloy. There are Japanese alloys that are similar, but none of them have the hardness and durability features that are needed for our gears." Sterndrive Engineering's gears are also shot peened and cryogenically treated. Both of these technologies add significantly to the life of the gears. "As far as we know, we are the only company cryogenically treating sterndrive gears." says Pickren.
 
Joined
Jun 23, 2004
Messages
7
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Thanks for your interest in our company. Here are some facts:

1) Our new factory is in Oldsmar, Florida and it is more than a warehouse. There is both assembly and light manufacturing. We moved into this new 17,500 square foot facility earlier this year. Capt Jason, have you been to our new factory? If not, you are of course welcome to come visit.

2) We shim our cases just like other lower unit/sterndrive manufacturers. We do not need or use excessive amounts of shims.

3) The raw cases/housings are not made at our Florida factory, but they are also not made in China. We designed and own all of the tooling for both the casting and CNC machining operations of the cases. The production is contracted out to a company that specializes in aluminum castings.

4) Our painting process is dramatically better than we when we started 5 years ago.

5) We also want to point out that we now offer outboard lower units that replace Mercury, Yamaha, and OMC. The sizes now available fit/replace most applications 150 hp and up.

6) Our three year no fault warranty is the best. It covers any failure that requires the drive to be replaced including user abuse and neglect such as running out of oil or dragging the drive up the launch.

7) Our low prices are the result of removing several layers of middleman that are typical in the marine business, our very low overhead organizational structure, and our strategy of selling more drives at a smaller margin rather than the other way around.

8) IBoats.com is an authorized dealer of Sterndrive Engineering (SEI) and our drives can be bought right here on this site.

If anyone has any other questions about SEI, please post them right here and we will do our best to answer them.
 

Lou C

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 10, 2002
Messages
12,671
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

If you are making lowers for OMC outboards (if they are the larger V-6 cases) it wouldn't be that much harder, to do the upper gear housing for a Cobra as well, come on and help us Cobra guys out!
Sierra just announced they are making a Cobra upper unit, in additon to the lower units they already sell.
The more sources the better!
 

big ken

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
200
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Thanks for your interest in our company. Here are some facts:

1) Our new factory is in Oldsmar, Florida and it is more than a warehouse. There is both assembly and light manufacturing. We moved into this new 17,500 square foot facility earlier this year. Capt Jason, have you been to our new factory? If not, you are of course welcome to come visit.

2) We shim our cases just like other lower unit/sterndrive manufacturers. We do not need or use excessive amounts of shims.

3) The raw cases/housings are not made at our Florida factory, but they are also not made in China. We designed and own all of the tooling for both the casting and CNC machining operations of the cases. The production is contracted out to a company that specializes in aluminum castings.

4) Our painting process is dramatically better than we when we started 5 years ago.

5) We also want to point out that we now offer outboard lower units that replace Mercury, Yamaha, and OMC. The sizes now available fit/replace most applications 150 hp and up.

6) Our three year no fault warranty is the best. It covers any failure that requires the drive to be replaced including user abuse and neglect such as running out of oil or dragging the drive up the launch.

7) Our low prices are the result of removing several layers of middleman that are typical in the marine business, our very low overhead organizational structure, and our strategy of selling more drives at a smaller margin rather than the other way around.

8) IBoats.com is an authorized dealer of Sterndrive Engineering (SEI) and our drives can be bought right here on this site.

If anyone has any other questions about SEI, please post them right here and we will do our best to answer them.
i would like to buy directly from SEI and elimiminate the middle man, but that is not possible is it?
 

ziggy

Admiral
Joined
Jun 30, 2004
Messages
7,473
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

and elimiminate the middle man
well, i'm as broke as the next guy and surely do understand your motivation. but.........my feeling is....
for all the help and support i've gotten from this forum, for free. i think, myself, i'd order through iboats.... they deserve a cut too....

i do this at my local dealer too. i know his prices are higher than the next guys. but man, i get to go talk to their mechanics. i'm known by name by all the staff, i know many of their names too. i've gained access to oem mercruiser specialty tools from them too, w/o charge. in short, they help me a lot.... you get the idea.. same is true here at iboats i think..... what comes around, goes around...
 
Last edited:

TilliamWe

Banned
Joined
Dec 21, 2004
Messages
6,579
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Actually the price to buy direct from SEI is the same as to buy through iboats.
 

mylesm260

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 13, 2007
Messages
444
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Think one of these would hold up to 400 HP better than a plane jane Alpha 1 gen 1?
 

JustJason

Vice Admiral
Joined
Aug 27, 2007
Messages
5,320
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Sterndrive Engineering said:
Thanks for your interest in our company. Here are some facts:

1) Our new factory is in Oldsmar, Florida and it is more than a warehouse. There is both assembly and light manufacturing. We moved into this new 17,500 square foot facility earlier this year. Capt Jason, have you been to our new factory? If not, you are of course welcome to come visit.

2) We shim our cases just like other lower unit/sterndrive manufacturers. We do not need or use excessive amounts of shims.

3) The raw cases/housings are not made at our Florida factory, but they are also not made in China. We designed and own all of the tooling for both the casting and CNC machining operations of the cases. The production is contracted out to a company that specializes in aluminum castings.

4) Our painting process is dramatically better than we when we started 5 years ago.

5) We also want to point out that we now offer outboard lower units that replace Mercury, Yamaha, and OMC. The sizes now available fit/replace most applications 150 hp and up.

6) Our three year no fault warranty is the best. It covers any failure that requires the drive to be replaced including user abuse and neglect such as running out of oil or dragging the drive up the launch.

7) Our low prices are the result of removing several layers of middleman that are typical in the marine business, our very low overhead organizational structure, and our strategy of selling more drives at a smaller margin rather than the other way around.

8) IBoats.com is an authorized dealer of Sterndrive Engineering (SEI) and our drives can be bought right here on this site.

If anyone has any other questions about SEI, please post them right here and we will do our best to answer them.

1. No I have not been to the new one, I went to the old one years ago. It was either Clearwater or Tampa... I forget which. At that location you didn't have much for drives there as you were just starting to build them. Really nothing but a bunch of mexicans (I hope documented!) rebuilding Rotax/SeaDoo engine.

2. I dunno who your trying to kid on this one. But i've pulled apart a few for reseal jobs. Some aren't bad, on some... i've litterally seen anyplace from 1/16th to 3/8ths of an inch of shims sitting there behind foward gear. In the end... if the backlash is correct, if rolling torque is correct on loaded bearings... and if it's sealed.... then who cares right? I'm just saying.

3. If you wouldn't mind then (i hope its not some insider industry secret!!). Then would you kindly tell us where they are made? You said that they are not made in florida, and not made in china, but you neglected to tell us where they are made. Can/will you tell the Iboats community where the housings are cast, and machined, and assembled? And where the internals are made? As of right now... the general consensus is China.

4. It's getting better..... not as good as merc... but definitely better than the drives 5 years ago. What are you guys using for primer?

5. Thats fantastic!!! It is always a good thing if a customer has options.

6. Thats a no brainer as well. Your warranty is the best. Now only if these things weren't so darn expensive to ship! (at the customers expense of removal of the drive, shipping charges, and reinstallation) Have you guys thought about contracting with local shops to have them warrantied at the shop? (no shipping costs and faster service to the customer)

7. Yes and no. Cost to dealer on an alpha 1 gen 2 (i'm gonna spill it here!!!) starts at about 3700 bucks. For a brand new one. They can go up a few bucks depending on the commanality of gearing. The warehouses get their cut, but cost to dealer is primarily fixed by merc. There's not alot of middlemen.... If i order an A1G2 from merc it's 3700 bucks... it doesn't matter if it comes from the warehosue or from fon du lac.... its the same. (say maybe a few bucks on shipping).
On a side note... i think you guys price fix a bit. Your drives always seem to be the same price no matter where you buy them. Give or take 50 bucks.

8. Yep they can be purchased right here through Iboats. And in case anybody else is wondering... you can call SEI directly (phone ## on their website) and order 1 from there.


Listen SEI.... you guys do deliver a GOOD product at a FANTASTIC price. But it's no genuine Merc. So lets just be realistic about it all. Merc's casting alloy (beer cans) is better than yours, Mercs machine work is better than yours, and Mercs paint is better than yours.
That being said...... If your drive can push the boat through the water and last for at least 3 years for 1200 bucks. That's a win win for everyone. Sometimes I have to bore out the stud mounting holes... but I'm not loseing sleep over it. And on some i've seen.... you do have a bazillion shims... but who cares as long as it works.
All and all.... SEI. If i've got a customer with a cheap boat... your product is a no brainer. If i've got a customer with a 40K boat... i'm not going to insult him by suggesting chineese (untill you specify otherwise) drives. Your product fits a niche quite well. But you guys aren't the best thing since sliced bread.
I do wish you guys many years of sucessfull business... and continued product improvement.
Best...
Jason




To myles and howard..... Alphas are rated at 300hp peak. If you fart around with anything more than 300 (especially in a heavy boat) your taking your chances. If you 2 are really dreaming about your 400HP monster..... get a Bravo.
 

big ken

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
200
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

well, i'm as broke as the next guy and surely do understand your motivation. but.........my feeling is....
for all the help and support i've gotten from this forum, for free. i think, myself, i'd order through iboats.... they deserve a cut too....

i do this at my local dealer too. i know his prices are higher than the next guys. but man, i get to go talk to their mechanics. i'm known by name by all the staff, i know many of their names too. i've gained access to oem mercruiser specialty tools from them too, w/o charge. in short, they help me a lot.... you get the idea.. same is true here at iboats i think..... what comes around, goes around...

wasnt about the money! more about the warranty. never liked having a third party
 

asdasc

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 28, 2008
Messages
680
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

I welcome these guys in the marketplace.

Let's face it, to buy a drive for 1/3 the cost I wouldn't expect it to be identical to the original, it doesn't need to be. If it works well enough to get my boat back in the water, I will save the 2/3 and perhaps buy another in 5 years.

Any company has to start somewhere, and if they improve a little each year, which they will and have shown to, they will have a 1st rate product, if they don't already, and you are covered under warrentee.

By the way, I don't buy from China where I have options, but that is a political statement, not an indication of the the quality. We have given them so much free Intellectual Property and manufacturing capability, anything they are making that isn't 1st class quality, soon will be. It just takes time, and very little of it, in the big picture.

Go SE!! Now, for a complete Cobra Sterndrive, let me be your beta tester of prototypes. I will give you tons of feedback!
 

billder62

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Nov 13, 2007
Messages
33
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

Yes , I have been running an sei drive four years now , 460 hrs , and yes its not a mercruiser , actually it has been better than the merc has ever been . shifting is quieter , and operation is quieter ,and after the 10 hr oil change it has been great. Sei has the the solution to replacement drives hands down ...
 

asdasc

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Aug 28, 2008
Messages
680
Re: feedback on aftermarket SE106 sterndrives

I was a little sad, I went to their website, and the only OMC lower units they have are for outboards.

Right now, OMC powered boats are depreciating rapidly due to the lack of replacement parts. SEI could really help us out. I think there is a lot of demand, and a bunch of boats that are getting parted out before they are due, mostly because they aren't worth the high cost of repairs if you have to machine something.

Just curious, how do they get around all the patents?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top